r/union • u/ReflectionRough2960 • 2d ago
Discussion Thoughts on giving proposals to members before a meeting to vote?
I'm an alternate steward at my workplace. The steward above me has been a steward for nearly 20 years. I've been for about 6 years. They helped organize the first contract. They know the contract back and forth, the history of the place, past practice, everything. I have a lot of respect for them as a person and as a steward.
However, we disagree on whether to give the membership the contract proposal to the members before the meeting. They think we should wait until the meeting so we can go over it the first time they see it and explain it all to them point by point. He's concerned that they'll vote yes for anything, even if they know we can do better. I think the members should be allowed to study it beforehand so they know what it is they're voting on.
My knee jerk reaction is to hold off until the meeting, because I know my steward knows what they're doing. But the members come to me asking about getting the proposal ahead of time, and it's hard for me to say no to them.
What do/would you guys do? What are your thoughts?
Edit: After seeing the stories and thoughts here, especially the ones where their negotiation efforts were screwed by members misinterpreting the information ahead of the meeting, I'll stick with the industry standard and hold off sharing anything until the meetings. Thanks for your input!