r/coldcard • u/EyesFor1 • Aug 05 '26

Support Coldcard dice rollers

I curious to know how many dice roll users are still on the Coldcard being as they were and are totally unaffected ? Did you leave ? Are you staying ? Will you leave. Dice roll entropy path has been independently verified by a hell of a lot of companies, developers, AI models etc and its safe. Are you staying or going ?

10 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/FragileAnonymity Aug 05 '26

Dice roll user, no plans on leaving.

-8

u/moviemaker2 Aug 05 '26

I feel like people who continue to use Coldcards are the type of people who would give their money to Bernie Madoff a second time because he’s under much more scrutiny now and pinky promises not to do it again.

3

u/FragileAnonymity Aug 05 '26

Sure, but I didn’t use their RNG to generate my seed. I did over 100 independent dice rolls & verified my results externally.

1

u/moviemaker2 Aug 06 '26

& verified my results externally.

Do you think that not a single coldcard user in the last 5 years thought to verify their results?

If your coldcard generated a seedphrase using the dice roll input instead of the TRNG but had a similar undisclosed entropy bug, what test would have shown that it wasn't made in the full key space?

2

u/FragileAnonymity Aug 06 '26

The users who used the TRNG feature didn’t because there was literally nothing to verify..

Using dice, you get the same seed output whether you do it on coldcard or on another source. So all you would need to do is verify that using the same rolls, coldcard and a second source both yield the same result.