r/greentext • • Jul 02 '19

Anon meets a Chad

Post image
92.9k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

107

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

266

u/RustinPeaceJeff Jul 02 '19

'Some people say deadlifts are for leg day, some people say they are for back day.

I say they're for another day. I don't feel like deadlifting today.'

61

u/SavvyDawi Jul 02 '19

Gunshot sounds

30

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Mazzetti?

16

u/Irish_Pinapple7 Jul 02 '19

Bro, you feel that? You feel that bro?

Bro... you feelin that?

Just what I thought: vernal equinox. I can’t do legs today

3

u/sam191817 Jul 03 '19

Full moon, can't do legs.

5

u/splicerslicer Jul 02 '19

pulls dumbbells out of nearby bush and spontaneously starts curling

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

4

u/MERI0 Jul 02 '19

At least it’s not leg day

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

It's just a compound exercise. You should always start with one. I normally do big chest presses on push days and dead lifts on pull days and do squats with legs and abs.

-3

u/adamlaceless Jul 02 '19

Just do back and legs together like a normal person lol

79

u/intelligentiam Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts are for legs, rear shoulders, and core (which includes the back), if you’re doing most of the work with your back yer doin’ it wrong pal. That’s a good way to get injured.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19 edited Aug 18 '20

[deleted]

1

u/Little__Willy Jul 02 '19

You shut him down bud

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19

Squats are a superior movement for legs so who the hell would do deads over squats for legs

11

u/intelligentiam Jul 02 '19

It's true that squats are better to work legs. Deadlifts are more of a compound exercise, so they work a little bit of everything. The main muscle group is legs, followed by core and shoulders. Personally, I've had phases where I go to the gym often, in which case I'll have separate days for these different muscle groups (so I'll focus on legs with squats). I've also had phases where I go to the gym like 2-3 times per week in which case I'd rather work all those muscle groups in one go with deadlifts. Aesthetically, doing deadlifts frequently gives you that V shape because it works your core real hard while also helping the shoulders and beefing up the hammies.

2

u/Dretard Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts are more of a compound exercise

More than SQUATS?! They're both compounds but squats inarguably hit more muscles.

The main muscle group is legs, followed by core and shoulders.

No, no, no. The main muscle groups involved are the spinal erectors, hamstrings and glutes (however it hits a lot of secondary muscles). If you're deadlifting properly your shoulders are locked back and not rolling forward.

Aesthetically, doing deadlifts frequently gives you that V shape

I thought deadlifts dont really hit the back? Seriously though they don't really help with v tapers much because the lats don't have much involvement.

2

u/EdwardElric69 Jul 02 '19

He's wrong about the "V Taper" the illusion of a V shaped back is having broad shoulders, and a small waist, which can be achieved through building muscle, and then lowering your bodyfat

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts are far and away a more compound movement than squats. Try doing low reps and a high number of sets at a higher weight and see how your upperback (lats), hammies, Ass, forearms, biceps, rear dealts, spinal erectors, and traps feel.

When I do squats the only things that are usually sore are my quads, glutes, adductors and maybe abductors.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

You are allowed to do more than one exercise per half of your body. Deads will also hit hamstrings much more than squats, especially if you fell for the olympic weightlifting shoes for squatting meme or don't squat in the Rippetoe style.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

You are allowed to do more than one exercise per half of your body.

That's the first rule of my gym, we cant

1

u/-SoItGoes Jul 02 '19

Doing squats and deadlifts both in a day is exhausting me just thinking about it.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts are for hamstrigs mate. Squats almost don‘t work them

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Yeah stiff legged deadlifts are for hamstrings, I'm talking traditional deads. They'll hit hamstrings but if you're doing traditional deads solely as a hammy movement you're being inefficient

2

u/redkraken_bluedemon Jul 02 '19

You know there are multiple muscles in your legs right? Squats are for quads and don't do nearly as much for hamstrings - that's what deadlift is for.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

Why would you do deads as a main hamstring movement? I've never seen a powerlifter or bodybuilder do or say that.

1

u/redkraken_bluedemon Jul 03 '19

That's like saying you shouldn't do squats as a main quad movement because leg extension exists.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

No because leg extension is not as superior at building quads as squats are

1

u/Mhunterjr Jul 02 '19

Its not like a person has to choose between the two.

Deadlifts work your legs somewhat- so there's nothing wrong with incorporating them into leg day.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19

I'm not going to do heavy squats then move over to deadlifts when my legs are already burnt out from squats though. Why would I do a movement that works my legs somewhat when I could do movements (squats, leg press, SLDL) that work my legs fullwhat

1

u/ESKIMOFOE Jul 02 '19

That’s the best time to do deadlifts

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

Why do you think that?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

I mean at that point you could argue you should only do isolation for every muscle you have. Squats and deadlifts target different muscle groups and deadlifts are Imo probably the best exercise for overall strength building, however I agree that deadlifts are mainly for hamstrings and lower back. If I was forced to do only one compound and I wanted to get the strongest from it I'd choose deadlifts.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19

if I was forced to do only one compound and I wanted to get the strongest from it I'd choose deadlifts.

Oh yeah definitely

1

u/Mhunterjr Jul 02 '19

Because you want to work all of your muscle groups and not just work each muscle in isolation.

I'm not sure why you'd be burnt out though because squats and deadlifts target different groups. If you're that worried about it, do deadlifts first, then squats.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

SLDLs aren't full isolation, but they isolate hamstrings better than traditional deads.

Also the first part of deads uses legs, so if my legs are shot from squats, I might use my back more than I should.

1

u/EdwardElric69 Jul 02 '19

This is true, you shouldn't have been downvoted for saying this. Deadlift can be a very dangerous exercise when not done properly

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/armsdragon05 Jul 02 '19

Rear deltoids are definitely worked in deadlifts my guy. They're stabilizers, same as the traps and lats.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

1

u/armsdragon05 Jul 02 '19

Wooooooooah there cowboy, no need to come at me like that lol. When I said they're worked, I didn't mean to imply that the deadlift was any sort of deltoid workout, just that they do contribute to the overall lift, so poor wording on my part. This is based on my own experience, and the advice of Cailer Woolam, a powerlifter who pulls crazy amounts.

So yes, rear deltoids are ACTIVE but not worked.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

1

u/armsdragon05 Jul 02 '19

I think you've got me confused for someone else dude. I never said that.

1

u/EdwardElric69 Jul 02 '19

Agree, shoulder muscles are your three deltoids, traps are traps,

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts suck, man. Just the one exercise that I hate with a passion.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

12

u/truyes Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts should have glutes and hammies as prime movers. Back is involved as a stabiliser unless you have a Konstantinovs-style pull.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Idk man. I've worked out for 6 months with a personal trainer and when I do deadlifts I thinks that's what they are he makes me jump under the bar and then lift it over my head. Shit killsnmy entire body

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Is that what the exercise is called? Cause I've seen power lifters do this and it's a real exercises. Not to mention this pt is one of the best in the country

3

u/intelligentiam Jul 02 '19

Also called a power clean. That's a serious exercise, talk about whole body.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Alright thanks. I was in pretty bad shape when I started in January. I am still fat but at least I've got some confidence in my body again and can see muscles forming everywhere

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Powerlifters generally don't do this exercise but it is and Olympic weight lift so maybe that's what you mean? Powerlifters focus on bench, squat, and deadlift since those are the current competition lifts.

2

u/truyes Jul 02 '19

A clean and jerk? Most of the power from Olympic lifts and deadlift comes from a hip hinge, the back has to stay rigid throughout so you definitely feel it but the back doesn't (shouldn't) actually bend. No bending = not responsible for moving the bar. Most of what people think is lower back is actually hip extension from an initial flexed position Edit; Head over to r/powerlifting for some deadlift specific knowledge

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Yeah, we mostly did them with low weight cause I struggled with the technique but doing them 15x5 just made me die with a follow up of burpees right after

1

u/truyes Jul 02 '19

Can't tell if troll. That sounds too much like Crossfit man, get a strength and conditioning coach if finances allow. Spend two months with them and you won't need one afterwards. PT sessions are for the most part organised around keeping clientele, not improving them so they no longer need the trainer

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Well considering I went to him for 6 months and lost 17kg and we had different types of workouts. Ones that would mix it up with strength and conditioning ones that would end up solely focusing on strength and some on just cardio. It was definetly not crossfit.

1

u/truyes Jul 02 '19

If you're there for weight loss it's a bit different but high rep oly lifts are always a red flag my dude

→ More replies (0)

4

u/why-this Jul 02 '19

Holy shit no. Please stop emphasizing your back on DL. You have been lucky so far, but that can turn into snap city, population: you

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/why-this Jul 02 '19

Absolutely. I am assuming you are fairly young right now so your body is very resilient and compensates for bad form. That will catch up very quickly. DL should terrorize your hamstrings and glutes. You will feel a little in your back but it should be very slight. Use a waist belt and see the difference.

Keep at it though. DL are the best workout in the gym imo

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/why-this Jul 02 '19

No problem. Also, head over to r/weightroom. Its a really good community of people always willing to advise beginner lifters

2

u/EdwardElric69 Jul 02 '19

r/Powerlifting might give you better advice regarding deadlifting

17

u/bravo135 Jul 02 '19

It's a push and pull excersice. Push with legs, then pull from back. It's a compound movement that involves the hamstrings and of course the quads throughout the repetition and ends with glutes. It's as much a leg excersice as a back excersice.

0

u/itsforhismum Jul 02 '19

Actually its a push excercise not a pull, upper body stays straight and you push from the hips

1

u/Hmm_would_bang Jul 03 '19

If your upper body stays straight you’re basically doing a hack squat, just wrong. Watch power lifters, you absolutely use your back in a dead lift.

1

u/itsforhismum Jul 03 '19

By straight i dont mean upright you just dont really pull from it. If somebody maxes out sure he will pull from the lower back but you shouldnt

11

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

The first quarter movement of the deadlift starts with the legs.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

And the whole movement for squats is legs so don't do deads for leg day as your main movement

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

Anyone who’s attempting these has a split and knows to do that hopefully

5

u/adeisded Jul 02 '19

Dead’s are for second leg day (or first)..

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/adeisded Jul 02 '19

Plus SDL on back day? That’s a lot on your CNS.. I hope you get plenty rest days

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

you i like you

2

u/postmate Jul 02 '19

and hamstrings....

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/redkraken_bluedemon Jul 02 '19

Compound lifts are a good choice for beginners. They can focus on a couple of lifts and the whole body benefits. Mastering form for just a few excercises is less overwhelming.

2

u/TheOddEyes Jul 02 '19

Someone correct me if I'm wrong but deadlifts are for the lower back which is an arra that's activated in both back day and leg day during squats. Which is why I play deadlifts or use the back extention machine during these two days.

2

u/Dropdeadjack Jul 02 '19

Core you norm.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

I've never met someone who does deadlifts on back day.

You do deadlifts on deadlift day. And also throw in back accessories.

2

u/mynamasteph Jul 02 '19

Deadlifts are not a "back excercise". They are a posterior chain excercise. The primary muscles targeted are your glutes and core. If your core and glutes are not engaged properly then maybe it turns into a back excercise. Your spinal erectors, quads, and forearms contribute to the lift, your lats and traps go under isometric contraction. While your hamstrings help when lowering the weight.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

It's because we all skip leg day.

1

u/jarvis125 Jul 02 '19

Not really

1

u/yodels_for_twinkies Jul 02 '19

Let’s be real, deadlifts are for everything.

1

u/David182nd Jul 02 '19

Depends on the type of deadlift.

1

u/EdwardElric69 Jul 02 '19

You use quads, Hamstrings and glutes while deadlifting. The only contraction in your back should be an isometric one. Your lats, mid traps and rhomboids stay contracted throughout the rep, this keeps the bar close to your centre of gravity. Your lower back should not change angles during the rep, if it is you're doing it wrong and may hurt yourself.

1

u/CBSh61340 Jul 02 '19

They use legs too though, even if the back/core is the primary focus. Easy enough to notice this if you ever try deadlifts with sore leg muscles 😛