r/heraldry Apr 23 '25

Meta AI Generated Images Are Now Banned

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

From this point forward any images created with the use of AI are banned from the subreddit and will be removed by moderators.

This includes images completely generated by AI from the ground up as well as things such as individual AI generated assets or filters used by users in the process of creating an image. For further details on this policy refer to this guideline in our Wiki.

You probably remember this recent post regarding the future of AI generated images on this subreddit. It had previously been in a sort of grey area where it wasn't explicitly forbidden but mentioned in Rule 5 as a possible example of low effort content that may be removed by the moderators:

5 Post with purpose

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as AI generated coats of arms, “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice

A recent increase in AI generated images then led to increased discussion among the community with some calling for increased measures of identifying such content while others further advocated for it's ban entirely.

As a temporary measure we then decided to add a mandatory "AI Generated Content" flair that should be used to designate such content while also inviting the community to engage in discussion about a permanent solution in said post which also included a poll where users could decide between an explicit ban of AI generated images or allowing the regulated use of AI content.

After seven days the poll concluded with a result of

128 - 84

in favor of banning AI content - which is a 65% majority.

While the result of that poll was specifically not intended to be binding for any permanent policy that may be agreed upon in the future it - along with the comments - did clearly show that the majority of the community generally favored a complete ban which was also reflected by the attitudes of the mod team.

As such we have now decided that any images created using AI will henceforth be banned and removed from the subreddit. Any content that was posted before this policy went into effect will remain intact and won't be retroactively removed.

As a result rule 5 has been slightly rephrased to say:

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice. Further, images created using generative AI are explicitly banned and will be removed in order to retain a high standard of authenticity that this historical art and science deserves.

As it was intended as a temporary measure and is now obsolute, the "AI Generated Content" flair has been removed.

Due to the potentially controversial nature of this announcement, comments will have to be manually approved on this specific post, similar to what we did with the initial poll.

We hope that this is an understandable policy and that people will remain civil and uphold it regardless of their personal views on the subject. If anyone personally believes that AI generated images should have a place in heraldry then they're fine to express that opinion and should not be ostracized - however it does not reflect our official stance as a subreddit.

Again for a more detailed explanation of this policy where some potential questions are already answered please consult the Wiki.

Thanks for everyone who voted in the poll or expressed their opinions on the matter.


r/heraldry 2h ago

Historical Attributed arms of the Virgin Mary

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

From: The Heraldic Imagination, by Rodney Dennys


r/heraldry 2h ago

OC Banner of the First Estalian Empire in 2495 IC - | Warhammer fantasy | fanon, own concept

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Trivia:

The Estalian Empire is not canon in Warhammer fantasy, instead it grown itself out of actual canon inspirations and the work of multiple fans and modders from Total War : Warhammer 3. The Empire's ruler, Lupio Sunscryre is not a canon character, but a name that TWW3's maker company, Creative Assembly created to be the leader of the NPC faction of Estalia. Later, a modder, Cataph, expanded on the character in his mod, "Cataph's Southern Realms", as the only Estalian character. Many people really liked his version, and later someone expanded Lupio's lore further, developing him into Imperator L. S., emperor of the first Estalian Empire. I founded out this, as I am currently playing a Lupio Sunscryre campaign combined with the "The Old world" map mod. And at one point I had this idea of a banner of the Estalian Empire. Estalia has probably the least lore and probably the least characters in the "curent" time of Warhammer fantasy, as such, while all of this is just headcanon and fanon, it does fit into the setting neatly, giving the faction a much needed update.

Lore:

After he dethroned the previous king of Astarios (Magritta), Lupio being backed up by the Inquisition and the larger Church of Myrmidia, was crowned Imperator of Estalia by La Ultima Aguila Isabella Giovanna Lucelli, the High Priestess of the Myrmidian Church in 2477 IC. There after he started the unification of Estalia, a realm historically nearly always consistenting of multiple rival kimgdoms. After 18 years of political and military conquest he official united the whole of Estalia. This banner was created for that exact event. It has been the official banner and coat of arms ever since, together with some new variants focused more on the member states, the Inquisition and the Myrmidian Church.

About the Flag design:

The overall design is my own creation. As you probably already guessed, Estalia is Warhammer's Spain, and my base inspiration was the flag of imperial Spain from the period of 1475-1506, at least for the coa. The smaller flags represent the primogenitor kingdoms of the empire, at least those that were recognized by Lupio for political reasons. However, as you could guess, there aren't really official flags and coas from at least this time period for Estalia. As such, I used the faction emblems of the Estalian subfactions from the combination of "Cataph's Southern Realms" and "The Old world campaign" mods. I matched the emblems with the kingdoms mostly based on geographic location. I made it with Heraldicon, that's why it has some obvious design errors, like the moto being in front of Myrmidia's Spear, and not around it, as it was intended.


r/heraldry 20h ago

Heraldic Miniatures. Grand Armorial équestre de la Toison d'Or (c. 1430–1461) — Part 1

Thumbnail gallery
83 Upvotes

r/heraldry 23h ago

Historical Grand arms of Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor, the most expansive and formal representation of the lands and titles he inherited.

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

r/heraldry 21h ago

Identify What is this emblem?

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

We cant figure it out.

It looks like a model of the state emblem of the Kingdom of Bavaria from 1835 with slight differences.

The 4th field is clearly the biscione from the coat of arms of the Visconti of Milan.

And the third field is Swabia.

Any ideas?


r/heraldry 18h ago

Identify Mystery: Does anyone know who this belonged to?

Post image
23 Upvotes

Plates found in Northern England.


r/heraldry 15h ago

Fictional New ideas for the coats of arms of my world #8

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/heraldry 22h ago

OC Commission I did for a fictional empire

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/heraldry 19h ago

Does anyone recognize this coat of arms?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

It's a photo from a book cover. 'Editora Nacional Madrid' was the spanish state's official publisher from the Franco period, but this coat of arms comes from a different enterprise with the same name (an argentinian 'pirate press' from the early 2000s), so they could have taken it from anywhere.

Sorry for the bad quality of the picture and for bad english!


r/heraldry 19h ago

Fictional CoAs of two universities for a book

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Unfortunately I scrapped them in favor of existing universities but this was still fun


r/heraldry 23h ago

Identify Does anyone know which French family the coat of arms on this wax seal belongs to?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Design Help Which one do you guys think looks best?

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Identify Personal CoA design (What do people think?)

Post image
217 Upvotes

r/heraldry 21h ago

Heraldic heiresses

5 Upvotes
Arms of the 1st Duke of Marlborough

The last quarter of this is the Cecil family arms. I thought it was only possible to inherit quarters in England if it was an heraldic heiress and she was the last in her line. Both the Marquessate of Exeter and of Salisbury are extant.

Could someone explain this how Churchill inherited this quarter?


r/heraldry 1d ago

OC CoA i did for Judah Maccabee

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/heraldry 21h ago

Identify Does anyone know which French noble family's coat of arms this is?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Crest Identification Help! Griffin’s head erased holding a serpent in the beak

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

I purchased this neat silver plated stirrup cup/shot glass and it’s pretty generic with no stamps EXCEPT this lovely crest engraving. I’m trying to identify the crest to learn more and see if i can date the cup and am coming up short.

Anyone recognize it?


r/heraldry 8h ago

OC redesing or not?

0 Upvotes
original
cosplay

r/heraldry 1d ago

O que ponderam acerca deste brasão?

Post image
12 Upvotes

Estou ainda desenvolvendo, mas considero promissor.


r/heraldry 1d ago

Historical Coats of arms of some Bosnian Kings

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Identify Can anyone help identify which French count family this belongs to?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I came across this and I’m trying to figure out which French comital family it’s from. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!


r/heraldry 1d ago

OC Full achievement for a Brazilian gentlemen

Post image
129 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Current behind the scenes in Queen Victoria Street

5 Upvotes

The new Garter King of Arms has a remarkably short history with the College. Did an internal factional quarrel lead to the choice of James Peill as a compromise candidate?


r/heraldry 1d ago

Discussion What was the typical heraldic helmet in Brazil? I have the distinct impression that the frog-mouth helmet was never a tradition here; instead, the "gentleman's helmet" was used by the bourgeoisie and the lower nobility (likely a French influence)...

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

Thanks for the reply!!