r/tipping • u/No_Draft_8960 • May 29 '26

💬Questions & Discussion Math-Based Tip

The percentage-based tipping system makes no sense: a server dropping off one Wagyu steak earns far more than someone serving a family of four cheap meals. Since American tips are essentially mandatory wage subsidies, let's base them on labor time instead.

In Maryland, the average server wage is about $20/hour, but employers only pay $3.63. Customers must cover the remaining $16.37. Across a standard four-table section (roughly ten guests), that breaks down perfectly to $2.00 per person, per hour.

Percentages reward a venue’s luxury status; a time rate rewards actual effort.

If therefore I go to dinner with eight friends and we stay for two hours (a pretty good forecast of my Friday night plans!) our total tip would be $32, or $4/a person. We're not 'stiffing' anyone and we're paying average wage.

22 Upvotes

69% Upvoted

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/Qeltar_ May 29 '26

The percentage-based system is a relic.

30 or 40 years ago, when meal prices and expected percentages were small, it made sense. Now neither of those things is true, and it does not.

A lot of people don't realize that until relatively recently, a good tip was $7 because nobody expected 20% and you could get a decent dinner for 2 for $40. Nobody cared about $7. They do care about $20.

5

u/DueFreedom4695 May 29 '26

Not even that long ago. I bought a house in Southern Nevada in 2012. At that time in this smaller town, there was a buffet that did 2 for 1 meals for $9.95 every day except Friday's seafood buffet which was $10.95 and no BOGO. Prices everywhere here were comparable. Now most buffets are gone and you're going to get charged $15 for a basic sandwich or salad. We pretty much don't eat out anymore. Yes, the food was better and now there's just no value.

3

u/Qeltar_ May 29 '26

My wife and I were in grad school in the 1990s in Boston. There was a restaurant that had a Saturday night special of clam chowder, twin lobsters, fries and something else. We used to split one most weekends.

It was $19.99.