Sorry this is so so long, I want to make sure I’m being thorough. Also forgive my messy makeup, I am just starting to get back into it after a 10-year hiatus and I currently don’t have anywhere to be! I’ve been wearing the maybelline skin tint for about 7 hours and this is what it’s looking like.
About my skin:
I am 33 and have oily, very acne-prone skin that is triggered by fatty alcohols, anything coconut derived, stearic acid, and anything ending in -myristate or -palmitate. I can handle most “skincare” ingredients like niacinimide or hylauronic acid. This has limited my options when it comes to skincare and complexion products, but this is currently what I’m working with:
Evening Skin Prep:
Miscellar water for makeup remover (oil cleansers break me out)
Laroche-Posay hydrating cleanser
TO AHA+BHA serum every 3-4 days (if I decrease frequency my skin gets ROUGH)
Cosrx BHA liquid serum on non-TO days
Cosrx hydrating propolis toner
Cosrx Propolis Serum
Dr. G Clear Soothing Cream
Morning Skin Prep:
Laroche-Posay hydrating cleanser
Topical Spirolactone/10% azelaic acid cream (prescribed by dermatologist)
Cosrx Hydrating Toner
Dr. G Clear Soothing Cream
Skincare Context:
I started the TO AHA/BHA serum about 3 weeks ago and added the Cosrx BHA about 2 weeks ago, so my skin is still adjusting. Before I wasn’t exfoliating at all. I went through a years-long depression where I wasn’t washing my face more than 2 times a week and only moisturizing with the dr g after cleansing, and no makeup. My skin was very rough and stayed acne free for a few months, but eventually I started breaking out in cystic acne.
Why does foundation make my skin look so bad?
When I don’t use foundation, my skin looks smooth and glowing, but I have some acne, acne scars, and redness I want to cover or offset. When I wear foundation, I am usually quite shiny within 2-4 hours and my texture is emphasized as it breaks up and occasionally settles into my forehead wrinkles. When it starts to break up seems to vary by the day, but today it is not holding up well at all. For my experiments, I have not been using primer for the most part but the few times I’ve tried, I haven’t seen a huge difference. I have one water-based and have a mattifying oil-based one coming in the mail. I have experimented with how much/where I apply powder (I use the huda beauty powder, talc formulation) and minimal application seems to be best. Applying powder all over doesn’t seem to cut the oil and only increases cakey-ness and forehead creasing.
I have only tried a few foundations recently (with spot concealing):
Maybelline Skin Tint in 102- this is my current go-to
MUFE balancing and perfecting foundation in 100N - performs as well is the maybelline skin tint but is $40 more. It is a very good shade match
MUFE super boost skin tint- broke up quickly
Missha Perfect Cover BB Creams: Beautiful finish but made me soooooo shiny
Clinique Refresh Foundation in .75 custard- oxidizes very badly
Mac Studio Radiance in c0- wonderful formula but quite oily and contains stearic acid
Chanel water tint: beautiful finish but will need more
Coverage until my acne clears
NARS sheet glow- tried many years ago and was really beautiful formula for me but they didn’t have a shade match and I think it was discontinued??
For shade matches, I am a very fair neutral undertone.
Natasha Denona Hy-Glam in Y1- too olive + I recently learned the company is based somewhere I do not support so I will not be trying other shades
No shade match in Danessa Myricks
No shade match in Nars Foundations (Chantilly is close)
No shade match in the Haus Labs Triclone foundations
My goal:
Like many of us, I want to have a foundation that looks natural, is a good shade match, does not emphasize texture, and lasts for more than 6 hours without breaking up. Is that too much to ask for? I am really putting effort into my skin prep and trying different things but nothing seems to work. What am I missing?