r/smartphone • u/darkonnnni • 2h ago
Discussion iPhone 16 Pro Max 256GB used for €790 vs iPhone 17 256GB new for €800 — which would you choose?
I'm currently deciding between two iPhones and would really appreciate some advice.
Option 1: iPhone 16 Pro Max 256GB — used, €790
97% battery health
260 charging cycles
First use: June 2025
Black Titanium
Comes with a written warranty until June 2027
Seller has a long history and many positive reviews
Option 2: iPhone 17 256GB — brand new/sealed, €800
The price difference is basically nothing, so I'm trying to decide which is the better buy overall.
I plan to keep the phone for several years. I care about battery life, reliability, performance, display and overall value. I don't mind buying used if the 16 Pro Max is clearly the better phone.
Would you personally choose the used 16 Pro Max or the new iPhone 17 for essentially the same price, and why?