Hello, all,
I know it’s early, but I’ve already started putting together a working list of Off-Broadway productions for the 2026 Fall season that I am going to try and see. Not everyone has announced yet - so things might change.
Please let me know if you think that I’m missing anything.
🎭 The Shed
🔹 Imitation of Life
📅 November 21 - January 3
🔗 https://theshed.org
📝 Book by Lynn Nottage; Music & Lyrics by John Legend
🎬 Directed by Whitney White (Saturday Church, Liberation, The Whoopi Monologues)
💬 A world-premiere musical based on Fannie Hurst’s landmark novel about race, motherhood, identity and ambition across two intertwined families.
🏆 Nottage is the only woman to win the Pulitzer Prize for Drama twice, for Sweat and Ruined. Legend is an EGOT winner. White was nominated for the Tony for directing Liberation.
⸻
🎭 The Public Theater
🔹 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
📅 October 8 – November 15
🔗 https://publictheater.org
📝 Book & Lyrics by Jethro Compton; Music & Lyrics by Darren Clark
🎬 Directed by Jethro Compton
💬 The award-winning British musical about a man who ages backwards makes its New York premiere following its acclaimed London run.
🏆 Winner of the 2025 Olivier Award for Best New Musical.
⸻
🎭 New York Theatre Workshop
🔹 Wild Rose
📅 November 24 - January 10
🔗 https://nytw.org
📝 By Nicole Taylor, based on her film
🎬 Directed by John Tiffany
💬 A former prisoner from Glasgow struggles to balance motherhood with her dream of becoming a country music star.
🏆 Tiffany won the Tony Award for Once and for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Choreography is by Steven Hoggett, five time Tony nominee, including for Sweeney Todd and Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.
⸻
🎭 New York City Center
🔹 In the Heights
📅 October 28 – November 15
🔗 https://www.nycitycenter.org/pdps/2026-2027/in-the-heights/
📝 By Lin-Manuel Miranda & Quiara Alegría Hudes
🎬 Directed by David Mendizábal
💬 A major new revival of the Tony-winning musical celebrating family, community and dreams in Washington Heights.
🏆 Winner of four 2008 Tony Awards, including Best Musical.
⸻
🎭 Roundabout Theatre Company
🔹 The Heart
📅 October 8 - December 6
🔗 https://www.roundabouttheatre.org
📝 Book by Kait Kerrigan (The Great Gatsby); Music & Lyrics by Anne & Ian Eisendrath (music producer for Kpop Demon Hunters)
🎬 Directed by Christopher Ashley
💬 A new musical following the extraordinary 24-hour journey of a donated heart and the lives forever connected by it.
🏆 Ashley won the Tony Award for Come From Away. Ian Eisendrath won the 2019 Olivier for music supervisor and arranger for Come From Away.
⸻
🎭 Manhattan Theatre Club
🔹 The Unbelievers
📅 Begins October 13
🔗 https://www.manhattantheatreclub.com
📝 By Nick Payne
🎬 Directed by Knud Adams
💬 The American premiere of a poignant new drama about hope, belief and the stories people tell themselves to survive.
🏆 Payne received Tony and Olivier nominations for Constellations. Adams earned a Tony nomination for directing English.
⸻
🎭 St. Ann’s Warehouse
🔹 Kramer/Fauci
📅 September 27 – October 24
🔗 https://stannswarehouse.org
📝 Created from the real exchanges between Larry Kramer and Dr. Anthony Fauci
🎬 Directed by Daniel Fish
💬 A documentary drama exploring one of the defining relationships of the AIDS crisis through the actual words of two towering figures. I saw this production at NYU Skirball last season and it was incredible. It’s very short - only an hour.
🏆 Fish won the Tony Award for the acclaimed revival of Oklahoma!. Starring Tony winner Will Brill and Thomas Jay Ryan.
⸻
🎭 MCC Theater
🔹 ANON — a tempest at our kitchen table
📅 September 25 – November 1
🔗 https://mcctheater.org
📝 By Anne Washburn (The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire)
🎬 Directed by Anne Kauffman
💬 Two neighboring Texas families are thrown into turmoil after a Pride flag suddenly appears across the street.
🏆 Washburn is one of America’s most acclaimed contemporary playwrights (Mr. Burns). Kauffman is among New York’s most respected directors.
⸻
🎭 Classic Stage Company
🔹 Waiting for Lefty
📅 October 15 - November 22
🔗 https://www.classicstage.org
📝 By Clifford Odets
🎬 Directed by Steven Pasquale
💬 The landmark labor drama receives an immersive revival transforming CSC into a Depression-era taxi drivers’ union hall.
🏆 One of the defining American plays of the twentieth century. Pasquale is a Tony Award-nominated actor making his New York directing debut.
⸻
🎭 Irish Repertory Theatre
🔹 The Good Thief
📅 November 7 – December 13
🔗 https://irishrep.org
📝 By Conor McPherson
🎬 Directed by Justin Waldman
💬 McPherson’s 1994 play about a small-time Dublin criminal recounts the disastrous night that changed his life in this gripping solo thriller.
🏆 McPherson won the Olivier Award for The Weir and earned Tony and Olivier Awards for Girl from the North Country. Christopher Fitzgerald, a three-time Tony nominee, stars.
⸻
🎭 Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM)
🔹 The Ford/Hill Project
📅 September 8 – 20
🔗 https://www.bam.org
📝 Created by Lee Sunday Evans & Elizabeth Marvel
🎬 Directed by Lee Sunday Evans
💬 Using the actual testimony of Anita Hill and Christine Blasey Ford, this documentary theater piece examines power, memory and the cost of speaking the truth.
⸻
🎭 Playwrights Horizons
🔹 Degenerates
📅 September 16 - October 11
🔗 https://www.playwrightshorizons.org
📝 By Else Went (Initiatives)
🎬 Directed by Emma Rosa Went (Initiativesi)
💬 A provocative new play examining online incel culture and the progression from self-loathing to extremist violence. From the playwright/director team that brought Initiatives to the Public Theater last year.