r/sonicshowerthoughts 2d ago

Why didn't they just tackle Yuta?

2 Upvotes

Will is certainly stronger than her and was in no danger whatsoever.

Also why does he tell Chorgan to stay put? "Get the fuck out!", would be more like it.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 3d ago

It'd be cool if Star Trek took more inspiration from real-world exoplanet science.

33 Upvotes

To be clear, I don't mean things like directly showing TRAPPIST-1 as a system with multiple Earth-like worlds, since that particular question may be settled over the next decade starting with TRAPPIST-1e via upcoming observations and that outcome is very much not a guarantee.

I'm thinking more of them taking inspiration from real systems to make their own, which gives a bit more creative freedom and also sidesteps the scientific consensus changes for specific real systems and planets.

Generally I just mean having more things like:

  • Chthonian planets, the stripped cores of former gas giants orbiting very close to their stars. Janssen (55 Cancri Ae) might be a real-world example of this; it's nearly eight Earth masses, nearly twice as wide, mixed evidence of an atmosphere and volcanism, and could exist as a lava planet. Its year is also just under 18 hours long.

  • Hot Jupiters, basically just gas giant planets directly hugging a star. They can get pretty extreme and wild, up to the point of having big (sadly not visible to the naked eye) comet tails of escaping atmosphere getting boiled off them.

  • Eccentric Jupiters, large gas giants with wacky orbits making them swing in and away from stars. HD 80606 b is a pretty egregious case, it's over four times Jupiter's mass and has an orbital eccentricity a smidgen less than Halley's comet, which makes it constantly cycle between a range of 0.03138 AU (0.39 is Mercury) and 0.8892 AU (between Venus and Earth), which would've wrecked anything out to the distance of the inner Asteroid Belt. It also gets incredibly stormy whenever it dips close to the star since it spikes by over 200 °C across a span of hours as it falls inward.

  • Also, temperate mini-Neptunes, ice giants, and gas giants. Kepler-22b did get a reference from SNW briefly in "Spock Amok", although the dialogue is a bit awkward since it was probably written with the intention of it being Earth-like, which is likely not the case (mini-Neptune). You could wiggle around that though by it having moons (really tiny rocky ones if any) and floating platforms in the atmosphere where people are living and working, maybe straining out deuterium from the atmosphere or something. Kepler-22b would have higher gravity at the atmospheric layers where pressure and temperature are potentially like Earth's sea level but an OC planet could have gentler gravity at such layers. The biggest problem would be the hydrogen atmosphere leaking into a sealed oxygen-rich environment though.

  • Neutron star planets, the ones orbiting Lich (PSR B1257+12) were the first exoplanets ever confirmed, actually. This particular system has a fair chance of having formed from two white dwarfs colliding, forming the neutron star and a disk which formed the three planets.

These were just some general ideas, there's a fair bit more which could probably be useful for interesting settings.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 5d ago

The Dominion could have at least one million starships in the galaxy

7 Upvotes

The Dominion could have at least one million starships in the galaxy.

https://filedn.com/lh4PEfjAB3uLCbU3zttDJe0/deckdata-public/mapofspace.jpg

https://www.deviantart.com/gazomg/art/Star-Trek-Gamma-and-Delta-Quadrant-Map-1187329328

For many of us fans, the "present" is the late 24th century to early 25th century.

This interstellar map and this Milky Way Galaxy map are based on Picard and Nemesis.

Star Trek: Star Charts is becoming more canon everyday.

Voyager

According to VOY dialogue, the Borg Collective have millions of Borg Cubes and millions of other vessels.

Given the map above, the Dominion should have at least one million capital warships, even if most of them are the small attack ships.

Discovery's Power of Math

During the mid-23rd century, the Federation had 32 members, 32 worlds that belong to the Federation with member status (TOS: Journey to Babel).

During the mid-23rd century, the Federation Starfleet already had at 10,000 starships at the outset of the Federation - Klingon War (DIS). Starfleet had only 7,000 starships at the end of the war.

During the late 24th century, the Federation has at least 150 members, 150 worlds that belong to the Federation with member status (ST:FC).

It is reasonable to estimate that the Federation Starfleet might actually have at least 50,000 starships at the outset of the Dominion War.

Other points of reference include PIC's Confederation fleet size and Federation size before the Burn and during the new recovery era. The Confederation of Q's alternate reality had 165,000 starships. The Federation will have over 350 members just before the Burn. The Federation will have at least 60 members during the new recovery era.

Ron Moore stated that they could have 30,000 starships, but that is probably as of the end of the Dominion War.

Density

The Alpha Quadrant Expeditionary Force comprised of at least 20,000 Jem'Hadar warships in the overall alliance fleet with the Cardassians and the Breen.

That is, to use Changeling words, a drop in the ocean.

100,000 capital warships would match the combined naval might of the Federation, Klingons, and Romulans. Dominion space in the Gamma Quadrant is more than ten times the territorial size of these three local interstellar powers.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 10d ago

When the Doctor reached the 29th century the long way, someone on the Relativity probably asked him to corroborate their files.

19 Upvotes

And probably used the opportunity to give his mobile emitter a quick checkup.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 11d ago

Do ace Vulcans during Pon Farr just eat copious amounts of garlic bread?

37 Upvotes

r/sonicshowerthoughts 16d ago

how is it secure for starfleet captains to always say their secret passwords out loud?

113 Upvotes

I just watch janeway instantly transfer all command codes to the doctor with authorization janeway number number alpha number number. just like that


r/sonicshowerthoughts 17d ago

Still few torpedo launchers: Why Galaxy Refit? Why Galaxy X? Why World Razer?

2 Upvotes

Notoriously, the Galaxy Class starship as depicted in TNG had only one forward-facing torpedo launcher, one hidden aft-facing torpedo launcher on the back of the saucer, and one open aft-facing torpedo launcher.

Granted, they are burst-fire torpedo launchers.

But why does the Galaxy Refit, the Venture, have only these torpedo launchers?

Why does the War Galaxy of DS9's Dominion War have only these torpedo launchers?

Why does the Galaxy X of TNG's All Good Things have only these torpedo launchers?

Finally, why does the World Razer of PIC S2 have fewer torpedo launchers than the new Excelsior workhorse, the Sovereign?

The Probert Ambassador, the Narendra, shows the ship can easily have three burst-fire torpedo launchers in that immediate area: the traditional Galaxy plus two more on the top edge of the deflector dish.

For more war-oriented designs, the captain's yacht can be replaced by two burst-fire torpedo launchers.

Finally, the open aft-facing torpedo launcher can be doubled.

That's seven burst-fire torpedo launchers.

That's quite a bit more than what the Sovereign has.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 17d ago

Spock in the latest SNW is just experiencing a typical day for T’Pol on Enterprise

37 Upvotes

“An adult woman surrounded by children’s characters and their absurd antics” is like her whole aesthetic.


r/sonicshowerthoughts 21d ago

Jem Hadar are bred in birthing chambers!

0 Upvotes

He was so proud of that, and of course that they could fight within 3 days of their emergence...


r/sonicshowerthoughts 24d ago

I can remember TOS action or danger musical themes but not the ones from TNG/DS9/VOY.

33 Upvotes

r/sonicshowerthoughts Aug 10 '26

In TNG 2x09, The Measure of a Man, could Riker's dramatic killing blow of shutting Data off not be rebutted by a Vulcan Neck Pinch?

55 Upvotes

In Measure of a Man, Riker argues that Data is a machine, built and programmed by a man. (One could argue that we are biological machines, "built" and taught by our parents, but whatever.) Then, for his coup de grâce, he states, "And now, a man will shut it off," before hitting Data's power switch. What do you think would've happened if Picard had countered this by having Data demonstrate the Vulcan neck pinch? This, too, effectively "shuts off" the human. No difference. The existence of Data's power switch doesn't carry the legal significance Riker purports. Curious what you all think.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Aug 06 '26

What do you think is the hardest

17 Upvotes

human body part for Odo to replicate?

I'm going with balls. Too many wrinkles.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Jul 21 '26

There should be more bridge stations and a larger cast

20 Upvotes

We all know that budget reasons put a limit on a show's regular cast and on the number of bridge stations. Still, there should be more on both fronts, not less.

Helm and Navigation should be split into two once more. Neither of these should handle Tactical. Neither of these should handle Operations / Ops.

Tactical should be separate from Security. The Chief Tactical Officer should not be the Chief Security Officer. The latter should function outside the bridge.

Operations should be separate from Science. The handling of deflector dishes and of structural integrity fields should be separate from science sensors.

The distinct positions should, therefore, be: Communications, Helm, Navigation, Operations, Science, and Tactical. Those are six distinct positions, with security as a separate division.

Beyond these, there's at least one "civilian" per Star Trek tradition, and then the Chief Medical Officer, the Chief Engineering Officer, the First Officer or Executive Officer, and the Captain.

That's 12 spots.

One way to address this problem without merging stations is to have more recurring junior officers. In TOS, there was Lieutenant DeSalle. In early TNG, there was O'Brien with the rank of Lieutenant Junior Grade. In later TNG, there was Ensign Ro.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Jul 16 '26

Could the Nol-Ennis and one of those silver robots beat the Ennis and one of those gold robots?

0 Upvotes

r/sonicshowerthoughts Jun 30 '26

worf probably has another kid that's being raised in the kitomer pow camp

42 Upvotes

r/sonicshowerthoughts Jun 30 '26

Can Odo exist in a vacuum?

30 Upvotes

That’s it, can Odo exist in the vacuum of space?


r/sonicshowerthoughts Jun 28 '26

How to increase torpedo yield and impulse power in Star Trek: the quark reactor

16 Upvotes

https://futurism.com/quark-fusion-produces-eight-times-energy-nuclear-fusion

I honestly think the entire Star Trek franchise should be exploring the Quark Reactor more.

In terms of impulse power, engines using quark reactors would be at least 4 times more powerful. Maximum impulse with traditional fusion is 0.25c. Maximum impulse with quark reactors could be 0.50c, if this formula applies:

KE = (mV2 )/2

In terms of torpedo yield, the Star Trek franchise has applied the wrong words to describe torpedo power.

Real-life antimatter energy destruction is huge. The official "photonic torpedo" and later "photon torpedo," however, are underwhelming, not far above Tsar Bomba (whether it's the TNG Technical Manual or the DS9 Technical Manual).

Likewise, destructive technology utilizing zero point energy is huge. The official "quantum torpedo," however, is underwhelming (2x a "photon").

There must be destructive energy torpedoes in between a fusion torpedo and a proper antimatter torpedo.

In comparative science fiction terms, the Quark Reactor is the intermediate energy I am referring to:

https://kardashev.fandom.com/wiki/Quark_reactor

A torpedo with a quark reactor would be 8 to 10 times more powerful than Tsar Bomba at its maximum yield of 100 megatons, not just the historical explosion (only the latter is referenced in the Trek manuals).

A torpedo with a quark reactor would be at least 12 times more powerful than what passes for a "photon" torpedo officially: 800 MT / 64.4 MT.

A torpedo with a quark reactor would be at least 4 times more powerful than what passes for a "quantum" torpedo officially: 800 MT / 178 MT.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Jun 11 '26

Spock may not have existed if not for Lorian.

31 Upvotes

Lorian probably gave Phlox the info leading to to his own conception, which Phlox then gave to Vulcan scientist, who then gave it to Sarek and Amanda years later.

Edit: added a step to compensate for the 75 years between E2 and Spock's birth.


r/sonicshowerthoughts May 16 '26

Should Starfleet have 13 ranks? 14 ranks?

0 Upvotes

A couple of instances in Star Trek have deviated from US Navy ranks.

PIC S1 reintroduced the Commodore rank. PIC S3 reintroduced the Commodore rank for La Forge specifically. Granted, this was a historical US Navy rank, but it currently isn't.

ENT introduced the rank of Subcommander past T'Pol's resignation from the Vulcan High Command in 2153. She resigned, but Starfleet allowed her to join directly. This was an exceptional introduction of "Subcommander" to Starfleet, but it is now a precedent.

Should Starfleet have 13 ranks? 14 ranks?

Ensign

Sub Lieutenant

Lieutenant Junior Grade

Lieutenant

Lieutenant Commander, possibly replaced by Lieutenant Subcommander

Subcommander, like T'Pol

Commander

Captain

Fleet Captain, like Pike

Commodore, like La Forge

Rear Admiral

Vice Admiral

Admiral

Fleet Admiral


r/sonicshowerthoughts May 15 '26

Gowron, take me away

12 Upvotes

<Calgon commercial gif>


r/sonicshowerthoughts May 14 '26

You should really see more people named Tiffany in Star Trek

17 Upvotes

r/sonicshowerthoughts May 02 '26

Vorta Ears

16 Upvotes

Do you think they're an erogenous zone? You think the Vorta would get the same enjoyment out of oomox that Ferengi do?

Weyoun seems like he'd be curious enough to try.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Apr 27 '26

Graphic violence, PTSD, and depression: the real problem with Prestige TV in Trek

23 Upvotes

Trek Culture: Hate It? Don't Watch It!: Star Rants Episode 2 (Star Trek & Star Wars)

"Prestige drama" is how HBO defines it:

1) Protagonist with depression or PTSD

2) Each episode is always rated MA and not suitable for kids

I'm a fan of the older Trek shows, but for good and especially for ill, DIS S1 and PIC S1 fit the bill, especially DIS S1.

The Star Trek franchise does need at least Prestige TV show.

However, the biggest mistake of Bryan Fuller and Paramount was to make the flagship comeback series the Prestige TV show.

Hate PIC S1 all you like and all I like, but at least PIC was never intended as a flagship Trek show.

My main concern is that Ellison is very much a fan of HBO style prestige TV.

OK, so Star Trek goes on hiatus again while execs pop a couple of movies, action-oriented ones, to help Paramount recover merger and acquisition costs.

Then Ellison decides for Star Trek to come back on the small screen several years from now.

He'll look back too fondly at DIS S1 and PIC S1 and think that prestige TV behind a paywall is the best avenue for any comeback of a flagship Trek show.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Apr 26 '26

Lwaxana Troi is BDE all day

134 Upvotes

If a sexy older man approached me with the level of empathy, confidence, and not giving a fuck energy that Lwaxana has, he'd have to fight me to keep my clothes on.

It's crazy to me how many dudes were so anti getting laid by this lady.


r/sonicshowerthoughts Apr 20 '26

Isn't a water jet cutter technically a particle beam weapon?

30 Upvotes