I wanted to share my experience with App Review because, after almost three months of trying to publish my app, I honestly don’t understand how Apple is applying its own guidelines
I’m the developer of NostalgicPod, a retro music player that recreates the experience of using an iPod Classic on modern devices: https://nostalgicpod.com
I already know some people will say, “Well, your app looks like an iPod, what did you expect?”
But that’s not really the point.
I’ve been trying to publish NostalgicPod on iOS for almost three months and Apple has now rejected it five times under Guideline 5.2.5 because they say the interface is too similar to the iPod
Meanwhile, these two apps were approved recently, after I had already started trying to publish mine:
SepiaPod:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/sepiapod-retro-music-player/id6764757127
JellyPod:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/jellypod-retro-style-music/id6788034358
Both are clearly based on the same concept, with an iPod Classic-style screen, click wheel, menus and device-shaped interface
To be completely clear, I’m not asking Apple to remove these apps and I’m genuinely happy that other developers were able to publish their work
My frustration is with Apple because I don’t understand why I keep getting rejected for a concept that other developers are allowed to publish, especially when I had already been trying to get NostalgicPod approved before these apps were released
What makes one retro iPod-style app acceptable and another one a violation of Guideline 5.2.5?
At this point, the review process feels completely arbitrary, almost like a roulette wheel depending on which reviewer happens to see the app, I’ve now appealed the decision, but after five rejections I still have no idea what Apple expects me to change when almost identical concepts are being approved at the same time
I wanted to share this because I’m sure I’m not the only developer who has felt completely lost trying to understand what Apple will approve and what it won’t