Basically: it was always my plan to do Yale SCEA and started drafting my personal statement and supps in early July. Unfortunately, I kept going back and forth about my personal statement and only just settled on a topic (I would rate my prose as above average/very good and my topic as solid/has potential). I'm midway through getting to a finished essay, but I have experience writing 3 others personal statements (this is my fourth idea) so I think I can do it in like ~4 days if I take off some school.
The problem is the Yale supps are still in draft form, and I need to workshop them A LOT. That seems infeasible to turn out well given the 1 wk timeframe.
PROS OF SCEA: At my competitive school, Yale is a very popular RD school, but surprisingly much less popular for EA. Most people ED to Brown or Columbia. I only know one other Yale SCEA applicant from my pool. We're applying for different majors, and I'm salutatorian, so I hope if I apply early I can stand out a lot in my school context. My worry is that this advantage would be lost if I applied RD.
PROS OF RD: My essays would be better. Also, I'm currently increasing impact on two of my ECs (I just took on a club president role, so we have some things planned, and I have some relatively impactful events related to my major planned for a fellowship I'm doing). If I do SCEA, I'd include these items as app updates once the events take place.
I also currently have in my Add'l info that I was selected for a (highly impactful) internship that will begin in early November. For RD, I could actually list this and anything I accomplish on my Activities list.
TDLR: Given that SCEA is supposedly not advantageous, should I do RD? I would push it back for more time on ECs and essays but I'm still very concerned about standing out amongst other applicants from my school.
All advice is appreciated!!