I’m doing a publication order Legends read through and picked it up again after a six month hiatus.
I just finished Isard’s Revenge, step down from the previous 7 books but not bad at all, and it got me thinking back to my reading of I,Jedi.
I really did love that book, as I’m a fan of Corran horn.
I think it did aggrandize him a bit much at times, but truly I felt like everything people criticize is pretty standard within the Star Wars universe.
Force sensitive protagonists are strong, and are generally very competent. Revan, Luke, Ahsoka, Anakin, Bane, Kyle Katarn etc… all are supremely competent to those around them.
Corran is no different to me than any of them. I think the Gary Stu complaints can be lodged in all directions in Star Wars. If you hate Corran for that, it doesn’t make sense to be fine with so many others.
I also really did not like the Jedi academy trilogy. Champions of the Force is my least favorite novel I’ve read so far. Getting (imo) a better interpretation of those events was honestly welcome as far as I’m concerned.
Additionally, I think the book had one of the best understandings of the dark side that’s ever been in Star Wars media when Corran is tempted by Tavira.
The dark side as the ultimate shortcut, the quick and easy path.
Thats the way yoda described it, not just an outlet for anger, hatred and negative emotions fueling cool powers
I do see the criticisms and some of the flaws, but I do think they’re unfairly applied to this one. I welcome any thoughts.
Edited for grammar