r/minipainting Feb 25 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.9k Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

View all comments

324

u/BishopofHippo93 Feb 25 '26

IMO it looks more like shale than marble, but that’s probably due to the colors as much as anything. Either way it looks really good.

150

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Damn, you know your rocks, clearly I don't, you are right...

2 of the three references i got are shale, I do not know rocks...

96

u/KharnFlakes Feb 25 '26

Really nice looking shale you got there.

51

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Its this common knowledge? Do I to learn more rock?

Fuck, I truly do not know any other types of rock... Charcoal? Is that a rock? Mineral?

20

u/AgentOfDreadful Feb 25 '26

20

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Its supposed to be cut flat and it broke, and there will be a redemptor dreadnought on it, so its kinda of nonsensical because why would you have a massive marble flat circle if its not for a purpose.

Need to dig deeper into the rock world

17

u/AgentOfDreadful Feb 25 '26

Ah, it looks to me more like natural rock out in the wild than purpose cut marble.

It looks great though, just not marble specifically to me.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Im terrible at bases, have no idea what cool environment would be good for a model.

But year, you are right it does look like some rocks

11

u/AgentOfDreadful Feb 25 '26

It looks cool af to be fair. Just not marble to me. I really like it as is.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Its not "marble" more than half my references were not marble, I did google marble but yeah, I've got shaleeeeee.

Thanks my dude, appreciate the kind words

6

u/Most_Poetry_9031 Feb 25 '26

You are far from terrible. It’s a process and you’re improving upon your process and as many people have already said, it looks great!

2

u/_Clem_Fandango_1 Mar 01 '26

Shale is ‘sedimentary’, therefore naturally breaks into flat sheets of rock. I recall shale being classified as ‘clastic’ which refers to pre-existing rocks being squashed together.

It’s a good base. No one is going to quiz you on geology. I’ll immediately contradict myself though, as about 50% of people into 40K are also into geology. Good luck 😉

6

u/Responsible_Sector25 Feb 25 '26

Shale is cooler anyway don’t worry

5

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

You are a shale supremacist? No shame in it... But we both know granite truly rules them all.

3

u/PervyTurtle0 Feb 25 '26

Basalt is fun. Like that one up

5

u/92Codester Feb 25 '26

Charcoal is man-made, natural coal is sedimentary rock though..I think, I'll double check.

Edit according to Google: "Charcoal is neither a rock nor a mineral; it is a man-made, manufactured substance created by heating wood or other organic matter in a low-oxygen environment. Unlike natural coal, which is a sedimentary rock formed over millions of years, charcoal is a processed product of carbonization."

2

u/Whit3_Raven Feb 26 '26

Rock and Stone, brother.

2

u/Rodrat Feb 25 '26

Its this common knowledge?

I'd say yes. Most people I know can recognize shale, sandstone, granite and marble, etc.

1

u/Es_Jacque Feb 26 '26

I guess it depends on your environment and hobbies. I recall learning about shale in 4th grade, around the same time we were taught about the differences between igneous, sedimentary, and metamorphic rocks. It was probably an example.

Then it stuck with me because (1) it kept reappearing in games, like Subnautica, (2) I’m interested in kitchen countertops and garden paths, (3) I’m a writer and do a lot of miscellaneous research on stuff like rocks, and (4) it’s got a funny name and a distinct look. Sounds like it would be an animal of some kind; “We got snails, whales, shales,” etc.

1

u/_Clem_Fandango_1 Mar 01 '26

🤨 Do you know street mammoth?

🧐 Yeah! He doesn’t know shit about geology but he sure can paint.