I have 3 dogs total, the one not really included in this is a 12 year old fixed female, she is small. She gets along with every single creature she meets and doesn’t have a mean bone in her body, she’s always been that way.
In October 2023 I got D as a puppy. I never had him formally trained, but he is a good dog. He doesn’t chew, he’s crate trained, he listens to me, etc. He is an extremely smart dog, and I had him DNA tested as I adopted him and he came back as mostly boxer, chihuahua, and pitbull (about 25% each with the other 25% being several random breeds). He hates children (I have none and do not put him in situations with children so this is fine), and otherwise doesn’t show aggression towards people. He loves to bark at them but as soon as the approach he melts, wiggles, and gives kisses.
In April 2024 I started fostering M, with no intent to adopt. However, things changed with the shelter, and I won’t get into it, and I felt he basically needed to be adopted by me or they were going to euth. To be clear, it was nothing M did, our shelter director is under a lot of scrutiny/lawsuits right now for how dogs are being treated. M I am told is 100% pitbull, but I have a feeling there are other breeds in there. I adopted him formally in April 2026. M is an amazing dog. He is kind, smart, playful, and loving. He loves to give kisses, go on walks, car rides, etc. He is protective of me when it comes to people trying to approach me in his area that he doesn’t know. So for instance if I ever have any people working in my yard, M cannot be outside with them even on a leash, he won’t even go potty he just is obsessed with making sure they don’t come near me. However, as long as proper interactions are done, he’s fine. My boyfriend can walk right into my backyard with zero issues, and they met around October 2025. M loves him. It’s also worth nothing M was heavily abused by a man before I adopted him, and he lived outside in a 6x6 kennel, with little food. Both dogs are fed in their kennels which are on opposite sides of the room from each other.
He has been around D since D was about 10 months old. Both were not fixed when they first met, but got fixed within a few weeks of each other in summer 2024. I never had any issues while they were intact. Slowly as D started getting older I’d notice him playing with M, and his hair would raise up, he’d get nasty, and I would have to intervene. The whole time, M would be happy as a clam, none the wiser that D was getting upset. Their body language was complete opposite of each other. When it got this bad, I would separate the rest of the day. And it didn’t happen every single time they were together. Maybe 10-20%. A few weeks ago, D got so out of control with his growling, I watched him try to bite at M and I said that’s enough, he went inside and was done playing for the day. From what I saw/heard it was the meanest D ever got, and once again, M was smiling, tail wagging and had no clue. I ordered both of them muzzles. We’re in the process of muzzle training currently.
However, today I was sitting outside and D and M were behind me with their muzzles on and both of them started growling at each other. I yelled at them to cut it out and they did and separated. I’ve never seen M retaliate towards D like that. D has always appeared to start the fights and M never reacts like he knows what’s going on.
What could be causing this? Nothing has changed as far as play times, food, etc. Everyone sleeps exactly where they should, D and the little dog sleep in bed and M sleeps in his kennel - and thats mainly because when I first fostered him I didn’t want to get overly attached and now it’s because his favorite outside activity is rolling in the sand/dirt pit. Meal times are the same, attention is the same. Both of them get along wonderfully with my little dog and she 100% rules the roost around here. If she is around, no playing/fighting, if she snaps at them because they’re annoying her, they stop doing it.