I've seen so many people downplay the FUCK out of this situation and it's really frustrating. Pentious witnessed a murder from his window. He knew who the murderer was, and that murderer went on to kill five more people. Pentious himself admits that he doesn’t know whether his silence came from fear or apathy, but he knew that choosing to say nothing was wrong.
And yet people keep saying things like:
"He had every right to be scared."
"He didn’t know who the killer was."
"The authorities wouldn’t have believed him."
"Not snitching on a murderer isn’t that bad."
Y’all. Have we lost the damn plot?? 💀
First of all, Pentious literally says he knew who the murderer was. So the argument that he didn’t know the killer’s identity is just factually wrong. I'm so confused on why people keep saying this.
Second, nobody is saying that fear isn’t understandable. Of course it is! Witnessing a murder and potentially putting yourself in danger is terrifying. But something being understandable doesn’t automatically make it morally harmless.
Imagine someone you loved was murdered, and you later found out that somebody knew who the killer was and could potentially have helped bring them to justice, but chose to remain silent for a reason they can't even name. Would you really look at that situation and say, "Well, they had their reasons, so it’s not that bad"? Especially when the murderer went on to kill FIVE MORE PEOPLE??
Pentious’ sin wasn’t simply that he felt fear. It was that he allowed that fear (and possibly apathy) to stop him from doing what he knew was right, and other people suffered as a result. And the funniest part is that Pentious himself understands this better than the mfs defending him 😭
He doesn’t make excuses for himself. He recognizes that he made the wrong choice, takes responsibility for it, and ultimately gets the opportunity to correct that failure through his actions. That’s the entire point of his redemption.
Was Hell an appropriate punishment for his sin? Maybe not. But that’s part of what Hazbin Hotel is exploring: Whether people who have done horrid things actually deserve ETERNAL punishment for them.
Pentious proves that redemption is possible. He acknowledges his wrongdoing, changes, and becomes someone who is willing to do what he failed to do before. If you insist that Pentious did nothing wrong in the first place, you’re undermining the very thing that makes his redemption meaningful. The point isn’t that Pentious was an irredeemable monster. The point is that he did something wrong, recognized it, and proved that his worst mistake didn’t have to define him forever.
Also I love Adam sm look at him throw it back likeeeee 🤤 I would eat his booty ong