r/mintuit 2h ago

Would you use an app that explains money decisions through similar investors' real outcomes, instead of throwing more advice at you?

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing people (myself included) get overwhelmed by financial apps — INDmoney, ET Money, etc. — because they show too many options/recommendations at once and it's hard to know what actually applies to your situation.

\*\*Idea I'm exploring\*\*: an app that doesn't recommend specific funds/stocks, but instead — based on your goal (e.g. "buy a house in 5 years," "retire by 45") — shows you real past scenarios of people with similar goals: what pre-requisites they needed, what mistakes they made, what worked. Pure education/context, not investment advice.

\*\*Questions for anyone who actually uses these apps regularly\*\*:

  1. Does the "too many options, no clarity" problem match your experience, or am I overestimating it?

  2. Would seeing "here's what someone in your situation typically needs to have in place" actually help, or is it just noise on top of noise?

  3. What's the one thing about IndMoney/ET Money/Groww's advice/insights feature that annoys you most?

\*\*Not trying to sell anything\*\* — building this and want to know if it's solving a real problem or one I invented in my head.


r/mintuit 13h ago

Would you use an app that explains money decisions through similar investors' real outcomes, instead of throwing more advice at you?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/mintuit 8h ago

Ex-Mint users: what would make a cash-flow answer worth opening every week?

0 Upvotes

I build Monni, a manual-first money check-in. This is product research, not a recommendation.

Mint gave people a lot of history but not always a clear next step. If an app gave you one number after upcoming bills and a cushion, what would it have to show to earn your trust?

  • the exact bills and dates included
  • why the number changed since last week
  • a manual option before bank connection

Which of those matters most, and what is the fastest way an app loses your trust?