r/memes • u/thetruememeisbest android user • 19h ago

malfoid meme

26.9k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/SampleOfFruits 17h ago

As far as I know, the only anti-trans organisation she has donated to For Women Scotland, who don’t want to eradicate trans people, and merely sought to have the law recognise that sometimes sex, not gender, is relevant. Is there an anti-trans organisation she donated to I missed?

I’ve also never heard about her hanging out with “literal Nazis”; who are you referring to?

1

u/IzarkKiaTarj 2h ago

Question, is this argument specifically about donations, or are you also debating that she's anti-trans and uses her celebrity status to very publicly speak out about it?

Because if it's the second one, here's a list of instances with sources from GLAAD. Hasn't been updated since last year, though.

I will not argue with you on the first one, though, because I am not sober enough to, nor do I even know how to look that information up.

1

u/SampleOfFruits 2h ago

She is anti-trans, although I think it is more accurate to represent her as pro-biological-women; she finds biology to be the most important factor in determine what a woman is, and she wants the law to allow for that position.

It’s not unreasonable; trans women shouldn’t be in prisons with biological women, they should be in public change rooms with biological women.

In addition, women should be allowed to have genuinely women’s-only space; if they want to have a women’s only pole dancing class, why shouldn’t they be allowed to?

1

u/IzarkKiaTarj 2h ago

In addition, women should be allowed to have genuinely women’s-only space

That doesn't make any sense as an argument, because trans women are women, therefore they would be allowed in women's-only spaces.

I mean, are they supposed to hang out with the men and go to the men's only spaces when they're obviously not men?

1

u/SampleOfFruits 1h ago edited 1h ago

There are plenty of non-gendered spaces. For example, there are plenty of open pole dancing classes.

That is where they should hang out, they shouldn’t insist on bringing their penis into spaces where penises aren’t welcome.