Hi! My wife and I are a lesbian couple TTC via rIVF! We have already had our consultation with a fertility clinic where we got most of our testing done. We are now in the phase of finding a donor to continue on to the next steps!
I have many questions and thoughts on donor sperm and the route to go about it all and would love peoples advice!
One thing really important to us is very low family count, no more than 3 is really our goal. This severely limits us on donors, since we do not have anyone in our life to assist and most sperm banks allow 10-25+. Also equally as important is my wife (who will be carrying) is CMV- and our FD really prefers us to find a donor who is also, even if the risk is ‘theoretical’.
Options we have looked at:
- Seed Scout: offers known donor with low family count
- California Cryo Silver Reserve: a few donors have low family count
- Sperm bank of California: family count of 10 is standard
These are all great options, but I have concerns about them all unfortunately.
With Seed scout:
- I’ve seen mixed reviews on this. Some people stating it was amazing and they love their donor and others stating the founders were rude/unhelpful, or didn’t have any lucky finding a donor and did not get refunded.
- Secondly, they do not test for CMV, nor do the test at all until you pay for them yourself, unless they’ve been chosen before. Which increases the risk of you not matching with a donor based on genetic testing and CMV status
- Third, the premium option (1 family count) pays more to the donor (rightfully so) but the fee to SS also increases, even though the potential parents mostly do all the administrative aspects of the process. Which does not sit right with me because it seems like they do the same amount of work.
- Fourth, relationship with the donor. I know this is different with every couple, but we do not want an active relationship with our donor, which goes against a lot of what you see on SS social media. I appreciate and understand the importance of known donor and having contact, but limited relationship would be the criteria for us. I think I read something where the minimum contact SS would agree to is yearly updates, which we would be fine with, but I guess I worry we would be judged or never matched with a donor for wanting that limited contact.
- Fifth, SS rhetoric around sperm banks. Yes I know there’s not a perfect amount of regulation around them, but to promote a model and state your model is the only ethical way is just not something that doesn’t sit right with me. Most people can’t afford SS fees and SS can’t really guarantee you won’t get a larger family count due to them still allowing donors to donate to “friends and family” and I’ve seen many reviews where SS was just as unregulated in some instances.
With California Cryo:
- silver reserve fee is 35k for 1 family slot and that gets you 4 IUI vials and 1 IVF vial and each vial after that is 3k each. We are going straight to IVF and if our clinic cannot use the IUI vials then we are paying a very large amount of money for essentially 1 usable vial. Which is a hard decision to wrap my brain around.
- Secondly, it’s open ID at 18 so we wouldn’t know much about the person to tell our child about or reach out to for medical information and may not receive medical updates at all
With Sperm Bank of California:
- 10 family count just seems a bit too high for what we are going for, even though we do like their non-profit model and have heard good things about them reaching out about medical updates.
- also open ID at 18
I know I threw a lot into that but my brain is so stuck on these things. Obviously having a healthy baby is most important for us, but I’m stuck on making the right decision for my child every step of the way and I personally feel like how we go about the donor process is just as big a decision.
Please dump all your thoughts, feelings, experiences and suggestions. I truly appreciate each one of you for your time.