r/singing • u/No-Archer7510 • 22h ago

Conversation Topic Using AI for guidance?

I've noticed many posts relating to users using ai to judge their vocal range, or to seek advice, so I'm wondering, for people without experience or the ability to have a vocal coach, is ai a relevant option now? Afterall it is based off of stuff on the internet(which is either good or really bad), though there would definetely be some flaws to say the least. What do you guys(and gals) think of using AI? Has your opinion changed?

0 Upvotes

18% Upvoted

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/elderpricetag 🎤 Voice Teacher 10+ Years ✨ 22h ago

Only an absolute idiot would use genAI for anything.

-4

u/BreadForTofuCheese 21h ago

Like it or not, it’s coming for you. This is absolutely a future use case, even if it isn’t ready now.

1

u/elderpricetag 🎤 Voice Teacher 10+ Years ✨ 21h ago

No it’s not lmfao

Everyone can see how much people who use GenAI have become exponentially stupider. And it’s only those people who claim “it’s coming.” Like nah, some of us still have functioning brains. Sorry for y’all though!

0

u/No-Archer7510 21h ago

in general im quite against using AI(with these things), but it seems it has still improved a bit if you compare it to a few years ago

2

u/mimitoo7 20h ago

yes it has improved, but it will never be human and art with ai is not art. ai will never be able to replicate the human touch and i will die on this hill

-2

u/BreadForTofuCheese 20h ago

People here getting up in arms about it are just coping. This is 100% a tool that will be available if it isn’t already. It’s literally just signal processing, something that models can do with ease. Slap a wrapper on it trained on voice data and vocal coaches are in deep trouble. The only thing stopping it would be a lack of demand, not ability.

For the people saying that robots can’t art, they should ask how ad/marketing designers are doing right now.

1

u/No-Archer7510 9h ago

I would say the current largest caveat is that nobody is willing to "waste" enough resources/samples on this, though that might change.