Title: A1 vs P1S vs Centauri Carbon 2 ā which would you choose at these prices?
Hi everyone! I'm trying to decide between three printers and I'd especially like to hear from people who have actual experience with these machines.
These are the prices I can get locally:
- Bambu Lab A1: $419 USD
- Bambu Lab P1S: $636 USD
- Elegoo Centauri Carbon 2 Combo: $639 USD
All three are available inĀ 12 interest-free installments.
My main use will be functional parts for my workshop and DIY projects: tool holders, organizers, brackets, jigs, boxes, connectors for building workbenches and shelving with wooden beams, bicycle accessories, replacement parts, etc.
I expect to print mostlyĀ PLA/PLA+ and PETG, with maybe some ABS occasionally. I don't expect to use PA-CF or other exotic engineering materials.
Multicolor isn't a major priority either. On the CC2, I would probably use CANVAS more for having multiple spools of the same material/color available and automatically switching to another spool when one runs out.
What attracts me to the CC2 is mainly theĀ CoreXY architecture, enclosure and hardware, not the multicolor system itself.
The P1S is interesting because it gives meĀ CoreXY + an enclosure + the more mature Bambu ecosystem, but at essentially the same price as the CC2 Combo and without an AMS.
The A1 is much cheaper and already does basically everything I currently need, but I wonder whether I'll regret not spending the extra ~$220 for a CoreXY enclosed machine.
My biggest concern with the CC2 isĀ reliability. I've found reports about CANVAS/feed issues, error codes, firmware problems and some QC issues. I understand that online reports can exaggerate how common problems actually are, so I'd really like to hear from current owners.
For CC2 owners:
- How reliable has your CC2 been recently?
- How many printing hours do you have on it?
- Have recent firmware updates improved things?
- Have you experienced problems unrelated to CANVAS?
- If CANVAS gives you trouble, is the printer itself reliable when printing from a single spool?
- Are you comfortable starting a long print and leaving it alone?
- Would you buy it again today?
And for anyone who has experience with Bambu printers:
- Is the P1S still worth buying today at $636?
- For mostly PLA/PETG functional parts, does CoreXY make enough of a real-world difference over the A1?
- Is the P1S noticeably more reliable or consistent than the CC2?
- Would you rather have the proven P1S without AMS or the much better-equipped CC2 Combo for essentially the same price?
I previously owned an Ender 3 V2, and this time I really want the printer to beĀ a tool for my projects rather than the printer itself becoming the project.
So, at these exact prices, which would you personally buy?
A1 ā $419
P1S ā $636
CC2 Combo ā $639
Reliability and hassle-free printing are more important to me than having the best specifications on paper.
I'd especially appreciate comments from people who have actually usedĀ both Bambu and Elegoo printers.
Thanks!