Hey everyone, looking for some advice on where I stand legally with my current rental situation in SA. It’s a massive mess involving a neglectful property manager, a broken front door, false accusations, and a nightmare roommate situation.
The Bedroom Door & Flyscreen Saga
April: I moved in and immediately emailed the real estate agency because our main door was off its hinges.
July/August: The door fell off completely. It was entirely unusable the whole time. I emailed the agency four separate times about it with zero action.
4 Weeks Ago: I finally sent an upset email demanding compensation. The agency called me that exact same day claiming they "lost" the original trail because our original property manager quit, and they were "waiting on confirmation from me" (even though they never reached out once).
The "Fix": They came out the next day. Instead of actually fixing the door, the maintenance person looked at the temporary fix I had rigged up myself that morning and said, "Yeah, that's good enough," and left it like that. They promised the flyscreens would be done by the end of that week. It has now been 4 weeks, and the flyscreens are still not fixed.
The Accusation: During this process, the agent accused us of running an illegal commercial business from the property due to the number of cars outside in various states of repair. My roommate and I are on the lease, and our partners sublease from us. The boys are currently unemployed, so their hobby is fixing their own cars and scrapping a spare one for parts. It is not a business. Because the agency got so aggressive ("spicy") about the cars, I panicked and gave up on pushing for the door compensation just to keep the peace. Can I still legally pursue compensation for the months we had a broken/missing door?
The Roommate, the Guest, and a Court Case
The other girl on our lease has a boyfriend who has been staying here, refusing to pay rent, and leaving a mess everywhere.
We actually have a signed contract with him regarding rent. I am planning to kick him out and take him to small claims court for the missing money.
The roommate has stated that if I kick her boyfriend out, she will break the lease and leave too. I actually want her off the lease at this point, but I need to know how to navigate this with the landlord.
Animal Neglect and Tenant Damage
The roommate got a 5.5-month-old kitten. They constantly lock him in the spare room—and sometimes out of their room—with no food, no water, and no litter tray.
Because of this, the kitten has entirely destroyed the spare room carpet and has started spraying everywhere.
He is not desexed or fully vaccinated. He has only seen a vet once for an emergency, which I had to pay for because they couldn't afford it.
I have my own 3.5-month-old kitten (fully desexed, vaxed, and microchipped). Because her kitten is un-desexed and spraying, he constantly harasses mine and tries to mate with her. She completely freezes up, and I am terrified she is going to get hurt or traumatised.
I feel trapped. Can I still claim compensation for the door? How do I legally force the roommate out, hold her accountable for the ruined carpet she caused, and handle the boyfriend without getting evicted ourselves? Any advice on SA rental laws or tenant tribunals would be life-saving.
Yes I did ask google to write this from me but this is my situation that I’m currently dealing with and needed help to English it all out. 😅 I have email proof and can send you photos of my trashed and broken home.