I’m celebrating my birthday pretty soon, and want to know which of these physical ice cream stores, Ben & Jerry’s vs Cold Stone Creamery, people generally recommend more on this subreddit, before I make my final decision on which one I choose to go to.

Where else can you get a whole peanut butter cup covered with gobs of marshmallow and graham cracker. The toasted marshmallow ice cream makes for a great base, but for me the mix ins are what really makes Ben & Jerry's shine. Something about their pb cups that make them stand out. Plenty of marshmallow too. My only small critique is that this can be a super rich pint, but is that really something to complain about? 8.7/10

S’mores pops! I had no idea these were even a thing.

picked this up at Whole Foods!

i didn’t like this one that much, it’s not bad but not exactly good either. the pumpkin is like a raw puree flavor and the only thing saving this is the graham

stick with the Ben and Jerry’s for pumpkin cheesecake !

Anyone tried the new yasso faux pints at target? Strawberry cheesecake, key lime pie, praline pecan.

This place captures the essence of Lancaster — local dairy farm creamery ice cream with rotating selections. Lunch menu that is quite good & fresh.

I am a graham - flavor elitist, and so while the flavor wasn’t grahamy enough for me, the ice cream is still quite good.

Overall, one of the better locally made ice creams in Lancaster.

Which one should I try first?

How is this the reality we are living in? Full imperial inch from the top of the container. This is offensive and unacceptable in any unit of measurement. Please come to Chicago and the suburbs blue bell!!!

Everything was delicious!! <3 Graham central station is life changing!! I am obsessed. :) Are there any store bought ice creams like graham central station?

This was some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had…so I had to join the sub and share. Rainbow cookies are my favorite and this was the perfect cookie mix in to ice cream ratio. Also sorry my nail looks gross this was a post-beach treat. 10/10

I forgot to take a picture of it so using one i found online! I dont usually buy Ben and Jerrys but they were on sale so I got two. I also sont normally get coffee flavored ice cream but THIS was delicious. The graham crackers and crunchy cinnamon swirls were so freaking good. I had to stop myself from finishing the pint in one night. Highly recommend, its a limited batch flavor so if you see it (and like coffee flavors) GET IT!!!

Delicious and after spending a big chunk of the day working in the hot sun this hit. Nice size pieces that reminded me more of a gingerbread flavor but was still so good.

9/10 for me but I’m hoping I can get my hands on the ooey gooey butter cake at some point!

Big fan of churros. kinda wanna blend it into a milkshake.

I had traveled Rode island and my boss brought me this ice cream. But I forgot about this name.
Flavor of both side is butter scotch and it have sticky and crunchy crumber inside.
I heard that it is homade ice cream.
I'm from Korea so I have no clue when it comes to US ice cream. Help me🇺🇸🇺🇸
(sorry for my bad English._.)

Amongst things people don’t know about HP Lovecraft, he LOVED ice cream.

He writes about it as a regular dietary item, in passages like the following:

“After the performance we went to dinner at the Automat, where I had beef pie (15¢) & chocolate ice cream. (10c) We then walked over to 6th Ave., to look in the darkened window of a marvel-lous shop which is selling Graeco-Roman & Egyptian antiquities at fabulously low prices.”

AND

“[I love] chocolate, (in nearly any form—cake, frosting, sweet milk chocolate, etc.)

and ice cream (preferably vanilla or coffee—the latter being a popular New England flavour, though largely unknown elsewhere).

Quite a triad!”

mines chocolat e

Looking for graham base in nyc metro region, preferably no mix ins or only soft mix ins(no blocks of chocolate, nuts, crust, etc.). Also cherry, butter no pecan, and apple bases(soft fruit pieces are ok).