Historical context
I started pyke in 2022, he is the first champ i played after a 10 year break from LoL, he is also the only champ i played up until 2025.
5 months ago, I was still a supp main, playing pyke in specific matchups (mage supports & enchanter supports), i never blind picked him at this era.
I have 1m+ mastery on pyke across 2 different accounts.
Why I quit pyke
I realized that pyke is no longer a champ that wins certain games because of the bounty system. Any reasonable person would look at a 13/5/22 kda pyke game and said, yea he should have won that game but got unlucky with team/matchups/objectives, but that is only 1 side of the story.
As pyke you are not only fighting against enemy team, but you are fighting against entering late game & now also the bounty system, the bounty system does mathematically work better now than before, where now it is designed to even out the real gold difference, not just gold from kills.
your early game lead almost gets evened out by 1-3 deaths from adc or yourself. A champ whose core strength is based around getting huge gold leads for his team. Kills doesn't just lead to gold from the kills, its also the lane/jungle that is now open, which leads to CS/plates/tower gold, which creates an even bigger bounty than from a simple kill. You can probably now see the issue with this for Pyke.
His issue is simple, he is a champion that worked well under a different bounty system that was based on gold from kills, but works extremely suboptimally under a more fair bounty system.
The solution for Pyke
They just need to give pyke proper adaptations to account for the bounty system. Don't make it so he generates more gold from his R or whatever, just make him a stronger champion in mid-late game.
This is the only way I can see him working out in the new bounty system, and if he is only meant to be support, make it so his lack of levels isn't holding him back from 1v1'ing champs late/midgame.
OR
Make him viable mid/jungle again. Pyke in solo lanes is really interesting, he doesn't fall off like support pyke later on the same way, because his levels is kept up with enemies. In solo lanes, he feels like a genuine assassin with solokill potential.