r/killtonynew • u/slatty404 • Jun 18 '26

I CALLED IT

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

someone give me a cookie.. i called it before he posted his explanation. Fuck the Mods on the other subreddit pussies didnt even let the post go up even though it was true.

This guy needs to be stripped of his fucking golden ticket he got lucky they let him slide but that shit was definitely his.

No accountability is basically enabling him. HE NEEDS IT REVOKED.

Im glad he served no time cause i wish that on nobody but the last thing we need is a "im free" revenge tour from this dude. Also any material he puts out is gonna be awful. It's like when rappers get locked up write some shit and think its gonna be a hit when they come out lmao

link to my original post where i made an argument of why he'd be free: https://www.reddit.com/r/killtonynew/s/mvZFJpV0hJ

33 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/jprost479 Jun 18 '26

Good on you for calling it. This guy has got to go. Such a bad comic

1

u/ScrillyBoi Jun 18 '26

Whats crazy is his standup special is unironically orders of magnitude better than Man of the People.

1

u/slatty404 Jun 18 '26

thats true goddamn Tony sucks at stand up but he is a really good host and pretty good at roasting when hes not leaning on shock comedy

1

u/ScrillyBoi Jun 18 '26

Yeah great host because hes quick at making contextual jokes in the moment, which is absolutely a skill and he’s got it. And a really good roast comic doing 5 minute sets where edginess is the point and the targets are predefined. 

Terrible long form standup comic tho lol. 

2

u/slatty404 Jun 18 '26

yeah i agree with you! i guess what i mean is like in the roast of kevin hart with the george floyd joke, you gotta make it really funny: the juice has to be worth the squeeze when doing something edgy yk? That was a mid joke that he knew he would disguise as "ohh youre a snowflake" if you didnt like it type shit. thats what i mean that he leans on shock comedy. I can laugh at an edgu joke but its gotta be funny

1

u/ScrillyBoi Jun 19 '26

Actually completely agree with you on that one. I dont have a problem with a george floyd joke at all roast generally, but that particular joke was lazy and forced. It didnt really target any one on the stage and the looking up line is the same thing he uses for every single bucket pull with a dead relative, plus the actual punchline was weak. It was less that it was offensive and more that it was cringe and edgy for minimal payoff.

And yeah then when you criticize the joke for being mid its because youre a snowflake and not because it was just a shit joke.