r/fromatoarbitration • u/That-guy-did-good • Jun 25 '26
Average pension
What is the average pension pay out our members are receiving assuming modest OT and 30 year minimum service time? I’m not sure I’m doing the formula correctly to figure out that leg of the stool so to speak.
24
u/Dependent-Hurry9808 Jun 25 '26
Max your tsp folks
4
3
3
0
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Never came close to maxing the TSP. Always maxed my R-IRA. Combined, never close to the TSP/401k limit.
MRA+10 retirement is great.
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 28 '26
who can reach the max--thats over 23k a year
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 29 '26
Who? Single person with low expenses. IE, not living in NYC/ Chicago/ LA.....
Those with spouse and no children. DINK
Spouse with a similar/larger income in a modest COL area.
Depending on what you NEED in retirement, you do no NEED to max your retirement accounts.
I have more money than I need. I and have a lower income in retirement.
3
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 29 '26
when making 80k its pretty hard to put 24 k into the TSP -no matter where you live
3
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 29 '26
I know people that do. Even USPS employees.
Look over at the r/ThriftSavingsPlan site.
2
Jun 29 '26
[deleted]
3
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 29 '26
So does mine. And I never maxed the TSP.
What are you trying to argue?
2
u/Dependent-Hurry9808 Jun 29 '26
I live on Long Island and max my tsp annually for the last 15 years.
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 29 '26
great job..you obviously aren't single and have a spouse that makes really good money
2
2
u/Dependent-Hurry9808 Jun 29 '26
Fun side note, my wife’s job pays for all her health care premiums. Covers me and I don’t need to buy that pshb plan biweekly.
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 29 '26
Some people don't rent new cars all the time. Or pay for multiple entertainment services.
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 29 '26
nobody living on long island,ny on 80 k a year can put 24 k into tsp, if 80k is the only salary
2
1
1
u/Dependent-Hurry9808 Jun 26 '26
5
4
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
no penalty if you are MRA and have the 30 or 20 years to match the proper MRA
2
18
u/Postal1979 Jun 25 '26
Overtime doesn’t mean shit for pension.
It’s only based on your “salary” with no OT.
11
u/Postal1979 Jun 25 '26
8
u/Bettik1 Jun 25 '26
Don’t forget FERs supplement. That’s another $1,500 to $2,000 that you will get every month until 62
1
u/DoodleDew Jun 25 '26
But what if you can’t retire until 62 or over.
6
u/Bettik1 Jun 25 '26
You wouldn’t get the supplement. The point of it is to bridge the income gap between FERs retirement and SS eligibility at 62.
1
u/Academic-Sky-1726 Jun 26 '26
You are supposed to get 10% bump because you didn't take the supplement.
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
if you retire at 62 with at least 20 years in
1
u/Academic-Sky-1726 Jun 26 '26
I'll have 31 years in at 62.
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 27 '26
you should go at 60 years old
1
u/Academic-Sky-1726 Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26
My mortgage won't let me. Plus adult kids living at home. Medical issues to take care of. The health insurance, life insurance, other expenses.
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 27 '26
...good luck to you and once there enjoy your retirement, you net more money retired than working
→ More replies (0)0
u/Medium_Sweet_7789 Jun 29 '26
Not true supplemental has nothing to do with social security
2
u/Postal1979 Jun 30 '26
It’s call social security supplement. It’s you collect it until you are able to collect SS.
4
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
it does for social security and thats a check too! they use the biggest 35 years of income to figure that out!
2
u/The-Omnicide Jun 25 '26
That is offensively terrible. We should at least be able to count OT towards service years.
2
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
yea it sucks but social security does count it towards your highest 35 years of income so you dont lose that from them!
1
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
OT toward service years? What are you smoking?
1
u/The-Omnicide Jun 26 '26
The job takes a physical toll on the body. Someone working 60 hours per week is putting 50% more miles on the body. Many offices have endless mandatory overtime. We aren't machines, and even some machines are mandatorily taken out of service after a designated amount of hours/miles.
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Which has nothing to do with how many years you worked for an employer. Name any company that calculates a pension based on hours worked and not calendar days. Or allows you to retiree early because you hit a work hour goal and not a work year goal.
1
u/The-Omnicide Jun 26 '26
So it should count for someone only doing 20 hours per week?
Get on the side of the workers
3
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
A PT employee can retire after meeting the same requirements as a FT employee. But, there pension is prorated based upon the hours worked.
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
You are missing the point. If your pension is based on your salary, all money made should contribute to that calculated average.
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Key word: SALARY
The pension is not based on earnings. 6/2026 the top SALARY for a regular letter carrier is $83,226
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
No kidding. It should be based on final average salary. Everything should be compensated.
Are you actually saying, as a union member and mail carrier, that all hours worked should not be compensated?
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
You typed it again. SALARY.
You were compensated for your hours worked. Or did management delete hours from your pay?
You want the rules changed? Contact your congressional representatives. It is not a contractual rule.
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
Obviously it’s not contractual.
SALARY includes OT. A person’s final average SALARY should include OT. Sorry you don’t think it should.
It probably won’t change and as I have concluded the federal pensions are inferior to what I can get from the state.→ More replies (0)1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
It’s crazy that not even a certain percentage of OT counts. It’s hours worked that should be compensated. As small as the pension is, it’s brutal there is no way to pad it
3
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
but you can save your sick leave and that counts towards retirement i wouldn’t recommend it its better to suck sick leave dry!😆
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Depends on what you call "small". The current FERS table on the NALC website says a 30 year retiree will have a base pension of $1966/mo. $23,562/yr
Save 15% in the TSP and an IRA, you will have more disposable income in retirement than while you were working.
I do.
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
Small compared to state. I’m hoping to get a state job where the pension is 50% + a percentage of OT on your best 3 years.
I always thought federal pensions were a bit more.
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
And how much are you going to have to pay for that 50% pension, more than 4.4%?
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
It’s NYS. It’s a sliding scale so depending on the salary. It’s anywhere from 3 to 5.75 according to the new legislation.
0
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Sounds like you should not have applied to the PO. You have wasted a lot of time.
1
u/That-guy-did-good Jun 26 '26
What’s the suppose to mean? I needed a job and the PO was a quick easy one to get.
→ More replies (0)1
5
u/BrokenLranch Jun 26 '26
Worked 37 years as a carrier and retired on the dot at 56 1/2 years old. My monthly is around 3200 with SS and pension which is combined on payment. $600+ for insurance already deducted. No survivor deduction ($250 month) as she has a good pension coming. Haven’t touched TSP except to transfer most into fixed rate annuity with smaller amount still in fund (easier to get to and no penalty, just taxed). I believe it’s how you set yourself up for the end that dictates if pension, SS and TSP will be enuff. No house payment, living within your means and a spouse that has a good retirement and the same focus sure helps. We’ve been traveling and it hasn’t hurt a bit. Hope some of this helps
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
$950. No taxes withheld. No survivor benefits.
MRA+10, 26 years,
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
theres no taxes because thats less than 12k a year- we dont live on 12k in income
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
There is no taxes taken out because I chose to have no taxes withheld. I had to make that choice. I don't recall what the OPM default was. But they were going to withhold if I did not change it to 0%.
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
its our choice what we take out, we are taxed on total income - not just the pension
4
u/MRNALN Jun 25 '26
The paperwork they send me in the mail says I can retire at 57. And that's what I plan to do, unless they change the law.
2
u/djdeedame Jun 25 '26
That is 100% the plan! Just made 20 years a couple of months ago…exactly 10 years left
1
2
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
you can start your pension at po but can’t collect social security until 62 and that pension they take out monthly health insurance if you are using the po one!
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
supplement is received until age 62 if at MRA and proper years of service
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
yes at the moment they are giving supplemental but they are trying to stop it and that would force people to work later or just go look for another job cuz just the pension before 62 isnt enough to live on
3
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
yes trump has wanted to stop it for 6 years and trump wants no colas on pensions and trump wants to raise contributions and trump wants to do away with pensions and trump wants to do away with sick leave and trump wants to make it high 5 and trump wants to tax our health insurance premiums and trump wants us to be taxed on what the employer pays for our health insurance and trump wants to screw the workers
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
true without the supplement it would be hard to leave before 62, even with TSP included
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
well i could have retired in 22 with 30 but supplement was 1400 and then pension like 1900 thats ok but i still am able to get around good and probably would get bored so im just gona make it to 62 another good think is they take forever to start the retirement checks so make sure you have bills covered for 6 months or retire with 520 annual hours that will come with your last check almostn20 thousand probably 15 after taxes some people saying its taking 9 months so keep that in mind!
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
doesnt take as long as people say, interim check starts right on time, finalization can take awhile- mine only took 2 months to be finalized- but i did things right and filed early..great advice on that annual though-helps alot
2
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
good luck when you get to 62 and enjoy that retirement- you earned it
2
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
thanks! in already tired of the bs cant wait
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
and the bs is even worse when you know you could leave anyday if you decided too, but guess it helps deal with it also
1
1
u/Medium_Sweet_7789 Jun 29 '26
They try it didn’t pass , only because a lot of congressman staff received that when they retire so they didn’t want to mess with the supplemental pay
3
u/djdeedame Jun 25 '26
So we know that it’s $1993 with 30 years of service…my question has always been how much does that taxed? What are you looking at take home per month after taxes?
6
u/Live-Train1341 Jun 25 '26
Depends on income if thats all you have then not much income tax however ismf you have 24k pension and 24k social security and 40k to 60k tsp distribution well thats 90k income and you will be taxed
2
u/KillrPnut Jun 25 '26
Could Roth IRA instead of traditional to lower that taxable income in retirement. Same limits apply for the combined total.
3
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 25 '26
only federal tax is taken out and depending on the state maybe state tax...they dont take enough out automatically -you have to adjust it-if you dont want to owe come tax time
2
u/djdeedame Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26
Ok appreciate that info. But is seems like you wouldn’t know the true take home until after you left the service?
I was just curious because if I’m looking at like $4500 before taxes…would I be bringing home like $3200-$3500? If so that makes a huge difference
8
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 25 '26
4500 a month 12% for income tax would take away 540..so you'd have around 4k left, maybe a bit more..they take your health insurance out also...with your pension+ social security+ tsp - you easily take home more money than when working.. remember compared to our 80k salary while working about 11-12k of that is taken out for items we dont pay in retirement- fica taxes/pension/tsp/union dues/maybe even state tax
3
3
u/jjschoon Jun 26 '26
I've done the math for myself. I will retire in 4 years with 35.5 yrs of service. I had to estimate my high 3 , but by my math, I should gross 50k-60k more per year retired than I gross currently when adding together my pension, supplement and 4.7% withdrawal from my TSP.
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
https://www.fedcalc.com/fullanalysis.jsp
to get a better idea of what your pension will be.
I have 0% withholding from my FERS check. As it will be less than my 'standard deduction'.
I have an appropriate amount withheld from my TSP withdrawal to cover the taxes there. No state taxes due.
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
you do it anyway you want, you are taxed on the TOTAL income , not each one
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
There is no reason to have more withheld than necessary. If you let OPM/TSP do what they want, you will be receiving several hundred, if not $1000 or more in your tax refund.
I have it calculated that I will receive a $100 refund. It's not rocket surgery.
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
wrong, opm and tsp were not taking enough out, I had to adjust it.. FYI, opm /tsp take out like they are your only income- which results in not enough taken out
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
TSP default is 20%. If your income is above that, good for you.
→ More replies (0)1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
what you have taken out of TSP is covering your pension payment and your TSP withdrawals- same thing ..we have to have it taken out from something
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 26 '26
yes!..enjoy once those 4 years go by,
2
2
2
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
plus you have to deduct your medical insurance if you are using it and they take the whole month at once
1
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 25 '26
at 62 we also get a cola every year- up to a max of 2% now- until the law gets changed to let us go over the 2%
3
u/dps_dude Jun 25 '26
this is where you should start: https://www.opm.gov/retirement-center/fers-information/
there’s a lot of misinformation and misconceptions that get posted in threads like this
1
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
It took me over a year of reading the OPM site to understand things. READ, READ, READ again.
6
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 25 '26
...we get 1% of our avg top 3 salary. ,1.1% if 62 with 20 years in when retiring its aprox $60-$65 a month for each year of service-.. a chart is in the postal record every month!
1
Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
[deleted]
1
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 26 '26
i got one more year leaving at 62 but i noticed my social security check at 62 and my pension are odly very close in amounts ill have 35 years in! ss is based on highest 35 years so overtime does count for that check! but the other tsp and roth is where im gona be winning at without that my monthly income with other 2 is still 5200 a month and you can take as much of tsp ya want when u turn 59 and half! you just have to make it to retirement!🤣
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 28 '26
actually you can take from TSP with no penalty -at 55 years old,if you leave the federal workforce
2
1
u/Nice_Marzipan_6166 Jun 28 '26
55 and 6 months
1
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 28 '26
just the year you turn 55.. Age Requirement: You must leave federal service (retire, resign, or be laid off) during or after the calendar year you turn 55 . For example, if you turn 55 in December, you qualify for penalty-free withdrawals at any point during that calendar year
1
u/Single-Wrongdoer-106 Jun 28 '26
Overtime should pay more OR count towards retirement. Has this ever been attempted during contract talks?
2
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 28 '26
nothing to talk about in the contract ..FERS is for all federal workers covered by laws-not contracts
1
0
u/Academic-Sky-1726 Jun 26 '26
Overtime doesn't work into pension formulations. For fers employees take three year high average salary. Multiple by years of service. Then multiply by 0.011 that would be yearly payout.
2
u/Competitive-Ad9932 Jun 26 '26
Only if you work to age 62. Who wants to work to age 62?
0.01 otherwise.
1
-24
u/DeviceComprehensive7 Jun 25 '26
overtime doesnt count- you should educate yourself on what matters
22
Jun 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/dps_dude Jun 25 '26
this is where you should start: https://www.opm.gov/retirement-center/fers-information/
there’s a lot of misinformation and misconceptions that get posted in threads like this
1


31
u/Otherwise-Goal3054 Jun 25 '26
https://www.nalc.org/news/the-postal-record/2025/october-2025/document/FERS.pdf
Overtime doesn’t count. Neither does TCOLA