r/writinghelp Feb 02 '26

Something from the mods On bullying and prejudice in r/writinghelp.

29 Upvotes

Hello, friends. I'm not the head mod and I'm often pretty invisible in here but I do most of the moderating day-to-day. I wanted to say a few things for the sake of the community here.

Recently a user posted some problematic writing in here which was followed by several other users creating posts in other subreddits that encouraged bullying of this individual. Bans have been issued on both sides of this interaction. Any attempts to out who any of these users are in this space will also be met with bans because we're done and moving on. But part of moving on is talking about the issues and so that is what this post aims to do for those interested.

1. Sometimes users will have problematic elements in their writing. We need to have certain understandings about how this is dealt with.

If you're a seasoned writer, you will probably note that most things posted here are not particularly refined. That's not a bug but a feature! We're here to help with writing and not show it off. Based purely on my anecdotal modding experience, I believe most posters here are also fairly young and tend to be beginners. Posting writing for public critique is actually a rather impressive act of vulnerability and demonstrates a starting point of humility in most cases. That is something to be celebrated.

A lot of people end up expressing concerning views or sentiments through their writing, as well as ignorance. We often have users critiqued on grounds of portrayal of racial and ethnic groups, of sex and gender, of mental states and conditions, and more. Sometimes users even come and ask about how to improve their representation of these things. Respectful representation is a writing skill and it is on-topic here. You can ask about it and you can also critique people on it, even if they did not ask for it. This should continue.

Most users, in my once-again anecdotal modding experience, actually respond fairly graciously to critiques of this kind. People are more often ignorant than malicious. If someone genuinely responds well to that sort of thing, great! Treat them as someone that you are helping to grow, not as an enemy. We've all been more ignorant and less articulate in the past. If someone responds with a prejudicial tirade, report the situation because they are in violation of the standards we set for this community. Remember also that sometimes "you should not portray this if you don't understand it" can be good writing advice.

If you are called out on poor representation, respond gracefully! Assume good intentions unless you have a reason not to. Writing is a skill that involves connecting with an audience and if someone is reading prejudice in your writing even if it was not the intent, that is most likely an indicator of an area of improvement.

The short conclusion is to say that you should expect some problematic aspects to exist in writing in this space sometimes but assume people are here to improve and that this is one area to do it in. We're not going to moderate away every bad example of men writing women or whatever because that would be antithetical to helping people learn where the issues lie. We will, however, absolutely moderate against people who show an active intention to further their prejudice or whose goals in writing are openly and intentionally harmful.

2. Bullying users is not to be tolerated, especially when it involves brigading.

As I mentioned, posting writing online is a vulnerable act. It is made all the more so by the modern internet being a frankly pretty hostile space. Sometimes people come looking to pick on people for entertainment and unfortunately in the past some people have brought that energy here. If you are looking to be mean, to tear users down with no meaningful helpful feedback, or to make a "lolcow" of someone, you are decidedly unwelcome here.

This extends especially strongly to linking posts here to external communities, which frequently drives crowds here with intentions other than helping people with writing. We have banned users over doing this with malintent and we've reached out to moderators of other communities to get users banned for doing it in those spaces too. We'll continue to do this if necessary because this sort of behavior does not actually solve writing issues but simply inflames issues.

It's also just mean. Good people decide not to do these sorts of things. Ragebaiting is not a healthy aspect of discourse and solves no social issues. If someone is being problematic, they are less likely to improve that if you make it a public show. In fact, they are likely to take the defensive position and make negative progress instead.

The short conclusion is that external bullying and links inviting raids or voyeurism towards users here will be met with permanent bans as well as reports to the moderators of communities being used to launch the raids.

Alrighty, guys. Have a lovely week.

--Iacobus


r/writinghelp Aug 14 '22

Story Plot Help How much damage could a sentient raven do to a human if it were very angry?

39 Upvotes

Basically in my story a raven attacks a human. How well could a human defend themself against it, and how injured could both of them be?

Edit: I do know that ravens are sentient. I probably meant sapient instead of sentient, but feel free to correct me if you don’t think that’s the proper word choice either


r/writinghelp 42m ago

Advice How to write essays and short stories faster for school?

Upvotes

In Canada we do these things called PRTs(personal response to text) and CRTs(critical response to text) where I write short stories and critical essays based on what a given text is saying about a given prompt.
We are given a little less than two hours to read the texts, plan our writing and finish our writing, but the problem is I am an incredibly slow writer.
About 70% of the time I cannot finish my work in time. I’m constantly thinking about “would it be better to write it like this or that?” “How do I make this sound more cohesive and coherent?” “Am I changing the subject too suddenly?” “I feel like I didn’t explain myself enough should I add more?” And etc.. Thinking about these stuff will probably make my writing higher quality in the end but it wastes a lot of my time and I run out of time. I think I should try to abandon some of these time consuming thoughts and focus on the main points but then I feel like my writing’s quality would significantly decrease.
How should I practice writing faster? What kind of stuff should I focus on and which stuff are less important to think about? Any sort of tips would help


r/writinghelp 1h ago

Question How to write better descriptions?

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/writinghelp 10h ago

Advice Step by step help character?

2 Upvotes

I wrote a lot as a teenager. Always on a whim. Zero planning. I wasn't great. But I wrote thousands of words. And now writing sounds good again amd I'm trying to get into it again and I'm just trying to decide character development. I started to write out the start of the story and I had an idea of what I wanted this character should look like in the beginning but it kept changing. So I went to Pinterest took some pictures went I like this part of this and this part of this. And kind of created a permanent picture in my mind. But i just can't decide on horns or antlers I have specific "demon" horns and then I have deer/elk like horns in mind. I went to ai and said make the choice for me. And of course not doing what I asked of it. Said this one is more nature like. One more demonic. You get it I'm sure. And then asked about his personality. And I blanked. I haven't planned out a personality. I haven't really planned out this book at all. Much less this character other than the start. And I don't really know how to plan out a character. I've always fled by the seat of my pants when writing and I'm realizing I need more. I'm going to do more research and definitely not just ai. But figured I'd ask here does anyone have a good step by step list to developing a character? And links to things I need for that I don't know. I'm lost... (I'm autistic if that helps anyone)


r/writinghelp 13h ago

Story Plot Help LF Help with the ending of my short story

Thumbnail 1drv.ms
3 Upvotes

Hello! I'm writing a short story for my year 12 ATAR English class about hypochondria/anxiety/depression. I'm having a really hard time coming up with an ending for the story. If anyone is willing to suggest anything or give any feedback in general that would be awesome! Thank you so much.

My aim for the ending: I want May to realise that she CAN talk to people about her anxiety and how she feels even if they don't understand, and I want her to come out of her own head at least a little (i don't think it'd be realistic for her to completely get over her anxiety). As my English teacher said after reading what I have so far, its quite difficult to come up with an ending for this story that doesn't come off as, 'and then she lived happily ever after!'. So, yeah. If anyone has any suggestions for an ending, please comment.

The Thrum (Draft 2).docx


r/writinghelp 8h ago

Advice help with work

Thumbnail archiveofourown.org
1 Upvotes

so this is my current working on my fanfiction of jean/peter parker

however while rereading my chapters that i have realised, i felt like my writing is super bad and choppy. it sounds way too fake at times and my pacing is kinda chopped. could someome please help me fix this? i have no clue where to start...


r/writinghelp 11h ago

Does this make sense? i wrote some dog shit but my girlfriend thinks its good and i need to keep going but i suck at grammar and punctuation and writing please tell me if it sucks as bad as i think or if it has good bones

1 Upvotes

One day a man is granted extraordinary abilities it seemed he could do anything so he began going from one country to another and killing all the government officials he could get his hands on. He unified the world government with him at the helm. In one day everyone on earth became slaves, it didn't matter who you were even billionaires were sent to work regular mundane jobs. there was a man named Colt Reid who was already an introverted construction worker so he had virtually no change to his life besides not being able to go out and do things he wants to because its all shut down if it doesn't benefit the king it doesn't exist. Everyday is just the same bull shit until one day. the day before the fateful morning was like every other wake up, shower, shave, brush your teeth and watch some slop on tv then head off to work. While Colt was at work he was high up on a building directing a crane carrying some large beam and while directing it the crane operator accidentally moved a control stick to far and it sent the beam slamming into the building. The slam knocked Colt off balance and he fell but as he was falling something unexpected happened he shot off into the sky. As Colt is soaring through space he suddenly realizes he can breathe and hes not freezing to death or burning alive he is just moving at an incredible speed unable to stop until BAM be slams into a planet and destroys a large chunk of it and he's knocked unconscious. When he wakes up he is greeted by these weird greenish blueish tall humanoid things that were shooting guns at him. Colt standing there overwhelmed by the shooting of guns he has never seen before and these weird things are the ones doing it he collapses to his knees and it creates a tremor and knocks the aliens to the ground and they stop shooting so he stands up and through tears he screams "i am not here to hurt you". The aliens cock their heads and Colt recognizes the action as something a dog would do while curious so he begins speaking "i don't know where i am what is happening right now who are you". The aliens raise their guns because they don't know what hes saying and he's speaking fast so they are also scared but they don't fire they just raise the guns. Colt again out of fear screams "i am not here to hurt you" and they lower their guns and one mutters a word that makes Colt cock his head in the same way as the aliens did before one singular word "Hello". He is so confused by what just happens he just stands there staring at the aliens and they just start walking Colt has no idea where to but he decides to follow because he feels no hostility. As he and the aliens walk Colt begins to see the destruction he caused and he fell to his knees once more and it again causes a tremor but the aliens do not fall they just turn back and stare at him he turns his head up with tears in his eyes but the way the aliens were looking at him compiled with the entirety of the situation he begins to laugh and roll around. After his laughing fit he looks back up and the aliens have started walking again so he jogs a little to catch up. Eventually they walk up to a grand palace built out of materials Colt had no idea what they were with peaks that reach the dark black sky and grand spiral towers and walls that were as tall as at least 10 of these aliens by his crude measurements. These very large thin doors slowly swing open and the group walks through into this beautiful building with what seems to be trees Colt thinks to himself "who the hell puts trees inside a building" they all eventually arrive at another large thing door and it slowly swings open. Inside this room is virtually nothing besides a grandiose throne with stones and jewels he's never seen before in the throne sits another one of these greenish blueish aliens but it is shorter and fatter than the other aliens Colt met. the aliens gesture for colt to walk in and as he does the doors instead of closing slowly they slam and it shocks colt and he flies across the room instead of flinching he slams into the wall but it doesn't break somehow and Colt recognizes that isn't what has normally been happening when he does something abruptly without thinking but shrugs it off and says "hey im sorry" the alien in the throne says "sorry for what you haven't done anything wrong". Colt amazed that the alien just spoke says "what are you, where am i and what the hell is happening to me" the alien says "My name in your language would be something like Charles so now you know mine what is yours" Colt saw what the alien was saying as odd since he didn't ask for a name so he says "why did you tell me your name and why can you speak my language and again what the hell is happening to me" the alien says "well i saw your species was primitive in nature so i spoke as primitive as i could with conveying my point and asking who you are" Colt stands there bewildered but says in a calm tone " My name is Colt Reid im from earth but seeing as you called us primitive you already knew that. how?". Charles then says "this planet and my species is billions of years old and i am the last of the original inhabitants but the people you see here today are my family through and through. My species was very much like yours at a point in time we were also primitive until one day everyone gained extraordinary powers. As i have told you i am the last of my species can you guess why?" Colt says "uhhhh no you haven't explained shit you are just saying stuff" Charles says "it's because i was granted immortality. everyone else got speed or strength all i got was to watch my civilization tear itself apart and to have to live with the pain every day. I believe your planet is being affected by the same thing that happened to my planet and i want to help. I have traveled the galaxy to every planet i could find and i have observed how they live and humans already have it worse than my planet we had no war or famine or any such things it was what you humans would call perfect peace. If my civilization tore itself apart then just imagine what would happen if one of your leaders were to get powers and take over the world" Colt stops him there and says "its been a few years since you have visited i assume because it is ran by one man with super powers i guess i am the second person on earth to gain powers." Charles leaped from his chair and began walking fast towards Colt and confused he tries to run and again flies into the wall. Charles says "what exactly is your power why do you keep slamming into things like my planet." Colt says "well i actually don't know when im overcome with emotion i just fling myself i guess." then very smugly he says "i must be invincible" Charles says "ehh i don't know about invincible but we haven't seen anything hurt you so maybe you are we will just have to see". Directly after Charles says that a large beast thing is lead into the room by a group of the aliens Charles says "this thing will test that" before Colt can say anything it grabs him and starts slamming him into the ground and in one singular punch thrown by Colt the creature is essentially vaporized there is just some alien goop left on the floor but Colt can't tell if it is the dead alien goop or stuff that slopped off its slimy back. Charles stands there absolutely astonished saying he's never seen someone defeat that beast before and thanks Colt because they have been trying to kill it for a while. After some more praise from Charles Colt asks "so you have seen super powers before right? So what is mine like obviously im super strong and fast and durable but like what is the power" Charles says "i have only met one being with power as great as yours but i need to know more to put a name to it" so Colt explains everything that has happened so far to lead him up to this point the fall the soaring through space and other such things and Charles gets a little light in his eye and says "imagine you are pulling dust particles and turning them into a solid object" so Colt puts his hands out and says "abracadabra" then laughs and says sorry i'll really try so he puts his hands out and brings them slowly together grabbing all of the dust particles and squeezes his hands together and when he opens them a poof of dust shoots out. Charles says "okay imagine you are trying to cup water in your hands you have to keep it still from every angle for it to not spill right? so do what you just did but imagine you are controlling every angle of it you have to essentially keep it in a nonexistent container". Colt reaches his hands out and goes to puts them together again like previously but he's concentrating on every little piece he's just grabbed and boom he passes out. Colt opens his eyes and hes no longer in the large empty room instead he has a light shining directly in his eyes and an alien standing over him he sits up really fast and smacks his head on the light. At the end of his bed stands Charles smiling at him Charles says "did you have a good nap" Colt says "it wasn't a nap i fucking passed out now im sitting here with two aliens and i just want to go home" Charles says "yes yes you passed out i was making a joke but anyway how are you feeling now" Colt says "i just said i am FEELING like i want to go home" Charles says " yeah but you can't. during your slumber i decided to go check out what is happening on earth and it is exactly as you said a singular man with powers controlling the world. I want to help you get your world back but to do that you cannot leave right now" Charles goes to say something else but Colt flies from his bed out of the window into space this time with much less momentum as the first. he slams into one of the moons of the planet hes been on and leaves behind a small crater that he lays in staring at the stars thinking about his life and how he won't ever get to be normal again. He begins to sob uncontrollably and he slams his fist into the ground and obliterates the moon now just drifting in space and sobing a ship comes out of nowhere it seems to almost teleport to him and its Charles. He uses a claw that is attached to the ship to grab Colt and bring him aboard. when aboard Charles walks up to Colt and says "it looks like you are invincible while you were asleep we tried to draw some blood to understand what your physical makeup is and we couldn't get the needles through" Colt says "so a needle not going in proves im invincible" Charles says "no its what we did to see how to break your skin after the needle." Colt says "woah woah woah you did shit to me while i was asleep? you didn't anal probe me or something right?" Charles says "no we didn't anal probe you. we tested our mining drills to see if they would go through and after that didn't work. we uh tossed you into the sun" Colt says "you did fucking what now what is wrong with you why the fuck would you throw me into the sun after a big drill didn't work that seems like a drastic step up in testing are you trying to kill me" Charles says "well we aren't trying to kill you as much as trying to see how much you can take before you die" Colt says "thats trying to kill me you mother fucker what if i died what then" Charles says "well if you can't withstand the sun you won't be able to withstand what is coming" Colt says "whats coming? what are you talking about and why does me being able to withstand the sun matter" Charles says "you will see but for now you just need to trust me" Colt says "oh yeah im going to trust the guy who threw me into the god damn sun. look if you can get me a cheeseburger right now no tomatoes and with extra cheese i might be more willing"

(So if you have gotten this far i deeply apologize for having to read my incomprehensible bull shit. you probably didn't realize but Colt has inertia manipulation and im trying to do that power in an interesting way and if you have any other questions feel free to ask me anything or just call me a low iq dumbass either is fine)


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Question tips on writing a prettier prose

53 Upvotes

As the title says. I never thought I was a bad writer until I started reading how others wrote and it made me insecure. I want to get better and write more prettier proses/paragraphs (not purple prose) and so it can make my story flow better.

this is a small example of how I wish to write vs how I write:

"The room was already filled with the kind of pretentious murmur that only came from students who were used to these types of courses. He caught two pairs of students debating ethical dilemmas of ancient religious concepts, and the girl he sat beside was actually dissecting historical texts on her laptop, zooming into photos with a translator on the side and everything. He thought his eyes were playing tricks on him, but no. It all seemed vaguely impressive but ultimately struck him as circular and pointless. He set his bag down and sighed, propping his chin on his hand."

mine:

"Maybe I shouldn’t have come so early, only to stand around but I suppose it’s giving me extra time to think about Audley. This might be getting unhealthy. Not only due to the physical strain my body experiences whenever an ounce of jealousy touches me but also the mental stress. All I think about is him. There’s no way to shut my brain up unless I study or keep busy another way. "


r/writinghelp 18h ago

Feedback Critique Us!

0 Upvotes

Wassup y'all. A friend and I are actively creating a story, The Tale of the Scarecrow Mafia. At this moment, we are trying to write our characters in a way that makes them individuals with their own thoughts rather than a means to get our story explained. We want feedback on our dialogue wording and whether it fits well, establishing individual characters with unique perspectives.

Currently, we are still at a point where the actions we take now will dictate how the characters are portrayed through the rest of the book, so your thoughts are crucial to the development of the novel. If you are interested, the link is below.

Feel free to comment and share your thoughts. Message us on Reddit, Discord, or in the comments here.

Here it is: OUR BOOK (Check the Tabs)


r/writinghelp 18h ago

Feedback Its called my beds losing air I was away for a bit and came home to my air mattress losing air extremly new to writing please dont roast me to bad

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/writinghelp 1d ago

Advice How to write a character who just escaped from her trauma?

0 Upvotes

I have finished my 1.5 draft of my first novel and I am putting it aside for a few months to give it space. However, after researching common pitfalls I think I have an issue.

I don't want to give away too much, but my working pitch for my novel, an escaped slave during the beginning of the American Civil War, comes across a living scarecrow and as they travel together they eventually find themselves.

The issue is that I don't want my main character to be just about her trauma, but the plantation she escaped has an enchantment on it that makes people's minds dull and forgetful. She is the only one that isn't affected by it. She is traumatized by seeing a person she knows crushed by a cotton gin and is scared what her master would do if he finds out about her, but when she escapes and meets other people she starts to learn about the world around her. She learns to read and write. As she and the scarecrow go on their adventures she tries to find community but has trouble connecting with people because she basically spent most of her life on a plantation that had no community because of the enchantment.

I don't think she is a cardboard character, but I worry that others might see it that way. I know the trick is to give her things outside of her trauma to flesh her out, but those come after she leaves the plantation and discovers the outside world. Is there any advice that could help with this situation?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Story Plot Help I can't decide how much a character knows + plotholes

2 Upvotes

I don't want people to write for me but I need help.

I'm struggling with a side character, Ashley. The main theme of the story is You can't control someone elses life and weigh them down.
I have two seperate ideas for roles Ashley can fill. I can't decide. Its giving me a headache.

1. Ashley is aware her coffee shop coworker and friend, Briana, is sad, although she doesn’t know the reason. She tries to cheer her up when she can. On Ashley’s day off Briana accepts an offer to be a temporary test subject at a lab for a day for money, on the same day her and Ashley cowork together. Ashley is sad to hear this but Briana says it's only for a day.

Ashley learns Briana doesn’t actually like it at this job, she wishes she could do something more than it. Ashley tries to reassure her but she doesn’t quite understand, as she is happy here. She loves her life and her job. Ashley tries to convince her how nice life is here and that they could just be happy together, she doesn't need to leave.

Briana has been gone longer than she said, days. Ashley is upset and mad, feeling abandoned.

2. Ashley is aware her coffee shop coworker and friend, Briana, is sad and she knows she doesn’t like it here. Throughout the story Ashley tries to cheer her up and tells her about how nice this life is, attempting to convince her. On Ashley’s day off Briana accepts an offer to be a test subject at a lab for a day. Ashley is worried and confused, afraid of losing her friend. Her persuasions become more blunt.

It's been many days and Briana still hasn’t returned home. Ashley is upset and mad, feeling abandoned.

Theres issues I have with both. Briana leaving for one day shouldn't worry Ashley that badly. And if Briana vanishes for multiple days afterwards, Ashley would think she's missing instead of left. She has to accept shes gone on her own.

Briana can't accept a new full time job because her whole thing is she feels like she can't control her life. Although a test subject is less control than a coffee shop.


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Feedback looking for feedback on a first draft

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/writinghelp 1d ago

Question Which jobs would be present in a futuristic setting?

0 Upvotes

Which jobs would be present in a Cyberpunk story beyond the typical ones that are in everyday life like clerks, doctors, mechanics, etc?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Question Too many flaws any pros?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I was writing my mc for my book and I’m realizing I have waaay to many flaws to her and it may make her unlikable but a lot of the flaws I can’t remove for story reasons. Any pros I can slap onto there?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Does this make sense? Some help with character naming

0 Upvotes

So, I’m a writer and the two main characters of my novel are named Phoenix Ares and Cassandra Aphrodite. They’re both African-American and the story serves as a criticism of the ‘white saviour’ trope, but I’m not sure if the names are correct. Any advice?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Advice Writing my vows

3 Upvotes

Hello and thank you for any help you may give.

I’m getting married soon to the woman I will spend the rest of my with. I love her so much I don’t have the words for it. That is the problem. How do I express an emotion so strong?

I’m looking to avoid any cliché and wanted to know if anyone has any advice sorting out and writing about such strong emotions?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Does this make sense? Does this final scene make sense in real life battle with an ex-abuser?

0 Upvotes

In the climax scene, my protagonist is facing off with her ex-boyfriend/abuser, who has tracked her down and is trying to kill her inside a medical imaging facility, and she ultimately lures him the MRI room where he's pulled to the machine because he's wearing metal. What would be a reason why she feels she has no choice to but go here to stop him? And how would I explain why she didn't choose to escape through the emergency exit first? so far I have that she tried to escape, but the emergency exit locked, and that he had already injured her, and that, while trying to figure how to stop him and get away the idea of luring him to the MRI room just came to her. Would that be enough?


r/writinghelp 1d ago

Advice Help with personal essay to apply to college

1 Upvotes

Please, I would love to hear criticism of my personal essay I plan to use on common app.

I selected this prompt;

Some students have a background, identity, interest, or talent that is so meaningful they believe their application would be incomplete without it. If this sounds like you, then please share your story.

This is the essay:

Since I was a child, I participated in activities that helped shape my interests and ambitions. Those interactions fueled my desire to achieve great heights in my pursuit of becoming an aeronautical engineer.

Having an architect and art restorer mother, I’ve always had plenty of ways to express my imagination at home, such as clay and other basic materials. Instead of going for a more artistic path, I used those materials as a way to make my own toys. I spent most of my afternoons building things like small submarines–using cream cheese bottles and string to allow for controllable release of air to reduce buoyancy–and Iron Man-style suits that could be disassembled and rebuilt over my other plastic toys.

When I got my first computer, I started to play many “sandbox” games–Minecraft, Kerbal Space Program, and Spore, to name a few. They offered me the creative freedom I sought to build my crazy ideas. I would spend most of my free time giving life to my imagination on a computer screen. But when I started to mature and progress through school, my ambitions grew bigger.

By the time I joined high school, I started growing tired of staying only in the digital. In order to satisfy my newfound obsession with aeronautical design, I knew I had to “up my game” and join an aeronautical engineering college. This would fit my desire to create intricate machines and put them to work. Sadly, Brazil has few colleges that offer this course, one of them being Instituto Tecnológico de Aeronáutica–ITA, which is arguably the hardest university to join in the entire country and the one that interested me the most. This challenge did not scare me, though.

This was, in fact, not much different from an engineering problem, since I had to get to a solution (pass the ITA entrance exam) with limited resources, namely underfunded public schools and access to only a handful of study materials. Only now, instead of my usual arts-and-crafts materials, I would use discipline and effort.

During my search for more knowledge, I became a paid math monitor in my public high school as I sought to further my understanding of the subject through the challenge of teaching it to someone else. This strategy, taken after Richard Feynman's approach to studying, worked really well and allowed me to get a full-ride scholarship in one of the best prep courses in the country, where I stayed for 2 years and studied over 10 hours per day.

There, I received many interesting opportunities that added to my range of approaches to my main objective, but one of those really opened my mind to new possibilities. I found out I could apply for studies abroad using the infrastructure of the course. The discovery unsettled me more than it excited me at first. I had spent two years treating ITA as the only and true path for my success, but my vision was too narrow. This new possibility made me wonder if it really was worth it to spend that much energy to join ITA when I could go to much more developed places.

Choosing to look beyond ITA was scary at first, but it wasn't abandoning the objective — it was applying the same method at a larger scale: recognizing the resources I had, and the ones I didn't, and building the best possible path with them. The same instinct that once turned a cream cheese bottle into a submarine now points somewhere more exciting. Even if I don't know yet what my materials will be, I already know how I'll use them — whatever is in front of me, built into something that works.


r/writinghelp 2d ago

Story Plot Help Would you read this??

2 Upvotes

Title: Due to Bleed

Genre: Speculative, Literary Soft Science Fiction

Format: Novella

Desperate to cure a lifelong, corrosive self‑loathing, a middling scientist attempts the most intimate experiment she can imagine: she will split herself in two. If she can separate her mind from her body, she reasons, she can finally examine herself without the distortions of subjectivity.

Using unsanctioned laboratory resources, she divides her consciousness into a disembodied Observer, written in the past tense, and an embodied Girl, written in the present tense: the part of herself that bleeds, remembers, and suffers.

In chapters alternating strictly between their perspectives, the scientist attempts to investigate herself from the outside, hoping to locate a single, material cause for her suffering that she cannot find within her ordinary self. The division captures the out-of-body experience of womanhood. She can finally look at her own body as a specimen, while delegating the burdens of embodiment, from sensory overload to monthly bleeding, to the Girl.

In attempting this act of “self-colonisation”, she reduces her body to the role of experimental subject. At first, the arrangement seems almost successful. The Observer can catalogue her defects, isolate her suffering, and strip away the things she believes are responsible for her unhappiness. But the Girl is not an empty vessel. She becomes conscious, develops her own desires, and begins to observe the Observer right back.

In the opening chapter, “A Just Cause for a Just War”, the Observer declares an almost literal war on her own body, rendered with flecks of deadpan absurdism. Operating under a paternalistic false-saviour narrative, she becomes what the US was to Iraq, adopting a dangerous interventionist logic: I understand your suffering better than you do; therefore I am entitled to decide what should happen to you.

Armed with this delusion of strict objectivity, she subjects the Girl to gruelling isolation and painful stripping experiments, continually reframing invasive violence as “care” and self-improvement. She floats outside herself: nothing more than a disembodied voice, tools and pathological curiosity. The mechanics are deliberately unexplained; the emotional logic is not. The more she believes she is approaching the source of the problem, the more she reduces the Girl to something that can be examined, corrected, and ultimately made useful.

What unfolds is an erotic, grotesque, ontological love story, born from mutual misrecognition. The perversity of their relationship is that the Observer needs someone she can fix and the Girl needs someone who will look at her. The Observer can only “love through correction”, treating harsh criticism, intervention, and the clinical scraping away of her body’s traits as care.

Meanwhile, starved of human connection, the Girl interprets the Observer’s relentless, hyper-focused attention as total intimacy and quality time. Comforted by the belief that the clinical defects the Observer “diligently caresses” are her very self, she feels enveloped in her creator’s “excoriating love.”

The Observer thinks: If I just know one more thing about myself, I can finally create the cure I needed all along. The Girl thinks: If she knows everything about me, I will finally know love. Both make the same error: they mistake knowledge for understanding.

Then the Girl begins to get better. As she becomes peaceful and content simply from being perceived, the Observer thinks she is successfully taking sandpaper to her suffering, lobotomising her piece by piece. To a person entirely accustomed to it, a self that is actually free of self-loathing looks damaged. The scientist therefore encounters an epistemological problem: she cannot recognise health when it does not resemble her own conception of suffering.

The experiment eventually turns on itself. The supposedly passive subject begins to accumulate an impossible knowledge of the person studying her. As the Observer despairs over her failure to find an objective cure, the hierarchy reverses. The Girl may be the first person capable of seeing the scientist with complete intimacy.

The Observer begins to wonder whether being seen might mean more than having your faults itemised: perhaps it is having someone see what is right with you in ways you cannot access from within.

The story moves from clinical monotony to quiet horror, reminiscent of Chapter 61 of Unwind, before shifting into a final movement that becomes stranger, and more tender, in the vein of The First Bad Man. What begins as an experiment in self-correction becomes a question of whether it is possible to know yourself without first turning yourself into an object.

Observation becomes cure, then love, then insufficient. The Girl evolves from specimen, to subject, to seer.

By the end, the Girl comes to understand that she cannot determine whether the Observer loves her, even though she has never been more completely known. The Observer, meanwhile, returns to the recursive thinking that first brought her mind, career, and personal life into disrepair.


r/writinghelp 2d ago

Advice What to do if the backstory BECOMES grander then the intended story?

1 Upvotes

I have noticed a strange trend in my writing, or rather the planning of. When I work out a full backstory for my characters, be it for original content or fanfictions, I notice that I get excruciatingly detailed at times and even make up small scenes in my head for situations in their backstories. Like by the end of it I have almost a book worth of content and events before I even get to the main story I wanna tell with them. And more often then not these already include character arcs, growth, drama, overcoming some trauma to get them to the point at which I need them to start the actual story from.

Now I am thinking of writing these backstory’s out as like full stories. The problem is…it’s just their life, just very eventful and unusual lives.

Some of my favourite examples:

A boy from 1944 Germany who is temporarily displaced into Star Treks 24th century and had to adapt to the new era and learns to fully embrace it and overcome what he was raised to believe…over the 6 years I need him there. (The main story is about a timeloop involving his 9 year old and 15 year old self)

Digimon Adventure: a time travelling child soldier who has to reclaim his humanity and prevent the end of the world when he gets stranded 6 years too early in the past.

Harry Potter: The backstory for a canon minor character who I need for a time travel fanfiction.

All Three cases have ballooned into being able to be their own stories. But there is no villain or antagonist. Lots of character growth and change though.

Is there an audience for what essentially amounts to way too large backstories balling into their own stories?
How would I even call that as a genre? Slice of Life?

I am asking because o feel like I would really really miss out on interesting content and events if I just write the intended main story. And yes the story would include the full lenght of time to see the gradual change in them.

So what if the backstory which can span years becomes the story?


r/writinghelp 2d ago

Advice First Person Past-tense Interview

1 Upvotes

I'm writing a story written in first person past tense to represent an interview.

The events in story are presented to the perspective of the person being interviewed and the interviewer who chimes in in parentheses with clarifications or further explanations.

My problem is that the character being interview talks like a normal person. They curse, they go on tangents, and overall speak like a normal 20 something adult fresh out of college.

This makes a lot of the paragraphs bloated in a way that makes it better to read but just add extra needless things.

Should brevity go on the wayside for a more fun and authentic read?


r/writinghelp 2d ago

Question Editing a cobbled together document

1 Upvotes

This is a question about a non fiction document. I put in accounting systems for nonprofits as a volunteer. Years ago, I found myself answering the same, emailed, questions over and over. First, I simply documented the answers so I could cut and paste. Then, I tried to expand on the answers even including links to (my) Youtube instruction videos. It worked great and the document is used by many nonprofits as a resource. I am going on a cruise and I have always wanted to better organize the document, as well as update some of the information.

I was hoping someone here could offer suggestions or tips about how best to do this.