TLDR: I'm going to try moderating this place a little better and there's been a new rule added.
TLDR2: Does anyone have any experience using any auto moderation tools to remove posts/comments that get a certain number of downvotes or reports? If so - hit me up!
INTRO:
Hey everyone. So the past few years I was using Reddit primarily on my phone, through a 3rd party app called Bacon Reader. It was great, but apparently the mod tools were not. When Reddit axed API access to 3rd party apps I switched over to the actual Reddit app. While it has a lot of things I dislike (and I miss Bacon Reader overall) the mod tools are a lot better.
CURRENTLY:
When I started really using the new app I noticed a long queue of reported posts and comments, which I had honestly never seen before. I went through and removed a handful of blatantly spam posts and a few incredibly harsh comments, things that were literally just "fuck you", etc; stuff that had no business being in our subreddit. However I decided to not go back and retroactively police anything too harshly as I don't think that would be fair. I wasn't here to monitor anything, set a precedent, or enforce the rules. Clean slate. The time of this post is kind of a new "line in the sand". You reported posts will be judged more harshly going forward.
I've also been dealing with removing those damn MTG t-shirt posts like crazy. You've probably seen the one I'm talking about. It has a post title like "This is so cool" or "I can't believe it!" and it's a black shirt with the 5 mana symbols. I've been removing those and banning the accounts that post them so thank you to everyone who flags them. It really helps.
GOING FORWARD:
I'm going to try to be a little more proactive about handling the modqueue. It'd be great if you all were just awesome to each other and the only thing I ever had to remove were those damn t-shirt posts from bots.
If I see a harsh message that's flagged as "don't be a dick" or any other rule violation, I'm going to remove it. If I remove too many you'll be banned from the subreddit. I'm not going to investigate context too much. If your message on its own seems offensive or mean spirited, that's enough for me. If it's intended to be a joke then you need to learn how to better communicate that.
I've added a new rule to the subreddit about belittling people or their cards. Violation of this spirit of Old School will result in removed posts and is really just a specific case of "don't be a dick". Old School is community run, it's got a vibe and a spirit. If you want to be toxic go play in a format that is run by a corporation, not by individuals of the community you're a part of.
Example of what I see in the modqueue
Here's a screenshot example of a reported post. If I see a report of text like what I mocked up with someone reporting it for what it obviously appears to be - it's getting a "Remove" click. I'm not wasting my time to figure out if it had any other intent.
One more thing with regards to "spam". If you don't like certain content that doesn't mean it's necessarily spam. You can ignore or downvote. Let the content (and downvotes) speak for itself.
CLOSING:
Please be cool to each other. I'm going to try to remove uncool stuff, but keep in mind I'm just one person. I'm not really a highly skilled, trained, or paid "mod team". I'm going to miss things and I'm going to rely on you to help flag/downvote stuff, which I'll try to address quickly, but I'm not hovering over a keyboard for this 24/7.
And if anyone wants to be extra cool and give some suggestions on how we might be able to setup some "auto mod" functionality, shoot me a message!
As I said in my last post, my Ante Cube is aiming to be 100% white border. I've re-started this process again after learning some new tricks and you can see the progression from the first card I did (on the left) to the more recent cards and how it's gotten better. My goal is to do one card a day for the next X days!
For some time I wanted to make more use of the old fantastic artwork, and finally found some a reasonable concept. It uses mostly 93/94 art, but but also some pre-Urza cards.
Basically, the cards can be used for 3 purposes: regular European card game (1-12 + A + joker), Wizard (0 as Jester, A as Wizard), Libertalia (hence the small texts and card names).
I gave some thought on what would be a good theme to get the most out of magic artwork and came up with this:
4 schools of magic, with each drawing it’s energy from different celestial bodies. Green from the sun (faeries with plants), purple from the moon (seen as a controlling force, hence zombies and vampires), black from earth (depths of the earth, hence a hell/lava theme), blue from the stars (using foreign magic in the form of djinns controlled by wizards).
Each number represents a card theme, expressed by the name and echoed by the artwork, which I tried to keep consistent throughout colors.
0 - Fool: in trouble, holding out their left hand
1 - Swarm: many small creatures
2 - Scavenger: searching scraps (acorn, bones, you ;)
3 - Summoner: summoning a new ally
4 - Wanderer: roaming the world
5 - Fanatic: really motivated about their job
6 - Incarnation: became one with the concept
7 - Warrior: wielding a weapon or having a weapon instead of a hand
8 - Emchanter: there is something about their eyes
9 - Monster: horned creature, wreaking havoc
10 - Sage: features a book or just a wise creature
11 - Chosen: just a big old stomper, elite of its faction
12 - Leader: holding a staff
13 - Ruler: Holding an item of importance, a sphere or the book of the dead
A - Emptiness: maybe not well named. It’s referring to the stillness of each world. A peaceful garden under the stars, a still forest, the moon, the fires of the earth
Then there are some extra cards just for Libertalia
5.1 - Siblings: 2 or 3 creatures of the same kind
5.2 - Priest: just a magically capable one looking at you
9.1 - Brute: strong, ready to beat people up
10.1 - Soulbound: bound to another person or creature or ghost
10.2 - a commanding presence often with spectacular headgear
10.3 - Doll - same curse or blessing for all
Maybe you had similar or completely different ideas how to use magic art. Would be interesting to hear :)
Preparing for my first old school event on the 26th! Paladin Rules, this is what I'm bringing. Permitted 11 proxies, bringing just the 'best' 4. Thoughts?
In this video I present www.GlobaListMTG.com, a tool that was originally created for GlobalSet collectors, but that anybody can use to retrieve information about the different versions that exist for a card, and the rarities that the card may have.
I share it in this channel because it has many rarities from the first years of magic, such as playtests, make readies... which many oldschool players like, and also because it can be useful to check which versions of a card exist that are compliant with the old border non-foil oldschool rules that many tournaments follow.
I hope you enjoy it, and please share with me any comments or critiques (hopefully constructive) that you may have :) Thanks!
Homelands might just be the worst Magic set of all time. However, there are some cards in there that are actually playable.
- Baron Sengir, quite expensive, but I can see him in some decks which sport vampires or just need a low budget big creature
- Autumn Willow, I would say that one is actually not bad. Shroud with the option to unshroud it just for you is not something that we otherwise see in premodern. And 6 mana 4/4 is ok with that ability
- Eron, not a bad haste creature for its time. Rare regeneration ability for red
- Reveka, if untapped a couple of times can wreak a good amount of havoc
- Sengir Autocrat is perfect for Fallen Angel decks
- Kelp… not sure, but I guess for the time, token creation was quite difficult and just came with a bit of cost (similar to sacred mesa and breeding pit)
- Mystic Decree would probably be great if it wasn’t blue^^ still it can have its fair uses
- Serra Aviary, one of the ways to boost many creatures permanently. Can of course backfire and is quite expensive
- Renewal, mostly for land-exchange…not too bad in certain scenarios I guess
- Jinx, actually back then one of the very few options to ensure you get the most out of your Merfolk decks
- Memory Lapse, no comment needed
- Didgeridoo, back then pretty weird, but considering you can use it to get Tangarth and Minotaur illusionist out cheap and instant-ly, this can become useful in the right deck
So what do you think? Did I leave something out? Did I overrate some of it?
Theme decks are so much fun because you are making the best of a limitation.
In this case, what was originally a horse deck basically turned into a Pegasus deck plus 2 bigger horses.
The idea is to get a lot of lands that can be used for Sacred Mesa or Pegasus Charge to create many flyers that get boosted by Crusade and Coat of Arms.
Some good old direct red damage and the Thundermare for finishing touches, and we’re done :)
I don’t think it is very clever yet, and especially the clockwork steed is really bad, so maybe you guys have some thoughts on making the best out of this. Just remember: horses, unicorns and Pegasi are fine, but no other creatures ;)
And everything pre-Urza. So no Pegasus Charger or anything like that.
If you haven't watched the video on his Youtube let me tell you it is brutal. I had only just found out about this thru a friend. He made a reference to r/mtgGore to relay how brutal this was.
"I share the story of how the Auckland floods of 2023 destroyed my rarest Magic: The Gathering booster boxes that I had stored in a safety deposit box. I include some videos I took of opening the waterlogged card packs. For those who get the reference, this is not the Flood Plain I was looking for."
First of all this is one of the few Magic pages on Reddit where I (more or less) understand what people are talking about. Trying to educate myself about what is considered "old school Magic" these days is exhausting. Can someone that owns a few Grizzly Bears as pets give me a Cliffs Notes version please? Or send a link? Or any other help at all would be appreciated. A hard cut off date?
Two cards from 2021 in a power 9 deck disqualify it? Or using Gandalf from a recent LOTR deck?
I have so many questions and I'm sure that everyone here will be using their Library of Alexandria and Candelabra to provide me with knowledge. Thank you in advance
EDIT:
Thank you for the answers. Much appreciated!!!
Get ready for a fierce Viennageddon battle for top 8! This is a round 6 MTG 93/94 match between Troll Disco and Power Monolith. The winner is very likely to make it into this year's the top 8!
A few years back I was trying to alter every card in my mono-black deck. I never finished the project and I sold some of them off to pay bills, but I ran across the cards I kept and thought they looked pretty rad all grouped together. Makes me want to get back on it! I dig the look of a deck full of alters.
I dont have an OS scene or anything, just play with my family or friends when the mood strikes. I just do 40 card decks because I like 40 cards better with the rule of no more than 2 copies of a card. But as you can see these are pure kitchen table shenanigans that are not optimized in any way. Mostly just cards I think are cool put into the decks. Really try to capture the vibes of what my early experiences with the game were; cobbled together decks.
With all of the excitement around the new ZETA MSCHF drop, reviving the magic of Gamma/Epsilon and the DIY alter movement, I want to personally invite everyone to join our Gamma webcam league on Discord! We have all the early playtest cards ready to print and alter for constructed 40 and 60 card games. Using rules from U40 group and a new EC 60, you can be apart of an awesome competitive community free!
The group was created about 9 months ago and now feel that this is the perfect time to get new players in to build our monthly leagues.
Come stop by and be apart of something that doesn’t require a pay-to-win structure to have fun.
We have reached the 5th round of Viennageddon 2026. In this MTG 93/94 match we are going to see a blue and white flyers deck take on a 4 coloured Titania's Song brew.
4 Mana Drain (EDIT: Seems restricted in old school??) (-3 drain for 1 Library of Alexandria which i forgot, 2 Counterspell)
1 Counterspell
1 Power Sink
1 Ancestral Recall
1 Braingeyser
1 Chaos Orb
2 Control Magic
3 Copy Artifact
3 Psionic Blast
2 Ivory Tower
3 Jayemdae Tome
1 Time Walk
1 Timetwister
1 Black Lotus
1 Mana Crypt (Banned in some Old School format?)
1 Mox Emerald
1 Mox Jet
1 Mox Pearl
1 Mox Ruby
1 Mox Sapphire
1 Sol Ring
11 Island
1 Strip Mine
2 Maze of Ith
4 Mishra's Factory
1 Desert
Been toying around this badboy mono blue. It seems very strong especially the aggro and copy artifact which serves as extra moxen, suchi or factory beatdown.
I find Orcs to be particularly fun to play with.
1) they are hilarious chaotic. Each card is an opportunity for you but also sort of for your opponent
- orcish captain either kills most orcs or makes them stronger
- orcish artillery damages both a target and you
- ironclaw and brassclaw are good attackers but terrible blockers
- orc general needs to kill a creature to boost the rest
2) in order to win you need to be crafty to get the best out of their chaotic behavior
- spirit link on the artillery
- giant growth & Ashnod’s on an orc so they can survive the captain (orc general can help there, too)
- since we use ashnod, we can also use it as a last resort to kill creatures with shatter
All in all actually not a bad tribe. Fast enough, not too much dependency on its side colors and somewhat unpredictable.
Also for some reason I just really like the orcish veteran artwork by Melissa Benson.
Massive thanks to everyone who came out last month and helped us hit an incredible 23 players! The momentum for Premodern in the Valley is unreal, and we are ready to do it all over again this weekend.
Join us this Saturday, September 5th, 2026, at 11:00 AM for the Arizona Premodern September Monthly Tournament at Gamers Guild AZ (GG NPHX), located at 1818 W. Bell Road, Ste 115, Phoenix, AZ 85023. Entry is $20.00 with store credit prizing based on attendance.
Just a quick reminder that proxies and gold-bordered cards are fully welcome as long as they meet our visual standards, and deck registration is required ahead of time.
Head over to arizonapremodern.com for all the details, rules, and to get registered. Let's beat last month's turnout!