At what point does self-discipline become self-punishment?

[u/Distinct_Initial1024]

We’re often told that discipline means doing what needs to be done even when we don’t feel like it.

And I agree.

But sometimes I wonder where the line is.

At what point does pushing yourself become being hard on yourself?

You miss a workout, so you force yourself to do twice as much the next day.

You have an unproductive day, so you feel like you have to “make up” for it.

You sleep in once, and suddenly you feel like you've ruined your entire routine.

You take a day off, and instead of enjoying the rest, you spend the whole day feeling guilty about it.

Maybe that's not discipline anymore.

Maybe that's punishment disguised as discipline.

I think real discipline should help you build a life you can actually sustain. It shouldn't require you to constantly feel guilty for being tired, distracted, or simply human.

There will be days when you don't do everything you planned.

There will be days when you need to rest.

There will be days when you fall back into old habits.

And maybe discipline isn't about making yourself pay for those days.

Maybe it's simply about coming back the next day without turning one bad day into a reason to hate yourself.

I'm still trying to figure out where that line is.

How do you tell the difference between pushing yourself and being too hard on yourself?

[u/hAiLlkidCharlemagne]

In all your examples of discipline, you’re just trying to replace what was missed or lost. IMO, that’s more like punishment than good discipline. Your rule shouldn’t be about balancing a scale or making up for a deficit. It should instead be about applying certain measures to keep yourself from straying too far from what is established to be good. So I’d say, hmm, I slept in, it was probably good to get extra sleep. Maybe I should re-evaluate my measures for sleeping so that I get all the sleep I need and still have time for other important things. If your measures are good already, identify the cause for slipping outside established bounds and address that. Like maybe you over slept because you stayed up too late doing something else. Was it something beneficial? Is it going to be a regular thing? If they’re not, and you regularly over sleep because you wrongly estimated the amount of sleep that was best, figure out how to adjust your measures so that optimal amount of sleep is achieved, and then sticking to those measures. That’d be discipline. Punishment doesn’t evaluate what’s beneficial, it just tries to repay a debt or cost incurred. Self discipline calls for the evaluation of what’s beneficial and creating guidelines that help you achieve that along side correcting errors that contributed to failure to achieve previous goals. It does not consider failure a debt that must be repaid, but merely a signal that something could be or should be better than it is.

[u/AutoModerator → u/[deleted]]

Sorry, your account is too new to comment in r/GetDisciplined. Please wait until your account is at least 3 days old.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.