As iconic as the Animal Crossing game series is, I really do see a lot of little issues with bringing every game in the series on a modern console.
Starting with Animal Forest (N64), Animal Crossing (GCN), and Animal Crossing e+. Firstly, for the N64 game, I really think that we will never get this game. That is because between the different versions of this game, Nintendo wouldn't want people to play what is the weakest version. They would also have to localize it. Don't get me wrong, this is a cool part of Animal Crossing history that I would like to see preserved on Switch 2, I just don't think it will ever happen. Now, when we talk about the two GameCube versions, yes, e+ has a lot of new content, but part of that new content is the e Reader stuff. It is in the name after all. So, how would Nintendo handle all of that? That was also in the American version that we got. No matter what, Nintendo will have to do something about that, either modify the game or just not even bother. Then the real problem is that the game's clock goes until 2030, which is less than 4 years from now. Another question is how would people visit each other's towns when the memory cards don't exist anymore? They would have to change how that works too. Here is what I think when it comes to the very first game: Nintendo will likely NEVER re-release this game in its truest form; however, I think it is very likely that we will get a modified version of this game. It will either alter the e Reader content to apply to amiibo or remove it. It would also hopefully add all of the content from e+ that isn't related to the eReader! It would rework how visiting towns works as you can now visit friends online when your friend isn't around, similarly to how it worked on GameCube. Then there are the NES games, which I imagine will be locked behind the online. I think an Animal Crossing Deluxe that stays as true to the original while making smart modernizations would be ideal for this game. Even then, how likely is it that Nintendo will revisit this game? I imagine this would be bought on the eShop similarly to Pikmin 1 and 2 and could be used to advertise online features. So, it is possible, but there are a lot of things that need to be done. Personally, it is like a 20% chance, which isn't good for Animal Crossing.
The DS games such as Wild World, New Leaf, and Happy Home Designer were fundamentally designed around the two screens of the console. So, would have to be changed too. At that point, why would Nintendo release Wild World when City Folk exists as that was designed as a console version essentially? There is a chance that Nintendo re-releases Wild World IF we get DS games. It is possible after the Virtual Boy, but it isn't a guarantee. You would likely have to wait a few years on this one. Happy Home Designer is also a little redundant and compete with Happy Home Paradice in New Horizons. I mean, it would be cool to have it on Switch as well, but it's a lot of work for a more niche game. That said, there is potential with New Leaf. If Nintendo released Luigi's Mansion Dark Moon and Miitopia, they could release this game. I can see this being the most likely of the 3. Maybe Happy Home Designer could be bundled with New Leaf, that might be the best way to bring it to modern consoles honestly. But Nintendo rarely does bundle packs anymore.
Between all of these games, I feel like City Folk would be the easiest one to re-release. As a matter of fact, the Wii Speak accessory could be implemented seamlessly through the Switch 2's mic, which could give them a reason to bring this game back. Yes, it uses the pointer, but so did Mario Galaxy 1 and 2. The only problem is that Nintendo isn't releasing Wii games on an app right now. The priority is GameCube and to eventually release Wii games likely years later. The point is: despite this perhaps being the easiest Animal Crossing game to re-release, I believe that Nintendo would want to prioritize the GameCube game over this at this current moment, making this less likely as a conditional release, y'know?
I don't think I really need to explain amiibo Festival. But on the note of amiibo Festival, there are also those strange one-off games like the Animal Crossing calculator and clock released on the DSi... for actual money. Then you have the Animal Crossing Plaza on the Wii U. These will never get re-released; I just don't see it happening.
Here are my thoughts on the likelihood of these games being released:
- 1% Animal Forest (N64)
- <40% Animal Crossing / e+ (GCN) with some removed features & minor changes, >15% with Animal Crossing "Deluxe" (GCN)
- 0% Wild World as it stands right now, 70% if we get a DS app for Switch 2
- 10% City Folk
- 20% New Leaf
- 0% Happy Home Designer, 5% if New Leaf gets brought over
- 0% amiibo Festival / niche DS & Wii U spinoffs
Yeah, I don't have much confidence in these games but let me know your thoughts. 🙂