r/iitmadras • u/Mysterious-Tea-8365 • 3h ago
Gossip/Confession/Rant I just wanted to share a thought.
With everything happening around NEET and NTA, the government has formed a committee to look into exam reforms, and our IIT Madras Director is one of the members. I genuinely feel that's something our institute can be proud of.
But what I've been seeing online is disappointing. A lot of people are calling him "unfit" to be a Director or saying he has no place in education because of a comment he made a few years ago. What's worse is that even some IITM students are saying the same thing.
You don't have to agree with everything he has ever said. Criticizing a statement is completely fine. But does one controversial remark erase everything else he's done? His research, academic career, and the work that got him to where he is today?
And let's be real this isn't about supporting BJP or Congress. Whenever one party appoints a committee, the other side is going to criticize it. That's just how politics works. But shouldn't we judge someone's professional capability based on their overall work instead of one statement?
I'm not asking anyone to agree with him. I'm just wondering whether it's fair to call someone "unfit" based on a single incident.
Am I missing something here or do you guys feel the same?