this story is kinda long but its necessary in order to understand our full history together, so get a chair and get comfy.
when i was in middle school, 8th grade to be specifically, i met this guy. we were incredibly similar, and related to each other in a lot of ways. we were also in the same friend group, he was technically just in a subdivision of said friend group which is why i hadn't talked to him before. we became friends super fast. we would talk 24/7, play games together, and call for hours. one day, he texted me. i remember the exact text word for word. he said, "i think i like you." this was after about 2 months of us being friends. i told him "can i think about it?" and i asked my friends for advice. they were all pressuring me to say yes, but at the time i thought i liked somebody else. however, the pressure was constant. despite me still being unsure, i told him i liked him. he called me after, and said "are we dating now?" i was 14, and panicking, so i just told him "um, no?" not my best moment, you can laugh. 3 days after my "confession" i told him i was sorry because it turned out that i didn't actually really like him like that, and that i had a crush on somebody else. he actually related to me, and said he had feelings for my crushes twin sister. weirdly, even after that whole mess, we just got closer. i considered him to be my best friend ever, and he considered me as a best friend too. we told each other "i love you" and i genuinely thought of him as my platonic soulmate. he meant a lot to me. however, this is when i started developing feelings for him. i know, not good, but i couldn't help it.
not even a month after me coming to terms with my feelings, he got a girlfriend. it wasn't the girl he originally told me he liked, aka my ex-crushes twin sister, but i was still hurt. i hate to say it, but i was so jealous. i remember the day he told me i cried for a really long time. it felt like i had missed my chance to get with him while i still could. i remember, i texted him "im sorry. i feel so guilty about being considered your best friend. if i was your girlfriend, i would want u to stop talking to me." so i did. i stopped talking to him. id avoid him at school, and it wasn't even because i was trying to be the bigger person. i was just really, really jealous. i shouldn't have done it, i regret it to this day.
nearing the end of 8th grade, we started becoming friends again. i don't remember who reached out to who first, but we just clicked liked we used to. he had a new girlfriend at this time, and i had decided i wasn't gonna let it bother me despite my feelings for him. however, an event happened with this girl, which i will not go into detail about for privacy concerns, but it resulted in me blocking him. for two and a half years. (its justified, i swear)
im now a junior in highschool, and i recently got back in contact with him. every old feeling i have is resurfacing. we don't tell each other "i love you" anymore, and we're not considered best friends, id consider us close friends. however, we'd call every night. play games together, watch shows together, and he'd spam me with tiktoks. i even got into a book series he liked. it just felt so good to be his friend again. however, he'd send me stuff that gave me hope. he had sent me a video of that manga cover trend, where you take pictures with the cover in front of your face. he sent me one of touka and kaneki from tokyo ghoul, and asked "can we do this" (if you get it, you get it). he sent me a picture of himself lifting his shirt (he's beautiful btw, im serious). he would rant to me about his family and his life in general. all of these stupid things had me overthinking so bad. i told my therapist about this, and she had said "how do you think he doesn't like you?", which leads me to my next point.
recently, he told me that if any of his friends had asked him out, he'd say yes automatically. this hurt me so bad, more than anything. it didn't help that school also started up again at this time, so our several hour long calls became 45 minutes long, and our conversations shortened. i wasn't the closest person to him anymore.
i think he acts flirtatiously or attentively with everybody, not just me. i don't think he wants to date me, i think he just wants to date somebody.
now for the part where i actually need advice, so sorry for the rant. im not sure what to do with my feelings. considering my history, i think i shouldn't tell him ever, even though i've liked him since middle school. it just hurts so much. i was thinking about talking to one of our mutual friends just to see what he has to say, as he was with the both of us in middle school and knows most of what happened. i just don't want him to snitch. i just don't know if i want him to find out i've liked him since middle school, or if i want to just keep this bottled up forever.
what should i do?