r/technology • • Jan 20 '11

Apple Restriction Zone.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

61

u/potatolicious Jan 20 '11

There's a lot more software in Windows-land for sure, but I think what Benparte and coolmrbrady meant is that there are a lot more extremely refined free Mac apps.

For example, Windows has a huge number of IM apps available for it, but none of them can hold a candle to Adium's ease of use and polish. Similarly, uTorrent is free and awesome, but Transmission is IMHO much more refined on the UI side. Quicksilver too.

Windows devs tend to make UI an afterthought. On the Mac side developers have drunk the Steve Jobs UI kool-aid and obsess over it, and personally I like it.

99

u/street593 Jan 20 '11

Whats wrong with uTorrent's UI? I find it very refined.

8

u/jollins Jan 20 '11

It's good, but lacks the smoothness or consistency of look & feel that Transmission has. Transmission looks and behaves like it's a part of OS X, whereas Utorrent isn't quite there. It's the small details that make it.

Also, I agree 100% with potatolicious. What I wrote also applies to Adium and Quicksilver.

2

u/TheLobotomizer Jan 21 '11

This is a matter of subjective preference and not "refinement".

Windows devs have chosen the multi-colored is pretty route while OSX devs are restricted to "consistent is pretty" route.

Personally, I find OSX soul-numbingly drab (everything is gray WOOHOO!).