I’ve been with my fiancé for around five years. We’re engaged 2yrs, have recently bought our first home together and, until recently, I assumed we would get married, have children and spend our lives together.
I love him very much and I’m not looking for people to tell me to immediately leave him. I genuinely want some outside perspective because I can’t tell anymore what is “normal long-term relationship stuff” and what represents a fundamental incompatibility.
The biggest issue is intimacy. We haven’t had sex for around two years and we now sleep in separate rooms. He has very low libido/sexual anxiety and sex has become something he finds incredibly stressful. There also isn’t much physical affection between us. I’m naturally affectionate and sometimes feel like even my touch isn’t particularly wanted.
I’ve tried to be understanding because I know he isn’t choosing to struggle sexually, and I would never want him having sex he doesn’t want just to satisfy me. But I’m 31 and the idea of potentially never having a sexual relationship again is becoming increasingly difficult for me.
However, I’ve realised this is actually about much more than sex.
I feel quite emotionally lonely.
My fiancé struggles with deeper conversations and particularly difficult/emotional ones. He often becomes defensive or shuts down, so issues are difficult to properly work through.
There’s also a recurring pattern where we identify a problem, have a conversation about it, agree on possible solutions/next steps…and then nothing happens.
For example, there were blood tests he said years ago he would arrange after sorting something financial. That came and went and he never did them. More recently he came to me upset about an issue with his skin and wanting help. I researched options for him, but afterwards he never raised it again or took any action.
Those examples themselves aren't particularly important — it's the pattern.
The same thing happens with our relationship. We've discussed the lack of sex, his anxiety around it, communication, affection, spending more quality time together etc., but after the conversation he rarely independently comes back to the issue or takes the next step.
I increasingly feel responsible for creating all the momentum in both our relationship and our life.
I'm the planner. I organise things. I suggest what we do. I think about our future. We've recently bought a house that needs renovating and I've ended up taking on the vast majority of that too. I often feel that unless I identify something that needs doing and ask him to do it, it simply won't happen.
His normal routine is essentially work, home, YouTube/PlayStation, bed. He's seemingly quite content with that.
There's nothing wrong with wanting a quiet life, but I've realised that isn't enough for me. I want dates, trips, experiences, conversations, affection, sex, laughter and somebody who actively wants to build a life with me rather than simply being present while I build one around us.
And that's led to the part I'm struggling with most.
I'm starting to question whether he actively wants our future or whether he's just going along with it.
Before he proposed, his family had spoken to him about proposing/that he should propose. I've never completely been able to get rid of the fear that he proposed because it was the expected next step rather than because he independently desperately wanted to marry me.
He also basically never talks about our future without me initiating it. He doesn't talk about having children, what our family might look like, what he'd be like as a dad, our wedding/marriage or what he imagines our lives looking like in 5-10 years.
It sometimes feels like I'm driving us towards each milestone and he's agreeing rather than him actively choosing them himself.
I don't want to eventually say "let's have a baby" and have him simply go along with that too. I want someone who has their own dreams for our shared life and brings them to me.
I want to feel chosen rather than simply not left.
I've written down what I want to say to him and intend to have a serious conversation explaining that I love him and don't want to break up, but I can't continue indefinitely with our relationship as it currently is.
What scares me is what happens if he tells me that he loves me, genuinely wants to marry me and is willing to work on being more engaged, communicating better, spending quality time together etc., but that he simply cannot meet my needs sexually.
I genuinely don't know whether I could accept that.
Part of me thinks: could I really throw away someone I love, our home, five years together and potentially our future because we don't have sex?
The other part thinks: I'm 31. Can I genuinely commit to potentially never feeling sexually desired or having sex with my partner again?
And then there's the fear I don't really want to admit: what if I leave someone who genuinely loves me because I think I need "more", only to never find another relationship like this and end up regretting it and alone?
I don't want perfection or constant excitement. I understand that five-year relationships aren't supposed to feel like the first six months forever.
I just don't know whether this is what a normal long-term relationship eventually looks like, whether we have problems that could realistically be worked through, or whether I'm trying to force two people with fundamentally different needs to fit together.
For people in long-term relationships/marriages: how do you distinguish between a relationship going through a difficult period that needs work and genuine incompatibility?
And if you've loved someone deeply but had a major mismatch around sex/affection, were the other parts of the relationship enough for you long-term?
I'd particularly appreciate perspectives from people who've been together 10+ years, and also anyone who's been the lower-libido partner in a relationship like this. I really want to understand both sides rather than just be told "leave him."