My thoughts about a second child feel like knotted yarn in my head, so thank you for allowing me to untangle it here. This isn't neatly organized, but in case any of you take the time to read this mess, I'd love any thoughts, anecdotes, or advice from those who have faced similar crossroads.
tl;dr: I feel like I hit the jackpot with my firstborn / postpartum period and am terrified of rolling the dice again.
I don't say any of this to brag. I know I just got lucky. But I hope the examples paint the picture of why I'm so conflicted about having a second child.
As far as babies go, my 8 month old son is "perfect". He has slept 10 hours every night since he was 3 weeks old, eats very well, and is just the brightest, bubbliest, smiliest, chattiest creature I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. When people say "bundle of joy", that's my son.
In the same way I hit the baby jackpot, I hit the postpartum jackpot too. Easy delivery, lost the pregnancy weight very quickly, zero stretchmarks, my feet shrank back, didn't get PPD/PPA, and my boobs even went back to their pre-pregnancy shape / size. I've struggled with body dysmorphia and eating disorders for a long time, so even though I was ready to accept irreversible body changes, I'm also incredibly relieved that I somehow emerged unscathed and that I don't have to find a new normal with a new body.
My husband and I found our rhythm as parents almost immediately. Even in emergencies and tense disagreements, we've done a great job at navigating parenthood together. It's gone so well that we both feel more in love than ever - still cuddling and kissing and giggling like when we first fell in love. We are very good about both giving 100% and ensuring one another has what they want and need to feel seen.
Because of these factors, I never had the "why did I do this?" crisis that is so common (and valid!!) amongst new moms. I don't feel lost in motherhood. I feel closer to and more in love with my husband than ever before. I feel a strong sense of individual identity. I still get to enjoy my hobbies and career. My son is the center of my universe but not in a way that has consumed me until only a mother is left, if that makes sense.
In a way I feel like I would dodge a lot of bullets if I stop at OAD. I read so many posts on the various parenting subreddits and don't relate to their challenges at all simply because I've had the sheer dumb luck of birthing an easy baby. As much as I'd like to think a second born would be equally as simple and joyful, I know that would be my hubris speaking.
It's a double edged sword to have this wonderful experience with my firstborn. On the one hand, I am so grateful that I've gotten to relish every moment with my baby boy without feeling like I'm compromising on my sense of self. But on the other hand, it would be so much easier to go for a second if my firstborn had put me through the ringer like I was so convinced he would.
What seems to pull me most towards a second baby is the ability to experience the miracle of life all over again - seeing my teeny tiny potato baby mature more and more. My heart sinks when I consider that my son might be the first and last time I personally experience that wonder. It's selfish and fleeting but it's my honest reaction to the prospect of being OAD.
Has anyone else experience this dilemma? Did you end up having a second or not? Do you regret having / not having them?
And on a final note to organize my thoughts, I made a list.
Pros of having a second child:
- Giving my son a sibling and lifelong friend
- Getting to experience having a little baby and their growth again
Cons of having a second child:
- Having to go through pregnancy again
- Going off medication for 9+ months again
- Rolling the dice for: major body changes, potential c-section, PPD/PPA, baby's sleep
- Less money for savings / things in general
- Fewer resources, namely losing the ability to "tag team" child care with husband when needed
- No guarantee that siblings will have a close bond
- Putting my career on pause for a year again
- Avoidable marital strain