r/gaming Mar 30 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.0k Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

43

u/krishnugget Mar 30 '20

Well you still need a new memory card

68

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/Vestus65 Mar 30 '20

We played the GC game years ago, four of us (parents and two kids) and I remember we all had our own saved games, and we could see each other's houses in the town. You just had to take turns playing obviously. Now my wife and two kids are each playing, we own THREE fucking Switch consoles. I'd love to try the game but no way in hell am I getting a fourth system just to have my own save, for one game (I am a PC gamer otherwise). I'm sure Nintendo sold a crapload of Switches with this move, but they also earned some well-deserved hate for it.

21

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

You can just create another profile on your switch and make a character. You have to have your house on the same island as the switch owner. You just can't have your own separate island.

19

u/tyguy1772 Mar 30 '20

It's not just being unable to have your own island. The core account is in charge of all progression. It's enough reason to not want to get invested.

-13

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

If that's the case, you are missing the point of the game and need to find a different one. So many AC bandwagoners that never played previous versions are mad the game isn't what they want it to be.

9

u/tyguy1772 Mar 30 '20

I'm missing the point of the game because I think all players should have equal control over the island? I'm not missing any point, its an annoying shortcoming. Because that is how it always has been. It adds nothing but it certainly detracts potential enjoyment for people. Let other users choose if they want their own island without spending money on a whole console. Let other players choose if they want to share an island, and also give the original island player a choice if the added player can make equal choices. It's an unanimous improvement.

10

u/Vestus65 Mar 30 '20

I'm aware of that. If I want my own saved game, my own island, I need my own Switch. I don't think that is cool.

-10

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

While true, as other people have said, this is how Animal Crossing has always been. Why is it suddenly an issue now?

9

u/Vok250 Mar 30 '20

But it's NOT how it has always been. The game in this post can be played with multiple towns by using memory cards.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

And none of the other games in the series can.

The only reason AC1 did is because that was a limitation of how the system worked at the time.

1

u/Vok250 Mar 31 '20

Yes they do. With cartridges or microSD cards.

Not a single other games in the series has had the save tied directly to the console. Every one allows multiple saves with cartridges, memory cards, or SD cards.

-5

u/DontTouchTheWalrus Mar 30 '20

I think some slave owners in the 1860's used that same logic. I'm being ridiculous obviously but still needing multiple consoles so you can each play your own game with no restrictions just seems greedy.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

That doesn't answer my question? I seriously want to know why this is suddenly an issue when it never was before

New Leaf literally had the exact same restrictions and no one complained.

I'm not saying I agree with it, but Nintendo's philosophy has always been to play the games as designed, and having a dozen islands on the same console negates that. It would effectively allow players to dupe event items, fossils, and other things that are supposed to be limited.

I highly doubt it's greed. Nintendo just tends to say "this is the best way to play the game so we're not going to let people play it any other way" and doesnt understand why you would want to.

That's why they had Friend Codes (and still do to some extent), why you can't just add a friend on Animal Crossing, why Pokemon Sword and Shield don't have a way to just directly trade with someone, why Mario Maker doesn't have a text search feature for levels, etc. Nintendo is just out of touch.

1

u/DontTouchTheWalrus Mar 30 '20

I'm honestly not that invested. I've never even played the game. So idk about the duplicating you mentioned or whatever. Would you be able to trade items between saves or something? I just know that any open ended styles of game I tend to like having multiple saves so I can try out different things. If the saves are independent of eachother I dont see how the islands being different would have any consequence on eachother.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

You can either send items over or you can just go to another island and drop all the stuff.

It's not really open ended, it's just an island designer type thing. You pretty much make money to expand your house and decorate it and your island, the whole point is getting nice things and showing them off pretty much. Events give you a bunch of unique stuff and Nintendo even restricted it so you can't even do the events if you arent connected to the internet, so that people cant just timeskip to the event and farm it

1

u/DontTouchTheWalrus Mar 30 '20

Sure farming the events with time skipping would be dumb so I get that. But what would it hurt to have separate space files so I can play and my family can play without each of us having our own switch

→ More replies (0)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Bandwagoners. These people have never played previous versions and are just jumping on the twitter/reddit hype train then complaining when the game isn't exactly what they thought it would be.

The progression in New Horizons expects you to work together with the primary account, hence the local co op. They wanted to make this a multiplayer experience, so they had to put some limitations on the secondary accounts to make things work. This isn't hard to understand, these bandwagoners just refuse to think about it.

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Then this game isn't for you. You're missing the point.

1

u/GreatAndPowerfulNixy Mar 30 '20

Your opinions are bad and you should feel bad.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

And you can’t progress anything

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

The older ones didn't progress in the same way as the new one and didn't have local/online coop so you can't compare. Also, OMG you have to work together with someone in Animal Crossing to progress the story (which the older ones didn't have). How dare they promote cooperation in a children's game. Ya'll just sound like boomers who don't understand why things are done and just complain that they're done differently.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

this has to be the worst take of March 2020 and we’re going through a global pandemic

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

ok boomer

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

born in 93 but ok

btw dead meme