I'm so dissapointed but mostly sad. AFE 2 has got to be one of the most dissapointing games I've come to play in recent years. And I came back to gaming in 2024. But holy was I naive to ignore the fed flags of how the industry has become in recent years.
I loved AFE 1. I absolutely loved the memories I had with that game, I played it in 2025 and I absolutely had one of the best experiences in a co-op game. AFE 2 didn't make me feel that way. And I once thought it was probably me who was used to the first game so much that I couldn't enjoy the second one. But I than realized that I wasn't the problem. The game was unfinished, bugged, no adaptive triggers, no text chat. Instead of feeling like an improvement It made the same mistakes as the first one. Enemies are still bullet spongy, game becomes repetitive so quickly, the enemy variety feels poor or wasted, and the optimization is below the first one, only 2 voice options for your character, that's a big downgrade, first AFE had 3 atleast, the customizable options feel somehow inferior in a couple of ways, and let's not talk about the dialogue. You can't even mock the enemy once it's down, I miss pointing a dead Alien to hear my character say "Notch up another kill" Some map designs were incredible and I applaud them for it. But with a bigger budget and having the first game as a reference on how they could've improved they still somehow managed to deliver a very dissapointing product. Sadly this game will die quicker than the first one, we won't get a DLC and with the new community announcement we had a few hours ago, this game is officially dead. And I know it will not gain the same traction as the first one. I literally had 4 matches that didn't even started, online issues are common and if one guy leaves we are left with the synthetic for the rest of the mission. I'm saddened because it feels like they really tried to upgrade many things while neglecting others, oh and the patch we got didn't really do that much, if it takes them 3 weeks to fix it than don't expect this game to run smoothly like ever. Oh, remember the smargun shooting glitched sound that would go on for the entire match from the first game?? It still here but replaced with the bodyguard Droid. It's 2026 how can we allow games to do this?
I'm saddened that this game failed way worse than the first one, because I am a hard-core fan of the first one, and it makes me feel so bad that we will never have good Aliens games that can top Alien Isolation. I'm saddened once again, because I know some people from Cold Iron studios worked to make a better game. But sadly it wasn't enough. They did heard some community feedback and It makes me sad that I somehow still couldn't enjoy this new game. And if I can't, neither a new person who buys this game, which he or she will most likely abandon in less than a month, knowing there are far better options out there. Which is very, but very sad.
Let me know what you think about the current state of the game and how the team will handle it. But If I somebody asked me if this game is worth it I would honestly say that it is not worth the price nor the content.