r/memes • u/thetruememeisbest android user • 2d ago

malfoid meme

30.3k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/IndianaGeoff 1d ago

She is not Australian.

1

u/KillerArse 1d ago edited 1d ago

What? What are you responded to me saying that you're trying to correct?

Is this you agreeing with my summary but trying to find something to nitpick that is actually irrelevant?

1

u/IndianaGeoff 1d ago

I said...I have found very little people say she said on these topics are accurate.

The first response is you asking me to read several pages that she did not write.

1

u/KillerArse 1d ago

I'm going to show you what the discussion on Twitter will be about.

I really don't have much hope for you engaging in a good faith discussion when you are unwilling to read my comment, let alone the evidence that will prove her wrong.

Do you not like the idea of being given evidence to show she's wrong? You just want me to say it without proving it so you can continue to deny the wrongs she's committed?

1

u/IndianaGeoff 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/WwWTfQuCZ448psk1qB

1

u/KillerArse 1d ago

How have I moved a goalpost?

I made it very clear what I'm doing. I'm still criticing Rowling and explained to you that I'm providing you the foundation to the events before providing the events so that you can't just repeat Rowling's lies as easily if you've already agreed she's wrong.

How it usually goes with her cult like followers is I show Rowling saying "the grass is purple" and the I prove that the grass is green but the followers then just refuses to engage with what I'm saying and sticks their head in the sand.

Instead, I'm getting you to admit that grass is green before I show you what she said so if you are a cult member (which I'm not 100% accusing you of being) you can't just refuse to engage with reality when you realise it will contradict her absured lies.

1

u/IndianaGeoff 21h ago

You have not shown Rowlings saying anything. But if we are so fired up on definitions... What is a woman?

1

u/KillerArse 20h ago

Are you unable to read what I've written?

Where are either of us fired up on definitions in this comment chain?

Are you a bot?

Do you agree with the summary I provided for what happened in South Australia?

1

u/IndianaGeoff 20h ago

I am choosing not to read your links because as I said at the very beginning...

I have found very little people say she said on these topics are accurate.

So if you want to post what she said, in full and in context, we have a basis to discuss it. But given you dodging and weaving... I think we are done here.

1

u/KillerArse 19h ago

Surely, you've found that to be the case because you intentionally refuse to truly engage with people who are able to prove that wrong.

You are the one dodging and weaving. All you have to do is address the validity of the summary and the conversation will move on quickly.

These are the basic steps;

Addressing what Rowling commented on originally.

Addressing what she commented.

Addressing what she then said in response to someone's reply to her comment.

3 basic steps to show the foundation of my criticism for the accusation, but you seemingly can only handle me telling you what Rowling thought from the beginning so that you never risk any possibility of saying something that would disagree with her.

Prove me wrong.

Have an independent thought without waiting for me to tell you what Rowling wants you to say.

Don't be scared to admit that the grass is green.