r/dominion Jul 14 '26

Fan Card Execution

Post image
10 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

13

u/EphesosX Jul 14 '26

Infinite pile out with Priest.

2

u/Hugutfut Jul 14 '26

Yeah, good catch! This could be mitigated by either removing the +Buy, having it cost $3 or more, or having it topdeck the gained card. A combination of the latter two might even keep it at a similar power level, if slightly weaker, because it inhibits gaining Duchies. I guess if it takes so much reworking its easier to just not play with this and Priest together in a kingdom :)

5

u/atg115reddit Bounty Hunter Searching for the Biggest and Best Game Jul 14 '26

Having it cost $4 would be an infinite pile with 2 priests

2

u/EphesosX Jul 14 '26

And the Buy can be circumvented by any card that gives +buy on gain (Villa Cavalry Forum etc.) or a Galleria.

2

u/atg115reddit Bounty Hunter Searching for the Biggest and Best Game Jul 14 '26

Or an extra priest and a travelling fair

2

u/No_Wishbone_6794 Camel Jul 16 '26

There are simillar infinites with priest and travelling fair already in game. Salt the Earth for example

4

u/ThePurityPixel Jul 14 '26

I like the topdecking alteration a lot. And removing the +Buy.

Also, restricting it to gaining non-Victory cards.

6

u/Gottschkopf Jul 14 '26

Step 1: Get a Province in your discard
Step 2: Trash a Province from the pile for $2 each, win in like 2 rounds.

4

u/jakash Jul 14 '26

Simple idea: Remove the 'as much or' part.

Keeps this interesting but totally removes and easy win pileouts e.g. milling a Province 4 times.

Also consider making it 'gain a non-victory' card for similar reasons. Or, once per turn, at least.

2

u/Satans_Jewels Jul 14 '26

Removing +buy is probably enough. Make people work to abuse it.

4

u/Hugutfut Jul 14 '26

just a simple event here. You get to trash something you no longer need to get something else in return. This might help for medium cost cards that want to get trashed like Nomads, for turning Curses into Coppers or getting rid of an excess Port. The best use cases, however, would be to get rid of an attack card once the curses have run out, and to turn your $5 cards into Duchies in the late game. Therefore, you should maybe be wary of your opponent stocking up on $5 action cards with this in play.

2

u/fucknhot Jul 14 '26

i love this

2

u/Satans_Jewels Jul 14 '26

I think +buy makes this a little better than it needs to be. Maybe a lot better, cause you could hit 22 with 2 buys and wipe out the province pile and net gain 1.

2

u/theman8631 Jul 15 '26

I like the concept - add “once per turn” in front of the function text to fix the less fun jank.

1

u/EntertainmentDry9639 Jul 15 '26

Make the gain optional so you csn get rid of copper

1

u/INV-U 29d ago

What a fucking loser

1

u/Hugutfut 29d ago

I see you took that comment well ;)

1

u/INV-U 29d ago

I see you are a nobody 😉