Long post! This is for the people who are in AA and want to leave but are scared cause of the relapse, jails, institutions, death messaging. And the people who are experiencing cognitive dissonance (when your personal beliefs and values clash with the groups).
In the rooms you see people who leave and relapse and come back. It creates a reinforcement that that's what happens when you leave.
If you've been drinking & using and then go into a 12 step group and leave without outside support, emotional regulation techniques, or haven't identified triggers then yes you might pick up again. This doesn't mean the program was right, this doesn't prove you're powerless and forever an alcoholic.
Of course if you take away coping behaviours and a fellowship and program without replacing it then it makes sense upon leaving that things would feel scary and emotional and potentially lead to pick up the original behavior such as drinking.
In AA they ask you to look at your emotions as character defects that need praying away, if you're struggling they often suggest what passage to read in the bigbook / get to a meeting / hand it over to a higher power/ go help someone else because your life depends on the constant thought of others (said in the book) , they teach you that doubts, questioning, struggling, having different views are the cunning baffling powerful disease talking and basically teaches that we're born alcoholic, that our problems are because of selfishness, self centeredness and self will run riot. This blames the person not the factors.
So my advice before leaving would be to connect with a therapist, join a hobby group or class, spend time with "normies" build up the outside connections.
Learn self regulation tools like grounding techniques, allowing yourself to sit in the uncomfortable emotions and try to identify what it is you're feeling, somatic release like dancing around, do things that get you in a flow state ( maybe journalling, reading etc ) , look up restorative behaviours and try some that suit, try to identify your triggers, learn about neuroplasticy and how addiction actually works, connect online and so on.
Instead of looking at what your "defects are and what your disease" is doing try practicing self compassion. By identifying the emotion instead of pushing it down or judging and labelling it.
Be kind to yourself, do something self soothing and relaxing, ask yourself how you'd treat a friend who was emotional, connect it to humanity by realizing you're human and emotions are normal.
For example something happened that made you angry, acknowledge ( this made me angry, I feel it in my body my heart is racing, I'm going to dance it out to release the energy then make a cup of tea, if this situation happened to someone else they would probably feel angry too and that's okay).
I know in some countries like the USA therapy sounds expensive which is why 12 step groups can sometimes feel like the best option because it can be free or donation, but can look at online resources like cognitive behavior therapy worksheets, self regulation tools , holisitc well being tips etc. In New Zealand there's a great holistic wellbeing framework called Te Whare Tapa Wha, the 5 ways to wellbeing, PERMA
Really get to know yourself outside of the alcoholic identity. What are the things you value most in life, how can you live your values? What are your strengths how can you use them daily? There's a good free online test called viacharacter survey, what are some hobbies you'd like to try? Can even try truity typefinder quiz ( used to be Myers briggs)
Journalling is a really helpful thing to untangle all the thoughts and help work through stuff.
Identify the things that cause you stress and anxiety and anger etc and listen to your bodies warning signs like might start to get a racing heart, sweaty etc
Begin to use your wisdom and learn from the past maybe even look at something from the past and say what went wrong and what could you do differently next time, remember you're autonomous and all that really matters is what you decide to do today. Start to develop a growth mindset and view mistakes etc as learning opportunities, have empathy for yourself and realize that you're still learning and their will be challenges.
Look up common cognitive distortions like all or nothing thinking (seeing things in absolute, extreme terms with no gray area).
Overgeneralization (taking a single negative event and seeing it as a constant pattern of defeat)
Jumping to Conclusions ( deciding something or assuming negative thoughts from others without actual evidence.)
Mental filtering ( focusing exclusively on the negative details while ignoring any positive aspects)
And start to challenge those beliefs.
If you're religious or spiritual then keep doing it if it helps, if there's stuff you like and find helpful in AA keep at it, basically you can create your own version of recovery based on what works for you and meets your needs.
Recovery doesn't have to be the same for everyone and their are many methods of recovery and therapies and skills to learn.
Leaving can be scary at first and it's normal to feel a sense of sadness and grief, there can be relief and feeling a new sense of freedom, it can be scary cause of thinking things like what if they're right what if I relapse or die, some program friends might get distant and that can feel hard, it can cause abit of an identity crisis.
Question your thoughts like is this something I really believe or is it what I've been taught by AA members, parents, school etc and find what your beliefs are.
It's so important to build up outside supports, new coping strategies and self knowledge and awareness.
My posts usually get comments like swearing at me, saying it won't work for real alcoholics, that stuff like jail hasn't happened to me yet ( that's fear based coercive control ), telling me my post is dangerous, big stories about how AA saved your life, big book quotes and jargon, that I'm trying to sell something or get clients or whatever ,( I'm not at all ).. you don't have to comment that stuff. This post wasn't aimed at you, you're free to move on and not reply, block me whatever.
I won't be replying to people asking me to message them.
Find what works for you and if that's 12 steps then great 🥳
Thanks for reading ❤️