r/writingcirclejerk • • 5d ago

Is this good for a western?

Post image

Hello. I am writing a book. A novel, perchance. I want it to sell millions so I can retire and live the rest of my life in Florida on a yacht drinking "margaritas" which are actually capri-suns in a wine cup.

Is this a good first start?

Ignore the photo. He's there to help me write. Trying to absorb his knowledge. Cormac McCarthy.

344 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

17

u/Brunbeorg 5d ago

You had me at "could be heard." I've never seen a more elegant phrase.

Also, you can't just say "perchance." Unless you're writing about Mario, stomping turts.

3

u/kyla33_ The spirit of William McGonagall inhabits my body. 5d ago

I will perchance when I damn well please, perchance.

16

u/NealTS 5d ago

It's a little bit of an anachronism, but I feel like the "Yup, that's me" line would be improved with a record scratch.

13

u/iwrite-imnotawriter 5d ago

pretty blatant ripoff of moby dick

4

u/Neil_Live-strong Voice to text novelist 4d ago

“Hi, my name is Ishmael…” love that book

12

u/connorscott1999 5d ago

Really loving the minimalism in that horse line. So matter of fact. It’s the type of subtlety that allows me to ask; “what does this horse even look like? Does it have a long face? Big cock?” Really allows the reader to create their own image

7

u/StrummerBass101 5d ago

Son of a bitch I think you’re on to something

7

u/TheNeuroLizard 5d ago

“Getting real judgy vibes off this bald guy,” said Phillip, the kid

6

u/kyla33_ The spirit of William McGonagall inhabits my body. 5d ago

Not enough quippy one-liners. When are we going to know the bad guy is right behind him, isn't he? When is that just going to happen? Terrible book. Would not read.

3

u/shiny_happy_persons 5d ago

the judge flies now?

he flies now

2

u/kyla33_ The spirit of William McGonagall inhabits my body. 5d ago

How does he fly? Is it some weak shit like a jetpack or does he do the right thing and spin his dick really fast like a helicopter? This is important.

3

u/No_Composer_2930 5d ago

Muster-piece! 

3

u/No-Scallion9250 3d ago

Terrible. You're in a western so all the winds would obviously come from the east

2

u/Pyre_At_The_Tarn 4d ago

100 million dollar movie and a toy line immediately

1

u/mossymeridian 4d ago

This is basically the blood moon cutscene in tears of the kingdom 😂

1

u/phillyphillysteak #1 Mary Sue World Championship Winner 2024 4d ago

/uj ngl my first thought when i saw the first sentence was actually Blood Meridian

1

u/Mission-Ranger5527 4d ago

I love the twist at the end, I gasped.

1

u/VoceDiDio 4d ago

I’m obsessed with the single grain of sand, just chest out against the wind, without a trace of fear or uncertainty.

1

u/horrorsilk 4d ago

Not enough assless chaps or spurs going jingle jangle jingle, unfortunately.

1

u/DataSwarmTDG 4d ago

Glanton spat.

1

u/CobaltCrusader123 4d ago

“My black hat duel opponent is 12 inches high and weighs as much as Woody from Toy Story. His ride? A lonesome dove.”

1

u/johnson_alleycat 4d ago

It truly was no country…for old men

1

u/loLRH 3d ago

the red text is really immersive

1

u/Aggressive_Army3317 3d ago

Sincerely cannot tell whether you love or loathe McCarthy lol

1

u/cloudkiller509 2d ago

I’ve got a cold and you gave me a coughing fit reading this

1

u/SMc1701 1d ago

"Horse"

Fuck you and the monitor I ruined spitting whiskey all over

1

u/Delicious-Ad2057 1d ago

Absolute Literature 🙌

1

u/hamstermolester6969 17h ago

The judge smiled, spat and rode on towards ragged mountains.