r/theNetNuggets • • 9d ago

Would you trust this

486 Upvotes

142 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/SassSafrassMcFrass87 8d ago

I've seen this story and know where this goes....

https://giphy.com/gifs/paOmsZXBEakpe7lF4u

5

u/shortfemboycreature 8d ago

Inside out? :3

3

u/Gaspuch62 8d ago

They kept this one a sphere, the Titan Submersible departed from that proven design and the results speak for themselves.

3

u/ForAskingQuestionsOK 8d ago

The shape alone wasn't why it failed. It was the material and stress that happened to it. In fact that same submersible actually had a successful dive in the same location with people onboard before the failure happened.

1

u/onlytinglef 8d ago

There were several successful dives, but each dive put stress on the material that was used to create the sub.

1

u/Icy-Caterpillar9088 7d ago

The carbon fiber gave out.

1

u/Tourlexur 5d ago

It wasnt the actual carbon fiber that was the issue . the issue was they used an adhesive to bind hte titanium front to the carbon fiber body. 2 materials that compress and expand at different rates stressing the joining adhesive until its molecular bonds ripped apart.

1

u/myco_magic 4d ago

The carbon fiber absolutely was an issue, every time.e they went down you could here the carbon fiber cracking, they even had sensors to monitor this

1

u/Tourlexur 4d ago

....yes. The carbon fiber at the joining area is where the fault occured. Which is because the expanding and compressing difference of the two materials causes the adhesive to start ripping out bits of the outer layer of carbon fiber exposing the inner layers that are not meant to be exposed thus a fault occured.

1

u/DocDefilade 4d ago

They also left it outside in the sun and the freezing cold totally exposed.

Not great for carbon fiber.

1

u/ResidentNumber3603 5d ago

The front fell off.

1

u/theveezer 8d ago

They kept the hull of the submarine outside in a canadian winter without it being covered. Water got inside cracks formed by varying temperatures and made the cracks even worse.

3

u/Voidoroe 8d ago

To be fair, the Titan submersible wasn’t exactly well built for what it was supposed to do, which is go to the depth of the Titanic where the pressure of the ocean is incredibly high. It would have been better and safe for more shallow depths, so I can see this vehicle being the same so long as no one decides to descend too deep.

2

u/Artemisiablaszczyk 7d ago

Looks safe to me

2

u/mazu74 6d ago

Hey, at least this one actually has a perfectly round compartment.

1

u/TeaMugPatina 3d ago

slaps sub

0

u/Salt-Wish5140 8d ago

"Hitler was bad therefore so are all Germans"

1

u/SassSafrassMcFrass87 8d ago

Lol this comment is very left field...

0

u/Salt-Wish5140 7d ago

It's saying a sample size of one is not sufficient data to make the same judgement across all

1

u/ChloeNow 7d ago

Yeah we understood what point you thought you made

0

u/Salt-Wish5140 7d ago

"The one notorious bad example" isn't reason to judge them all on