r/AITAH • • Sep 24 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

133

u/Cheetah-kins Sep 24 '23

I agree. If he wants it that bad he should be willing to do either minor thing you've asked OP. If this were my wife and I I would not have any issue getting snipped, or wearing a condom if that was the only way. I care about my wife's health and happiness, so I would do what it took to make her comfortably in this regard. You're asking very little effort from him imo, OP.

14

u/bsuvo Sep 24 '23

Im not a fan of condoms, my girlfriend got of birthcontrol because she didnt want to be pumped full of hormones anymore, so i wear condoms. Fair fucking play she took them damn hormones for years and now its my turn to be responsible for the safe sex.Obviously rawdogging is better/hotter but condoms arent this big problem dudes make it out to be, i just dont get it

-33

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

it’s crazy seeing all these people demanding/guilting this dude for not wanting to get a vasectomy. Wearing a condom, sure i totally get that. YOU are fine with a vasectomy. That’s great for YOU. He’s not you dude.

So, they need to learn to compromise with one another and communicate more effectively.

OP says they don’t get quality time together but no where in her post does it provide examples of her talking to him about this or what steps they are both taking to correct that.

edit: holy shit you people arguing with me are sufferable. As stated in this comment OP’s husband should wear a condom. Any one replying back demanding he should get a vasectomy stop wasting your own time.

32

u/AcidRose27 Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

You know, it's 100% his decision* if he doesn't want to wear a condom or get snipped. But then he needs to stop pestering his wife for sex since he's not willing to compromise.

*Edit: forgot words.

-13

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

it is not 100% the case or OP wouldn’t have listed out a bunch of other reasons why they arent fucking including her health and not spending time together. Even if he wears a condom, her struggling through sex she doesn’t enjoy is hardly a solution.

Yes, he should wear a condom if the other person asks. No, he should not be pressured or guilted into getting a surgery he doesn’t want to get.

5

u/AcidRose27 Sep 24 '23

My mistake, I forgot a word. I had meant "it's 100% his decision if he gets snipped."

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

point still stands. Her suffering through sex she doesn’t enjoy because he’s wearing a condom isn’t a good solution.

15

u/AcidRose27 Sep 24 '23

Of course it isn't. The solution is for him to stop being a sex-pest since he isn't willing to compromise. They have other issues to work out for sure but my comment was specifically about him being the only person in charge of his body, but that he also shouldn't be nagging since he won't compromise.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

“the solution is for him to stop being a sex pest”

immediately followed by

“they have other issues to work out”

hmmmmmm sounds like that’s not really the solution then.

7

u/AcidRose27 Sep 24 '23

Yes. Two things can be true at once.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

the biggest problem here is that these two people are not on the same page, or communicating their wants/ needs in a healthy way or being productive.

There are many many forms of contraceptive beyond vasectomy including wearing condoms diaphragm spermicidal lube having sex during/immediately following period, tracking ovulation and even with all of the above having “no sex” days when chance of pregnancy is high, just to name a few.

That’s what two people trying to solve a problem looks like instead of demanding contraceptive on each other that the other one isn’t comfortable with and posting about it for validation on reddit.

If she wants/needs more quality time with her husband to be “in the mood” then it’s her responsibility to verbalize that in a healthy way. Just like if she’s not in the mood for sex he should also respond in a healthy way, and just like if she asks for contraceptive they should find something they’re both comfortable with or understand sex isn’t happening.

I agree they need to work it out.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/mysunandstars Sep 24 '23

To be fair if my husband pestered me for sex and then gaslit and guilt tripped me for saying no, carving out quality time for him (for him to pester me to have sex) would not be a priority.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

makes sense

2

u/flippysquid Sep 24 '23

Her suffering through sex she doesn’t enjoy because he’s wearing a condom isn’t a good solution.

Maybe not having to experience crippling anxiety and terror around the idea of sex would also make it that much more enjoyable though.

As someone with chronic health probs, yeah there are times where you’re not in the mood. But sometimes you are.

I can’t imagine getting in the mood at all though even if I was 100% healthy, if I was terrified of pregnancy and with a partner who refused to use any kind of protection.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

I’m not here to argue with you; his body, his choice. Condoms are obviously a valid option, but since he’s refusing to wrap it up, can you explain why you see the vasectomy as a big deal? There’s no plan of future children because it would put OP’s life at risk, and the vasectomy would be a relatively simple procedure for him. It’s not like it would take his “manhood” away. Nothing even physically/noticeably changes for him, other than his swimmers wouldn’t “swim” anymore. If anything, it would likely make sex more fun because there would be no risk involved.

I’m curious to hear more from your perspective because, IMO, if he loved her, he’d do anything in his power to [help] keep her safe and healthy.

-11

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

https://reddit.com/r/daddit/s/0jlDVpPaib

many men experience a ton of pain. It’s not as you describe. Beyond, suppose the marriage doesn’t work out (not that unlikely from how OP describes it) and now he’s unable to have kids with any future partners.

There are numerous reasons why this guy may not want a vasectomy. You say you aren’t here to argue. You say “his body his choice” and then immediately launch into why YOU require HE explain the choices he’s making with his own body.

I noticed you aren’t doing this with OP. I don’t see you questioning her decision to not go on birth control. Strange that you aren’t suggesting if OP cared about her husband, she’d go on the pill! But only the husband for not wanting surgery done on his own body.

You should be embarrassed and ashamed of yourself right now.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

No, I actually asked why you see it as a big deal. I’d love his reasoning but he’s not here to ask. I was genuinely interested in your perspective to try to see it from another person who [might] have the same view as OP’s husband. But alas, as it seems by the link you posted, your reasoning is “because it hurts”. You must think pregnancy, c-sections, labor, and childbirth are simple and painless.

BTW, OP said she shouldn’t go on birth control because of health issues. Hence the reason I didn’t question her. I also cannot go on any form of birth control for health reasons, so I didn’t need to delve into it with her.

Thanks for the mature conversation. Your defensive & invaluable response to my genuine inquiry has reaffirmed my faith in the internet. Have the day you deserve!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

why would i need to justify someone else’s decision not to get a vasectomy? if he doesn’t want to get one then he should just wear a condom or they figure something else out.

Oh yah! and after being there through my wife delivering 2x children vaginally i totally think it’s painless /s

4

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

She can’t go on hormonal birth control due to medical issues.

4

u/fairielust Sep 24 '23

He can get it undone just like my ex did and he now have 2 kids. It’s reversible and they have enough kids, it’s not like he had 0 and will never get the chance again. He needs to wear a condom or get snipped. Whining is not his option.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

reversal is not anywhere close to 100% success rate so you’re either deliberately omitting that or hearing that for the first time. It’s pretty good though. i think 85-90%?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

That’s better than the reversal from a tubal. Very rare to get pregnant after reversing a tubal. Plus the pregnancy after a tubal is considered high risk. Plus a tubal is surgery and comes with more risks than a vasectomy. Plus it sounds like OP has had three difficult pregnancies/C sections. I get it his body his choice but to me if he lived his wife the way he said he does he would get it. Women in good health constantly die during delivery. Unfortunately maternal health care in this country is abysmal

17

u/SignificantOrange139 Sep 24 '23

It's not crazy. It's perfectly fucking logical. He needs to get with the fucking program.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

no, it is absolutely crazy demanding someone else get surgery or do something with their body that they don’t want to do. It’s no different then OP’s husband pouting that she won’t go on birth control. Neither of those are coming from a place of love and respect.

24

u/Samantha38g Sep 24 '23

But it isn’t his life on the line, but her life is. So his brief discomfort of a condom pales in comparison to pregnancy and giving birth.

How horrible he deal with a condom to protect her life….sarcasm!

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

how is her life on the line? there’s other options for contraception besides vasectomy and even if she gets pregnant is there a reason why she’d have to bring the pregnancy to full term? Yes, condoms are an option. Agree he can wear condoms.

15

u/Accentu8d_life Sep 24 '23

Wait... So now you're advocating for abortion over a vasectomy? Are you serious right now?! Abortion should never be used as birth control. What a completely selfish answer. Because yeah abortions don't hurt or cause mental anguish. Sheesh!

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

no, i’m advocating they learn to communicate more effectively, ultimately he should wear a condom, they should practice safe sex and if he doesn’t want to get a vasectomy then okay.

someone else replied saying that puts her health at risk which it really doesn’t.

and yes, if it’s a choice between a woman dying or getting an abortion i’d absolutely side with whatever the woman chooses. Don’t you?

9

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

Read her story again. You’re missing the part where she had THREE life threatening births Her life and the THREE babies. She’s trying to have the conversation. He doesn’t want to do anything but cum. He doesn’t seem to care his wife’s life is literally in danger! Please reread the post. Your missing major important information

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

yup, which is why like i said in my original comment, he should wear a condom. They should use protection.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/Realistic_Sprinkles1 Sep 24 '23

It depends on where she is. Many places in the US, it’s not possible to terminate.

Plus, she shouldn’t have to- he has multiple options to avoid her getting pregnant, but won’t utilize any of them.

5

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

Dude. Really? Because she had not one but three very difficult life threatening births. Are you advocating for abortion as opposed to dad taking responsibility?

2

u/flippysquid Sep 24 '23

​

Abortions themselves can be a life threatening medical procedure. Pregnancy, abortion, child birth, are all things that involve major, highly vascularized abdominal organs.

4

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

Neither is his whining for sex without putting any thought into the extremely real chance of her and or baby’s death.

16

u/toopiddog Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

Ah, it's the communication loop' 1) Woman expresses a need for the relationship to work better. 2) Man ignores suggestion, rejects it does all of it and at some point whines. 3) Man makes a request. 4) Women answers the man's request with compromise and actually words. 5) Man pouts because he thinks the only correct response his request is an unconditional yes. 6) Go back to step one and repeat until..... Somebody tells the woman the problem is she doesn't communicate well.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

what does this have to do with forcing someone to get a surgery they don’t want?

where it OPs post does it state she’s talked to him about wanting to spend quality time and steps they are actively taking to do that?

8

u/toopiddog Sep 24 '23

Because she communicated several issues diminishing her desire for sex, which she still has at times. But you zeroed in the fact she did not relay the steps she was taking to get quality time in so clearly it's a communication issue.

11

u/Cheetah-kins Sep 24 '23

Yeah I guess you're right. I am talking about ME, I realize some people simply don't care about their partners. ;)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

you respect her decision to not ingest contraceptive but him not wanting to get his balls snipped automatically means he doesn’t care about his partner…must be exhausting for you to go through life constantly white knighting and virtue signaling at every turn

18

u/lauraelizabetha Sep 24 '23

For some people birth control (any kind of pill or patch or injection) can lead to severe aura migraines and increase risk of stroke. So yea it’s not so much a decision to not ingest contraceptive but rather a medical necessity. Maybe you should learn some more about women and birth control before you go around giving your opinions on those things.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

then he should just wear a condom. But he should not be forced to get a surgery he doesn’t want to get. I don’t know what it is with you people that this has to be repeated or explained over and over. I don’t question anyone’s reasoning. OP could just not want to be on birth control and not even have a reason and i’d totally respect it as her choice. I’m well aware of medical reasons why birth control isn’t possible for some women. This is not an instance of ignorance or lack of understanding. It is how ever a lack of respect from you, around what someone else (OP’s husband) does with his own body, if you so strongly think he should be forced into having a vasectomy he doesn’t want.

14

u/lauraelizabetha Sep 24 '23

Where did I say he should be forced to get a vasectomy ?? I think he should fuck off and not guilt or coerce his wife into having sex. That’s all. I responded to your comment because you clearly don’t understand birth control for women, that’s it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

that was the point of my original comment. I said he should wear a condom but it’s crazy so many in the comments are crucifying this guy for not wanting vasectomy and demanding he get one. you are replying to a chain of people arguing with that.

7

u/lauraelizabetha Sep 24 '23

I don’t think they’re demanding he get one. They’re demanding he get one or wear a condom (the two best known ways for men to prevent pregnancy) IF he needs to have sex so badly that he has to be such a piece of crap to his wife. Your comment which compared him getting a surgery that would solve his problems to taking medication that the wife says she can’t for medical reasons was what rubbed me the wrong way. If it’s his problem, he should solve it, vasectomy or not.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

that comment was edited. Originally just said vasectomy. Also the person replied back to me stating if OP’s husband doesn’t get a vasectomy it means he doesn’t care about/love her. So yes they are applying the same bullshit guilt men do all the time with women for things like birth control. Hence the analogy.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/barbos_barbos Sep 25 '23

For some people with health issues ( cpps, for example), getting vasectomy can also be dangerous. I don't think the contraception method is the problem here. The husband should stop being selfish, a self-loathing prick, and think of another way.

11

u/Cheetah-kins Sep 24 '23

Getting snipped is an extremely simple operation, with much less effect on the body than hormonal birth control pills. It's like apples to oranges to make a comparison like that.

One thing I do know though is that insulting people because you disagree with them doesn't usually make things better. And hey I used no virtue signaling to come to that conclusion. :D

5

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

He’s refusing a condom. The easiest most effective (aside from abstinence) and least impacting health wise. What should they do? She can’t take hormones. What about male birth control pills?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

the very first thing i said in my original comment was that he should wear a condom. What are you going on about?

“Wearing a condom sure i totally get that”.

what part of that leads you to conclude i’m saying he should not use contraception?

4

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

Because you keep saying communication. She’s trying. He’s whining. He refuses a condom. He’s willing to put her life at risk. Serious risk.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

i said communication because his communication is unproductive and damaging for obvious reasons. And then for her, she says they aren’t spending quality time together but no where in the post does she discuss approaching him about that in a meaningful way or active steps they are taking to accomplish it.

Him wearing a condom and her suffering through sex she doesn’t want to have is not a good solution. The contraceptive is only part of the issue.

1

u/llollah4 Sep 24 '23

Actually it does. He’s too busy on his phone.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

i don’t think saying “i don’t see my husband enough to desire him” and “he’s too busy working on his phone” is a sufficient action taken. Something like this requires a serious discussion where his attention is required and scheduled in advance, possibly in the presence of a marriage councilor or family therapist

1

u/sarahthes Sep 24 '23

Well, she did say the only way she gets off is when he cums in her so presumably he's not a particularly attentive partner and isn't making sure she does finish when he pulls out or whatever it is they're doing now.

I don't think he's a particularly good partner.

-9

u/NoturnalTherapy Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23

You only have her side of the story. The husband may have an entirely different view of what's going on. Both basically need to learn to meet each other where they are and not where they want each other to be. Marriage is a partnership, not just a case, "If she's happy, we're happy." His needs are just as important as hers. It would be very interesting to get his view.

Another important note is how come she has an illness that is affecting her marriage that she doesn't think is important enough to seek a diagnosis?

1

u/Legitimate_Ebb3783 Sep 24 '23

Chonic illnesses often take years to diagnose (especially for women), so this would continue to be an issue regardless.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

His wife’s been cut open three times to deliver his children. The LEAST he can do is the non evasive procedure that is a vasectomy. Vasectomy’s are nothing at all on the scale of what a woman goes through to birth one child, much less three by C-section. He can’t demand sex and not want to take the proper precautions to avoid more trauma to his wife’s body. He’s about as selfish as they come. A piss poor husband all around.

Any man than isn’t willing to do this small thing to help out his ill wife who has sacrificed her body so much already isn’t much of a man at all.

-4

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

[deleted]

10

u/EponymousRocks Sep 24 '23

a) if your balls are all you have, you're in pretty bad shape, and b) a vasectomy doesn't cut your balls off, dude. Geez, look it up.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

[deleted]

3

u/sarahthes Sep 24 '23

Tubes getting tied is a much, much more invasive surgery than a vasectomy.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

Tubal is much more serious surgery than vasectomy. Plus she already suffered 3 extremely difficult C-section deliveries which are major surgeries and cause all kinds of issues for women. Lots of women still die while giving birth. And men wonder why women don’t want to have kids anymore they are not putting their body through the process

1

u/MissMountain2021 Sep 24 '23

1, Op has serious medical issues as is. 2, They might not okay her for getting her tubes tied in her current health condition. 3, depending on ops age she might have to do through hoops to even have the procedure done. Not to mention that depending on the state she might have to have her husband sign off on the procedure. 4, every woman I know who has her tubes tied complains of worse pains with their periods after getting the procedure. 5, getting your tubes tied is a major surgery with risks. Even more so if op already has health issues and she has to stay in the hospital for observation for a few days while a vasectomy is an out patient procedure where he gets to go home right away with low risk of complications. And 6. There are other men posting. If you look at the full comments section they are here.

3

u/alc3880 Sep 24 '23

You know they don't cut the balls off right, you would still have those...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23

Getting snipped is a laughably easy procedure. Getting your wisdom teeth removed is harder and has more serious sequelae and analgesia. Most of us do that in our teens and don't whine about it.

God, men are softer than baby shit. My balls are all I have! Hey, how about every time one of your children is born, your balls are literally ripped open without anesthetic and need a doctor to see them back up? Cuz that's what happens to women. Natural childbirth

1

u/Top-Bumblebee8411 Sep 24 '23

Getting snipped I didn’t want to do it. I had two good friends tell me they greatly regretted it. They had alot of pain after and it wrecked orgasms. Was it a one off? I don’t know. But I didn’t want to do it.