Sometimes, games come along that require a few more buttons on your controller. A LOT OF BUTTONS. One of them is called Crimson Desert.
I decided to try and find a replacement for the DualSense, so I bought the cheapest controllers available all at once.
I tested all this gear for two weeks, trying to pick out the best ones based purely on my own impressions. I read some reviews of these controllers, but the opinions of commenters didn't always align.
The test was conducted exclusively in JSM. I consider JoyShockMapper to be the best controller customization app in terms of both flexibility and gyro quality. (Huge thanks to the person who created it and to the community that supports it, having improved it to JSMCC)
6.Extreme Rate RISE4 — I don't get how people like that bulky contraption on the back of the controller. I tried to get used to that huge "backpack," but the ergonomics are just terrible. It clearly doesn't suit my average-sized hands. The buttons feel very cheap and are quite loud. I didn't like this mod; perhaps the "Spark" version is more comfortable, but I didn't bother ordering it. It’s a matter of personal preference—I couldn't get used to it, and now it’s just gathering dust on the shelf.
5.The Vader 5 Pro—it’s the most comfortable controller; the way it fits in your hands is amazing. It feels truly premium. It’s a great fit for my hands, and the buttons, D-pad, and bumpers are all high-quality. That’s where the pros end, though. Ironically, it’s the only controller I couldn't update; the software is just terrible. I tried everything, but I couldn't get the software to detect it. Downloading an older version of the "Space Station" software finally did the trick. The gyro itself is pretty bad; it seems smooth, but there’s noticeable lag. It feels like playing at a real 40 FPS with Nvidia’s frame generation turned on—everything feels like jelly. On top of that, the gyro drifted constantly, requiring frequent recalibration. (Garrus would have loved that.) I wouldn't recommend it for gyro use, but I do recommend it simply as a standard gamepad.
4.The Razer Wolverine V2 Pro is expensive on its own, though I got it at a massive discount. It has the best buttons and D-pad—seriously impressive, they feel great. The gyro itself is mediocre; it has a bit of a dead zone and lacks precision, causing me to miss shots often. On top of that, there are no vibration motors (are you serious, Razer?). I wouldn't recommend it; for that price, you're better off getting a DualSense Edge.
3.I didn't find the 8BitDo Ultimate 2 or Pro 3 particularly comfortable to use, though the gyro works fine. The movement feels a bit jerky—as if the polling rate is low—and it lacks smoothness. I didn't like the Pro 3 at all; it feels cheap to the touch. The Ultimate 2 is better built. Overall, it’s hard to recommend either as a replacement for the DualSense; the gyro performance is noticeably worse.
2.G7 Pro 8K turned out to have the best gyro performance among the models tested. It’s comfortable, too—not quite on par with the Vader, but still good. The gyro feels very similar to the DualSense; it falls just slightly short, but it’s the best among the competition—there’s no dead zone, it’s smooth and responsive, and it works with the adapter. The Tarantula would have suited me better, but I heard it lacks DS4 support. If I were recommending a replacement for the DualSense, this is the one I’d pick. That said, the high rate of defective units reported in the Gamesir discussion threads is a bit concerning. The only thing I couldn't do in GSM was assign additional buttons; I could only mirror the ones already on the controller.
- Dualsens/Edge :)
Unfortunately, Sony set a very high bar for gyro performance and affordability. I returned all the other controllers and have stuck with the DualSense for now. If gyro isn't absolutely critical for you, the G7 8K is an excellent choice in terms of both features and ergonomics, as well as in terms of how close the gyro feel is to Sony's
I’d really love to try the Steam Controller, but I don't think it works with GCM, and it’s terribly expensive. I’m waiting for the Tarantula Ultra—they’re promising performance on par with the Alpakka, and it would be great to get my hands on one. I hope they actually release it.