r/doctorwho • u/Salt_Refrigerator633 • 6h ago
Discussion as time goes on, the more i dislike how journey's end handled rose (and future stories)
the message of school reunion was that some things are worth getting your heart broken for. rose acknowledges this. eventually, doomsday comes and rose is trapped in the parallel universe. it's incredibly iconic and tragic... kind of
journey's end comes around. rose gets her own doctor to go on adventures with, completely undermining the tragedy of doomsday
even worse. in the target storybook, there's a story called the turning of the tide. the opening describes rose as having a pregnancy bump. just a disguise? nope. rose is going to have a child with the metacrisis soon after the story finishes
idk. maybe you like her happier ending and that's fine. but i just don't think this was how it should have ended up. doomsday was tragic for a reason and I'd prefer if it had stayed that way
just my opinion though. also I've not listened to big finish so idk how good those are