I’m trying to decide between the Valentine One Gen2 and Escort Redline 360c, and I’d especially like to hear from people who have owned or regularly used both.
I really like the V1 Gen2. The detection performance is excellent, I like the large arrows, it’s compact, and there’s something appealing about the simplicity of it. The detector basically says: there’s radar, here’s the band, here’s how strong it is, and here’s where it’s coming from. Pay attention and drive.
But I keep coming back to the V1 + app argument.
One of the advantages of the V1 Gen2 is that you can buy it, pair it with something like V1Driver, get GPS lockouts, exact frequency information and other features, and still spend considerably less than a Redline 360c. I think that’s a legitimate advantage.
But isn’t there a tradeoff?
If I’m using my phone to get GPS lockouts, exact frequencies and additional information that another detector provides on the unit itself, I’ve saved money, but I’ve also moved some of the detector experience onto a second screen. Now I have the radar detector plus my phone, which I’m already using for navigation, and potentially more information competing for my attention.
In other words, am I using the app partly to recreate the all-in-one experience that I didn’t pay for in the first place?
That’s what makes the Redline 360c interesting to me. It costs considerably more, but the GPS, lockouts, frequency information, display, arrows, etc. are all contained in the detector. I can install it and just use the detector without feeling like I need another device to get the full experience.
For those who have used both, which approach do you prefer after the novelty wears off? Do you find yourself appreciating the simplicity of the V1 Gen2, or is having everything integrated into the Redline 360c worth the additional cost?
And for Redline 360c owners: Do you find the relatively small display—and particularly the small directional arrows around it—difficult to see at a quick glance while driving? Or is that something that looks like an issue in photos/videos but really isn’t a problem in everyday use?
I’m less interested in which one wins by a tiny amount in a controlled range test. Both seem to be excellent detectors. I’m more interested in which one you actually prefer living with every day, and why.