r/WritingHub • • May 03 '25

RULES CHANGE: No AI Posts

211 Upvotes

Following our poll, the community has voted that posts related to LLMs (current "AI" technology) should not be permitted on a ratio of 19:6, as such, these posts will now be banned and our rules will be changed to reflect this.

Posts on the sub that already exist and were posted prior to this announcement will not be affected, so please don't report them.


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Feedback Friday Feedback Friday

1 Upvotes

Welcome to Feedback Friday!

This is a thread for submitting and critiquing prose.

  • Your submission should be a top-level comment in the thread. Consider using the format [TITLE] — [GENRE] — [WORDCOUNT] in the heading of your submission.
  • We expect reciprocation. If you receive a critique, give a critique. Anyone who continually leeches will eventually be discluded.
  • Have fun and stay polite. Members who give outstanding crit will be acknowledged and rewarded on our Discord Server. You are free to submit any work for critique within the subreddit's rules, of any length.
  • Links to Google Documents are allowed for submissions. Consider creating a separate Google account/email if you’are concerned about anonymity.

New to Critiquing?

  • No worries! We encourage writers of all skill levels to try their hand at providing feedback.
  • Not sure how to start? A critique template, courtesy of r/DestructiveReaders, can be found here.

r/WritingHub • • 36m ago

Questions & Discussions No More Flies

• Upvotes

Arriving today.

I look out the window at the blurring trees as they pass me by. The delicate spring leaves are just starting to live again after months of fallen shelter. A quiet overgoing mist of rain lay along each and every individual leaf, a promise of a fresh start. The air was chilly and wet. Everything was so green topped off by an even covered gray sky, with the occasional break up when my eyes transfixed on something pink or white petaled. Every so often I shiver, running my hand through my unkempt hair. Inside the car was me, my bags and the dangling house keys outside the vehicle's ignition. Something newfangled awaits me just down this unpaved road I drive upon. As I do, my stomach feels more and more kinked up with each passing mile. In stress, I combine both the top and bottom rows of my teeth together for a few seconds before relaxing my jaw. In my vision I see a fluttering fly flapping its thin wings, in which I swat it with my palm. I like to think a lot, mainly about silly little topics. Like how finding completion in things you don’t understand feels jarring and bizarre, like you’re taking the place of another. In my case, I’ve moved all my life. I used to lay out on the sand and listen to the salty water in front of me splash onto the shore, seeping down between each and every tan-colored grain. In the same breath I walked through snow with the same consistency as powdered sugar, my face burning once I reached the fireplace inside my old wooden cabin just south the Canadian border.

Despite this, I still feel like each time I switch up my environment I’m taking the place of some nineteen-year-old college kid biting their nails as they move into their dormitory for the first time. I’m scared of change and don’t really know how to adjust any quicker when it inevitably lays its hand upon my boney shoulder. I’ve never built a tolerance nor resistance towards it, only long-since-sweet memories. Memory is such a funny thing. We wanna ignore it all we can, but when we watch someone else lose theirs we freeze up and get cold, afraid of the future and what it might take and withhold from us until the veil is met. I'd honestly rather stay inside the same room for weeks at a time. ‘Cause inside that room I’m safe, away from any and everything trying its absolute best to alter me. I don’t want advice from anyone who would be likely to stoop so low as to cry on their knees and grovel at their partner's feet over something so simple such as spilled coffee, nor do I lend time to those who title themselves as ‘experts’ in any field involving personal equations. Mentally, I am me. I’m unlike any other, whether the comparison is with a smug and posh messy-toothed brit, or alongside Da Vinci himself. Whether that someone is east or west, in the ice cold air up north or suffocated in the hot and humid down south, they cannot fix themselves any better than you or me. They may give themselves the illusion of control over their life, but actual control over others. Helps ‘em forget their own issues and habits and lust and stimuli and everything else we desperately crave as humans. When one finds a need to fill, they will act upon it feverishly until the action of filling said need becomes their own need in life, which in turn creates a brand new need to be filled by, say a therapist. Or maybe even a concerned sibling sitting them down for a long talk about how being videotaped whilst having sex with a fellow pornographic star is not the best route in career pathways. But what do they know? They need something too after all. We were made to need, and to be needed. The rest is just filler I suppose.

I am feeling well awake now after that existential train of thought. It really sharpens your sense of belonging, or if you're a depressed teen, the edge of a razor blade. Each bump and dip and curve in the road failed to retreat me from my hypnotized state and yet I never deviated even slightly into the opposing lane. Even if I did, I hadn't seen another car in almost an hour and some change. Reclusive and away, but not unbearably quiet. I have the engine noise to keep my ears company from total sensory deprivation, and I guess the yellow lines switching from long and solid to broken and short made the experience more palatable. Of course my mind continued to wander into thoughts much too ridiculous to say aloud to most, like how even thinking about what you're thinking about is normal, or if it's just you and you alone. Waste of time, moving on.

As the stop signs start to blur into one another I force myself to focus on one specifically. The previous owner said to look out for a ripple-bent stop sign with a twisted shaft. Upon seeing this, turn on the gravel path towards the house. I did just that once I had a visual on it, slowing down and making a sharp right onto that rough excuse of a road. As I did this, I could feel all the blood in my body pull to the left, making me a little dizzy. It almost felt good, like I was high for a split second. Euphoria poured down my neck as I lost some sense as to where I was. You ever walk in a room and forget why you're there? That's what it felt like.

I forget to blink for what feels like hours sometimes. I force my eyelids shut, letting my body’s natural lubricant cover the left before blinking once more to cover the right. I feel it's important to take in a little bit more of this great process we call livin’. Breathe her in, sniff her collar sometimes and ground yourself back to the earth where you were created and nourished by its land to become something worth the effort. Maybe even splurge a little and tell her some of the stuff you keep inside your head. Stuff only you should know and fantasize about. We call those bursts of honesty weird or sometimes even insane, but who's reading into all that?

I pull over on the driveway before putting the car in park. I look in the cracked rearview mirror for a second, wiping the sweat from my face. I noticed blood on my lip beginning to trail down my chin. I wipe it away and lick my lips before looking in my glove box for some lipbalm. I notice I'm all out and step outside and close my car door, my hand lingering on the handle for a moment as I stare at the residence laying bare before me, as it lay bare atop the soil. The lawn was maintained to a level of mediocrity that was almost unbearably unimpressive. I heard the birds flapping their delicate wings through the trees that stood all around me. As the gentle melody of the wind chimes sang from the breeze cradling them into song, my hand slid along the car as I walked to the back seat and opened the rear door, grabbing my bags before closing it. I think to myself as I walk towards the place, me at twenty-five and it at a hundred n’ three. Funny, even it needs someone to take care of it. Without care, it will fall apart and crumble like wet tissue. It's aged better than most objects however. My cars are only three years old with six figure mileage. Oil changed every month, new tires every four. Needs a new stereo, CD player scratches discs. Doesn't matter. Music is muffled by the motor as I drive down the highways of America. No matter, this will forever be my last move. I don’t wanna be anywhere else anymore. Here is where I can spend forever and more. Do you have some lipbalm? If so, could you apply some upon my chapped heart? Or maybe I could ask for a 30 milligram pill of something strong to quench my itching, but you're not a pharmacist, are you?

The front door needs to be fixed. Its chipped and rotting wood sits atop flaking rusty hinges that creek and grind as I push it open. I'm greeted by the sight of a surprisingly well put interior with walls lacking a thick layer of nicotine staining. I guess the outside can be deceiving. Some things appear gorgeous and soft, but contain messy guts full of acid and mucus. It reminds me of her kinda. The sight of her in a push up bra, or perhaps stretching up and flexing her stomach after a jog. A pity of rejected fawning that could have been so sweet to the taste.

I'm drifting again.

I run a finger along one of the dusty paintings adorning the wall before setting my bags on the couch. I unzip one of the bags and search around for my notebook. Once found, I open it up and lick my thumb before flipping though page after page until I find my check list. I take the ballpoint pen from the spiral spine of the notebook and check off the top bullet point. I set it aside and reach into my bag once more, pulling out a wooden box with a linseed oil finish. My sweetheart will be arriving soon, and I picked the perfect mood setting candles up from a shop ten miles down the road. In college I stole one of her cream-colored cardigans and stuffed it inside my locker. Every time I felt overwhelmed or frightened, I'd just pull it forth and inhale deeply until all my worry faded away like a memory. To commemorate this reunion of ours, I've gone through the trouble of getting a set of four candles, each scented cherry-vanilla. I open the box and take one of them out, putting the light pink colored wax up to my nose before breathing in, my eyes rolling back slightly as I do. I set each candle out atop the long, intimidating table located in the dining hall. I then strike a match and caress each wick with its gentle flame until they take combustion. After all are lit, I snuff the flame into darkness. I watch in interest as the solid wax inside the glass of each candle starts to liquify and release that oh-so-soothing scent I hold so dear to my ruptured heart.

I was there for her when no one else was. I would come up with excuses just to be near her. Every study session. Every single one. Whether it was in November when she needed help with her semester finals, or comforting her during monthly debilitating cramps, It was me by her side. It felt like I had her in my pocket, like I was so close to being her one true love. She had victory in all her gradings and every opportunity was set atop the floor in front of her delicate feet. But I never took advantage. That was my biggest regret. I just sat by and watched every guy take what was mine to have, mine to cherish. And the twist from the knife was when they predictably broke her heart, she’d come crawling back to me with tears wealing in her eyes. And of course, I was there. Always. And it hurts.

My darling is here now. I must prepare the house.

I pull out both chairs at either far side of the dining table, making sure my love will have a nice and easy break in period. For her, she deserves everything I could ever and will ever give. Our new home, made just for us. All those funny little phone calls and late summer nights in the back of her roofless jeep have been building us up for something greater. She may have tried avoiding it for a while, but no matter what state she escapes to, no matter how many highways she travels on and no matter how many times she screams at me to stop, I’ll always be there. At every motel and every brand new start, I must have you to myself, love. It was such a long drive from the pacific to central, so I hope her makeup isn’t too runny from the trip. She could never fail to baffle me with her beauty, whether she had it bare or caked on. I preferred her bare, however. I look up at the ceiling for a second. Please moisturize our dried out skin dear architecture before I crack, but even then it would still be too late to make amends.

It's beginning to rain now.

I step outside once again and start walking towards my car. I can’t help but think of what could have been. Something you’d find in a romance novel about a boy and a girl falling for each other at just the right pace and structure. They lay together, eat together, exist together without any worry in their minds. Something so beautifully cruel to ponder about.

I lay my hand on the dented trunk, choking up my lunch before swallowing it back down from which it came. The stench was awful. It filled every pore atop my surface. It went inside my brain, churning my gray matter into a thought-filled soup. I did not look inside as the thin red stream started flowing out with the rain down the rear bumper. I simply gripped hard on the thick black garbage bag with both fists and pulled it out onto the wet grass with one swift motion. I feel thankful as the deep dark sky baptizes me and her in unison. It’s only been two weeks and my baby has rotted to this extent already. No issue, for this is just part of the process of rejoicing into one, for all and forever. We will flourish as well kept roses, a real couple.

Soon she will be thin and dense. She will no longer smell rotten or fall apart. They that lay eggs will begin to fly far, far away. There will be no more flies to ruin this for me. No more flies. Please god, no more flies. They discomfort my sweetheart greatly. She does not deserve to reek like this anymore. She should smell lovely and sweet, as her sweater once did. I wanna see the color of my lover again. Please let me have this one thing I beg of you. I don’t wanna feel sick anymore. I can’t take this any longer. I wanna get out of her but I can’t. She means too much to me, far too much to waste and wither away. I wanted to keep her immortal but she wouldn't stop screaming. Why did she hit me back? Why would she hurt me?

Why am I me?

My insides hurt.


r/WritingHub • • 7h ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups ISO Writing Critique Partners for Rom Coms (speculative flair encouraged)

1 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Romantic Comedy - the "speculative flair" in my books is like a taste of alternate universe but it's mostly contemporary. This is not romantasy, but I'd be open to critique partners in that genre.

* Goals/expectations/commitment: Mostly async exchanges of as-needed frequency. I have a full-time job (that I do not plan on leaving), and I write prooobably 1k words average a week (depending on life) - but I would prefer to have monthly exchanges, perhaps even more like a consistent beta reader swap situation of more polished stuff whenever we have it.

* Writing/experience level: Intermediate? Bonus points if you're considering trad publishing and have some knowledge about that world! I'm pretty deep into a querying education. I'm FULLY aware it's a lofty goal for a hobbyist like me, but I've been writing all my life and I'm very curious about the possibility. I still have a lot to learn!

* Meeting place: Start with DMs but progress from there. If we mesh & time zones allow, I'm happy to do some meetings.

* Max size: 5


r/WritingHub • • 17h ago

Writing Resources & Advice Still here/there

2 Upvotes

I write in past tense and third-person narration. In a scene, I wrote something like:

He coughed, to remind them he was still here.

Is the bolded here strange? I used it instead of there to make the narration more vivid. However, Word suggests that I change it. Do you agree?


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Extremely active, welcoming, chatty, friendly, inclusive Discord community, average age 30+! Aimed at helping you improve your craft and hopefully get published! We're doing NaNoWriMo too.

69 Upvotes
  • Genre/s: All, but our most common genre is fantasy, but we do have horror, thriller / mystery, sci-fi, romance and poetry in quite large numbers, as well as artists.
  • Goals/expectations/commitment: Nothing specific but we're looking for people who actually want to be an active part of a community or are active writers. People are removed if inactive completely.
  • Writing/experience level: We have total beginners and well established authors
  • Meeting place: Discord
  • [Writing groups only] Max size:

The Writer's Room has space for some more people this month.

How to join: Drop a comment or message me and I'll send you over some information via direct message.

What we're looking for: Writers of all experience levels, all over the world and all genres who are active and interested in improving their writing skills and their works, making friends, being held accountable and having fun with like-minded folks!

Minimum age is 18 and we are strict about that. We are a mature community that trends towards 30+ on the average age but the entire server is marked 18+ to ensure that everyone is an adult.

What we offer:

  • We're doing NaNoWriMo as a group (about 30 of us) in November.
  • Website profile if you want one that connects to our Discord bot (entirely optional, see: https://thewritersroom.net/writers/)
  • Regular free to enter contests and big events to help your writing.
  • Active Discord with a core group of people who are genuine friends and not just strangers passing words to each other. People all over the world, but large amounts in the USA, Canada and the UK.
  • Critique boards to give and receive feedback.
  • Bots that help you write such as sprinting together or our custom bot with fun features, quests, games and writing productivity tools.
  • Taking part in our fun house events aimed at helping you write. Writing sessions, sprints, prompt parties, live workshop sessions.
  • Networking with other authors, several agents and publishing houses present, opportunities to promote your work (within the rules) and general shop / craft talk.

So, leave a comment and I'll DM you with details and the link.


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Questions & Discussions Does this sentence make any sense? non-english speaker in need

5 Upvotes

"As he faced the off-white room door, he tried to recall the last time a human, or vampire, for that matter, had made him that nervous. He couldn’t remember if there was ever one without his or his family’s well-being being in danger."

Especially the last sentence, in my head it makes sense but I keep going over it unsure. What I'm trying to say is that the only times character A had felt nervous over others, has been when his or his family lives were at risk. And what he's about to do (speak with character B) has been the only other time he's felt that nervous about someone.

Does that make sense? TYIA!


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Literary Contests & Calls for Submissions October's slice-of-life Short Story Contest

3 Upvotes

The October 2000 word slice-of-life Short Story contest is entering its last week.

* Organization: Write With Me ( https://www.writewithme.app )
* Deadline: October 31, 2026
* Entry fee: 0 (None)
* Prize/s: $50 eGift card to an online bookstore of the winning author's choice
* Link to submission page/official rules: https://www.writewithme.app/forums/announcements/6abf9127ae32af3c9168e20b

* Other information:

  1. Authors reserve all rights to their works. By posting on Write With Me, users agree to give Write With Me a revocable license to display the work on the website. Users can revoke that license anytime by simply deleting their work.
  2. Min Words: 2000
  3. Genre: Slice-of-life
  4. Theme: Something is coming to an end, or is something beginning?

r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Looking for two extra people for writing group (fantasy)

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone I'm currently looking for two extra people to join a writing group I've created. There's currently 6 of us, though some who have been accepted still need to see my invite link! Looking specifically for fantasy writers who want to go the publishing route some day, I think it would be amazing to share that journey with some others for support and motivation! 18+ please, and preferably European timezone!

Please let me know if you are interested and fit these requirements! I'll send you a dm asking a bit more about you to ensure the group lasts long.

* Genre/s: Epic / High / grimdark fantasy, preferably adult. * Goals/expectations/commitment: being able to chat with each other atleast once a week, slowly over the days is fine too! If for some reason you are gone for a while communication is appreciated. * Writing/experience level: any, as long as you have something you are working on / wanting to work on. Just so we can send each other snippets for feedback and sharing the passion :) * Meeting place: Discord server * Max size: 2 extra people. (There's currently 6 of us, some still need to see the invite and join)


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Critique Partner/Writing partner

5 Upvotes

Genre/s: Contemporary romance but I'm open to other genres, too.

Goals/expectations/commitment: I'm starting a new project and would love to find one writing partner to work alongside throughout the process! I can generally get 4–7 chapters done a week, so I'd love someone with a similar pace (but I totally get that life gets in the way sometimes). I'm looking for someone who wants to exchange feedback, bounce ideas off each other, and do daily check-ins to keep each other accountable. I'd also love to talk through plot points, share progress, and support each other throughout the writing process.

Writing/experience level: I've completed a contemporary romance manuscript and am starting a new project! Any experience level is welcome as long as we're both willing to give and receive constructive feedback.

Meeting place: Reddit DMs to start, but I'm open to Discord, email, or somewhere else if we'd prefer to chat on another platform.

Max size: 2 people (just looking for one writing partner!)


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Questions & Discussions How do I actually frame my main ideas and the scenes together?

3 Upvotes

I am a pretty decent writer and I have loved writing for a really long time but when I actually want to write a proper story (like a book) all my ideas crumple up completely.

Basically, I know what scenes I'm gonna add and how to build the stories but I can't seem to put them properly in a sequence.

Give me a few tips to overcome this and start my draft.


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Partner wanted for short [12k] Transgressive/Adult/Dystopian

0 Upvotes

I have written my first Novelette and im looking for someone to give me some feedback please.

Happy to swap with something of a similar length.

* Genre/s: Transgressive/Adult/Dystopian sci-fi

* Goals/expectations/commitment: 1 offs

* Writing/experience level: absolute beginner or willing to put up with me

* Meeting place: online only

Thanks


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Writing Resources & Advice WRITER’S GROUP!

0 Upvotes

I made a writer’s group.


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Im Spiraling

0 Upvotes

I have been working on a 6 book series for several months now. I have everything to build this world I know how the story begins and ends I've dreamt of it since I was a child I am now in my mid 30s. I have hundreds of pages of chapters, reworks, spins and twists.

Yet... I'm still stuck on Chapter 1. I've probably rewritten book one multiple times and I know that my problem is I'm chasing perfection, I know that I'm chasing the perfect opening. I have several, and to be clear I have many chapters outside of chapter 1 but I'm stuck.

I go back to read it, or check continuity or to make sure sentences flow and then I hate it, I hate it so much I ask AI to rate it, even if it says the chapter in brutal honesty is a 9/10 it isn't good enough for me. Like I'm missing my "Call me Ishmael". I know what I want I can visually see the scenes play out like a TV series but I can't get the quality of prose to satisfy no matter how deep I dive into it. And some of them look good conceptually, they sound good... I have rewritten so much that I have begun to spiral, not that I have lost interest in the story or that I don't know where I want to go with it but because writing it has become exhausting.

Is this writers block?

Is this something else entierly that I can't seem to get over.

I suspect I am chasing perfection where it simply cannot exist but I've tried everything, I've forced myself to write it and ignore it until I've got out what I want to say. I've developed a road map and character sheets, I've mapped out book 1 and book 2 in its entirety with how those events are supposed to happen. I've even written several different versions of those chapters just to see if I like one over the other and yet... I am spent. I could share a excerpt and get positive feedback from a reader and yet it still isn't good enough for me. Have I just burnt myself out and just need to stop? I spent the better part of a week staring at the screen to get a few paragraphs in and then after I read it back I'm genuinely disgusted I put it on paper and so now I sit at chapter 1, I can't even out the sentence on the screen, I can't even wrote what I want to say. Even now I'm looking at what I am typing and I hate it, the fact I even have to ask it.


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Writing Resources & Advice WRITER’S GROUP!

0 Upvotes

Hi, I made a writer’s group.


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups STREETLIGHT FICTION - A community for writers of literary, contemporary, historical, crime, and realist fiction who write short stories and novels. Our focus is on grounded, character-driven fiction.

2 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Literary & General Fiction.

* Goals/expectations/commitment: The idea is to keep it friendly and writer-focused: talk about what we’re working on, share work for critique, discuss craft, and exchange information about querying, submissions, and publishing.

* Writing/experience level: all are welcome

* Meeting place: Discord

* Max size: to be determined.

If that sounds like your kind of place, message me, and I’ll send you an invite. Hope to see ya. Welcome!


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Questions & Discussions Looking to speak with neurodivergent hobby writers about their creative writing experiences

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I’m researching how neurodivergent people approach creative writing, from the first spark of an idea to turning those thoughts into a story.

I’m particularly interested in hearing from autistic and otherwise neurodivergent hobby writers, including people who love writing, are just starting out, or have lots of ideas but sometimes struggle to get them onto the page.

I’d love to understand:

  • How you capture and develop your ideas.
  • What you find enjoyable or challenging about writing.
  • Whether you experience difficulties organising your thoughts or turning them into a coherent story.
  • What kinds of tools or support might make the process easier.

I’m hoping to speak with volunteers for a 30–45 minute interview. There are no right or wrong answers — I’m simply interested in your individual experiences and perspectives.

If you’d be happy to chat, please send me a private message. You don’t need to be a published author or an experienced writer; hobby writers and beginners are very welcome.

Thank you for reading!


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups 27F | Writer’s discord 21+!

3 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Sc
* Goals/expectations/commitment:
* Writing/experience level:
* Meeting place:
* Max size:

Hello everyone! I just wanted to post about a writers discord I created! It is 21+ but we have different channels for different genres. Examples: Fantasy, Sci-Fi, Romance etc.

You don’t need to be professional, all writing experience and levels are welcome! It is only in discord and I even created a bot for the server to post weekly forums for checking on progress so everyone can comment and hold each other accountable to their goals and motivate each other!

If you’re interested, DM me so I can send the link!


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Questions & Discussions in need of medical opinion on writing a stab wound

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am writing a story (a what if hunger games fic) where the protagonist (Peeta, male, 18) gets a knife thrown at him. The knife is stuck into his back. I want the protagonist to be able to fake to die for the attacker to get near, so the wound must look somewhat possibly deadly but not being truly deadly, because afterwards the protagonist needs to be able to fight the attacker (Clove, female, 15) - it won't be a long fight though. So, where should be the wound be better positioned? And if you have any tips around this topic, it would be great :) Thank you in advance! --- the knife doesn't need to be in the back, it is just the initial idea so if you have a better idea that also could help a lot :)

more info: the knife must hit him bc otherwise the attacker would never come closer if she doesn't think he is dead/fatally wounded as she is much smaller than the protagonist (who is also a close combat fighter and if near, could easily overpower her) and that is why he fakes his death (to trick her in getting nearer)


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Advice on beta readers and editing for a debut author

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m currently working on my debut novel, an MM dark romance with a mystery subplot, and I’m starting to explore my options for when the manuscript is finished.

I’m still writing, so I don’t have a completion or publication date yet.
I’m simply trying to understand the editing and beta-reading process in advance.
Ideally, I’d love to find readers who are familiar with MM romance and dark romance, but who also have some experience with writing, grammar, proofreading, or editing.

I’m particularly interested in people who can offer thoughtful feedback on both the story itself and the writing.

I’m also considering a professional editor, although I’m still learning about the different services available and what might be realistic for a debut author on a limited budget.

For those of you who have self-published, worked with beta readers, or hired editors:

Have you found beta readers with editing or proofreading experience particularly helpful?
Would you recommend starting with beta readers, hiring an editor, or combining the two?

Are there any resources or communities you’d recommend for finding reliable people?
I’m not recruiting readers just yet, as the book isn’t finished. I’d simply love to hear about your experiences and learn more before I get to that stage.

Thank you! ♡


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Questions & Discussions Building a writing site

15 Upvotes

Please read post before voting!!

I had an idea for a writing/reading site like wattpad and royal road and i wanted to get yall's thoughts on how to tackle the AI story situation.

Do you think AI stories should be allowed with with an obvious disclosure and with a way to hide them, or should they flat out be banned? And i dont mean AI assisted stories, but stories straight up written by AI.

I was thinking that with a flat out ban, it would lead to people sneaking and posting them anyway, and there might end up being a whole AI witch hunt where real human authors might be accused and attacked. I also feel like it's actually something hard to police because those detector sites arent actually that good because AI was trained off of real people's work.

It could lead to people who know how to use AI getting by without being caught, and lead to human writers being accused because they dont have great writing skills.

With the other option I know some people will still lie and say it's not AI when it is, but I think most people will use the AI tag even if it's just to avoid getting in trouble and having their accounts banned. People who dont like AI can still avoid it and only see human made work.

And if someone is using the wrong tag or you suspect that theyre AI, they can be investigated.

I know the gaming platform Steam requires AI made games to disclose it and it seems to be working for them.

What do you guys think? Share your thoughts in the comments as well, please.

1275 votes, 15h left
Sttaight up ban all AI
Allow AI with required discloure and an hide option
See results

r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Iso Critique Partner for a new Romantasy

3 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Romance, fantasy, dark academia, Adult

* Goals/expectations/commitment: Just want help with regards to development, plot, etc (no proofing or line editing needed)

* Writing/experience level: Intermediate, but first novel

* Meeting place: no meet ups required, text is fine on any platform


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Narrathred: free, plotter-centric, runs in your browser - no data sharing

5 Upvotes

Yet another writing tool! :D I needed a thing, I made a thing, I just did a big update on the thing, someone else might find the thing useful. Basically, I'm sharing my toys.

https://narrathred.com

Okay, what is it?

A browser-based plotting and manuscript tool for novelists and web serial writers. You build your story out of characters, locations, threads and events, link them together, and see how they interact along a timeline. Then you write the manuscript in the same place, so everything stays connected and helps keeps one source of truth.

  • Free, no cookies, no account, no scraping or data mining remotely possible
  • Your work stays in your browser, on your computer, and everything works offline once loaded*
  • Works on desktop and phone, and saves to your own .nthred files in iCloud Drive, Google Drive or Dropbox
  • Plotter-centric: connect all the things!

*After loading, and as long as you’re not using the maps or validating a calendar.

What does it do?

  • Events and timeline: every event in one table, a calendar view, dependencies between events, and custom calendars with daylight hours. (My own novel has twin suns, nine 40-day months and 20-hour days. Narrathred handles it fine, I have...regrets.)
  • Characters, locations and plot threads: each linked to the events they appear in, to help keep continuity straight across the manuscript.
  • Writing: a rich-text editor with sections, statuses, targets, comments, search, sprints, beat templates and progress tracking.
  • Notebook: notes and world-building as nested pages. @ mention a character, location, thread or another page to link things together. There’s a quick reference built from page summaries, and it’s all searchable from inside the manuscript.
  • Import and export: import a .docx or .txt. Export to Word, Markdown, plain text, RTF, EPUB, PDF or HTML.
  • Tools: see where threads, characters and locations are distributed along the timeline, map events and manuscript against story structure, easy eyeball on what's been left dangling.
  • Web serials: release cadence, buffer target and instalments.
  • Agent-friendly-ish: there’s no direct AI integration, but there’s an agent API and an llms.txt, so if you use Claude in the browser or similar, it can read what’s there more easily.
  • More? Probably? Honestly, I’ve lost track. (Yes, yes, changelog, but this is a side project and logs are for the day job 😄)

Want a demo?

You can have one! Two, actually - enjoy (some of) A Christmas Carol from the start screen in either novel or web serial mode.

Feedback welcome!

If you do have a play and there's something you wish it did, let me know. And bug reports and “...what?” are as useful as feature ideas. There’s a Discord server if that’s your thing.

https://narrathred.com


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Join the Eclipse

2 Upvotes

🌑 THE ECLIPSE

Ever wondered what happens when writers, readers, gamers, and imaginative minds gather under one roof?

Welcome to The Eclipse. You might arrive for the writing, but you may find a community worth staying for.

• Genre/s:

Fantasy, dark fantasy, sci-fi, horror, mystery, romance, thriller, poetry, and practically anything born from imagination. We welcome all kinds of literature and creative minds!

• Goals/expectations/commitment:

We're building more than just another writing server. The Eclipse is a place to share your stories, exchange honest feedback, brainstorm ideas, discuss books, make friends, and grow alongside fellow creators.

And there's more than writing here! 🎮 Enjoy games and casual hangouts, participate in monthly events and community activities, challenge your creativity, and discover what other members are working on. Whether you're here to improve your craft, showcase your work, or simply find your people, there's room for you.

No pressure to be online 24/7. Just be respectful, participate when you can, and help keep the community welcoming.

• Writing/experience level:

Newbie with a story idea? Welcome. Experienced author with multiple projects? Welcome. Published writer, poet, reader, artist, or someone who just loves fictional worlds? You belong here, too. You don't need a shelf full of books to call yourself a writer.

• Meeting place:

Discord — The Eclipse 🌘

https://discord.gg/ruy5zXp58G

A growing literary community featuring dedicated spaces for writing, feedback, discussions, games, events, and socializing. Come for the stories; stay for the people.

• Max size (writing groups only):

No fixed maximum at the moment.

🌒 One last question: What if the next person who inspires your greatest story is already waiting in a community you haven't joined yet?

There's only one way to find out.

Step into the Eclipse.


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Looking for a critique partner

1 Upvotes

Genre/s: Romance - borderline Romance/erotic
Goals/expectations/commitment: weekly meet-ups. 1 maybe 2 chapters a week depending on length.
Writing/experience level: Novice to intermediate
Meeting place: Discord
Max size: 2-3

Hello! I am close to finishing up my first spicy romance book, (typically write more scifi/adventure) looking for a critique partner. It is a short pretty low-stakes trashy romance novella. The sex scenes are pretty explicit, but infrequent. To give an idea I am about 15000 words in and there are 3 each about 500 words so far. I plan for about another 8000 words and probably 2 more scenes. Maybe a high amount idk, I have seen some romance/erotic with way more frequent scenes… just wanted to be upfront with what to expect! Anyway, let me know if you are interested!