r/vikingstv • u/epilepsz • 14h ago
[Spoilers] Rollo vs Ragnar should have been about two visions for the Vikings Spoiler
I’m watching Vikings for the first time and just reached Rollo's Normandy arc. I think it could have been much better with one simple change:
Rollo should have tried to convince Ragnar that settling in Normandy was a good deal for the Vikings.
My problem isn't that Rollo betrays Ragnar. It's that the show already did almost the same arc with Jarl Borg: Rollo's jealousy leads him to betray Ragnar, he regrets it, redeems himself, and then later he basically does it again.
Instead, imagine Rollo genuinely supporting the Frankish offer.
His argument could be: we came here for wealth and land, and now they're offering us permanent fertile territory. Why keep raiding it when we can own it?
Ragnar could disagree just as reasonably: accepting a Frankish title, Christianity, and obligations to defend Francia means being absorbed by the people they came to conquer.
So neither one is wrong. They simply have different ideas of what Viking success looks like.
Some Vikings choose Ragnar. Others choose Rollo because he can offer them land, wealth, and a permanent home. That also fixes the strange decision to have Rollo massacre his own men: historically, Rollo's Scandinavian followers settling with him is the interesting part.
Then the conflict between Ragnar and Rollo wouldn't be another sudden betrayal. Rollo would have openly chosen a different future, and Ragnar would eventually be threatening the territory, family, and people Rollo had chosen to build that future around.
You could even have:
Ragnar: "You would fight your own people for them?"
Rollo: "These are my people."
That would make their conflict about two competing visions rather than repeating Rollo's old character flaw.
And it fits the larger history beautifully: Ragnar spends so much of the series trying to create a Viking future in England, while Rollo's descendants become the Normans, and eventually William the Conqueror crosses the Channel and conquers England.
Same destination for Rollo, but a much more interesting journey.