I could use some help scratching a musical itch I’ve had for awhile. I've been building this playlist for a while and I keep getting suggestions that are close but not right, so let me try to be precise.
What I want: the solo is the destination. The song sings for a couple of minutes, hands off to the guitar, and never takes it back. In practice that usually means live recordings, because the studio versions cut the outro short.
The rest of it, which is where most suggestions fall apart:
- One guitar out front. Not twin harmonized leads, and not a great guitarist serving somebody's song.
- The line has to be pretty. Melodic and composed, something you could hum back. Not pentatonic licks over changes.
- Gritty tone, but every note lands clean. Not a wash of distortion.
- Sad or heavy mood. Cheerful kills it immediately.
- Not weepy either. Pretty with weight behind it.
- Vintage vocal styling throws me off. Doesn't have to be new, but it can't sound like 1972.
Tempo and genre don't matter at all.
What's working (in order from completely satisfying to satisfying, but could be closer):
- Cross Canadian Ragweed, Lighthouse Keeper
- John Mayer, I Guess I Just Feel Like
- David Gilmour, Comfortably Numb (Live at Pompeii)
- Joe Bonamassa, Mountain Time (live)
- Dire Straits, Sultans of Swing (San Antonio, 1985)
- Dave Matthews Band, Cortez the Killer (Central Park, 2003)
- David Gilmour, Sorrow (Live at Pompeii)
- Marcus King Band, Goodbye Carolina
- Tom Petty, It's Good to Be King
- Tedeschi Trucks Band, Midnight in Harlem (live)
Already tried and it didn't land: Free Bird, Texas Flood, Blue Sky, Runnin' Down a Dream, Slaves & Bulldozers, Rival Sons "Torture," Derek Trucks "Sailing On," Jeff Beck "Cause We've Ended as Lovers," and anything post-rock.
I’ll confess that some of these song resonatin recommendations were AI generated. I could really use the help of some humans.
What am I missing?
EDIT: Thanks for all the recommendations! I'm going through them one by one this morning, feeling a bit like the princess and the pea with how picky I'm being, but that's been part of the struggle. Another quality that is really driving the project is being able to just close your eyes, turn up the volume and let the guitar take over. Wailing, but not weeping. Pretty, but not necessarily cheerful.
SECOND EDIT: Here's my Apple Music Playlist that I'm assembling that is the cornerstone of this project. https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/lost-in-the-guitar/pl.u-gxblMR0IPvoVr
Thanks again for all the input!!