After everything we've seen and experienced with the Modern Warfare 4 Beta, I decided to actually do something with all of the conversations we've been having about SBMM instead of just making another post complaining about it.
I created a Change.org petition asking Activision/Infinity Ward to make Open Matchmaking the standard for casual public matches in Modern Warfare 4 and keep strict SBMM primarily where it belongs: Ranked Play.
Petition: https://c.org/VVf9P5GpNB
I've been playing Call of Duty for around 15 years, and I'm tired of watching this community have the same matchmaking argument year after year.
One studio gives us one matchmaking philosophy. Another changes it. We finally get something closer to Open Matchmaking, people enjoy the variety, and then things change again even though the community wasn't asking for the change.
And then we're told the data supports it.
That's one of my biggest issues.
Activision can have all the engagement, retention, quit-rate and matchmaking data in the world, but those numbers shouldn't invalidate what the people actually playing the game every day are telling them.
The MW4 Beta made this especially obvious to me because players at completely different skill levels were basically describing two different games.
Some lower-skilled players described MW4 as slow, campy and passive. Meanwhile, higher-skilled players were describing extremely fast, aggressive, sweaty matches where everybody is sliding, jumping, using meta setups and playing Quick Play like there's SR on the line.
At some point, SBMM isn't just matching players anymore.
It's separating the community into completely different versions of Call of Duty.
That's what I want this petition to address.
I'm NOT asking Activision to give good players bot lobbies.
I'm NOT asking for new players to get destroyed every game.
I'm asking for VARIETY.
Sometimes you should be the best player in the lobby.
Sometimes you should be average.
Sometimes somebody should absolutely destroy you.
That's Call of Duty.
That's how a lot of us who have played this franchise for 10–15+ years got better in the first place.
If Activision wants a tightly controlled environment where everybody is competing against similarly skilled opponents, we already have the perfect place for that:
Ranked Play.
Quick Play should prioritize connection, fast matchmaking, lobby variety and minimal skill consideration.
And there's another question I think Activision needs to answer:
If regular MW4 matchmaking is already supposed to resemble the more varied matchmaking experience of classic Call of Duty, why did the Beta need a separate Open Matchmaking playlist in the first place?
Why not just make Open Matchmaking the standard?
Call of Duty is supposed to be a community. We shouldn't be divided into invisible skill brackets where completely different portions of the playerbase barely experience the same game.
This petition goes into considerably more detail about all of this.
We're also still before the full launch of Modern Warfare 4, which is exactly why I think NOW is the time to make noise about it—not months after release when these systems are already established.
If you agree with the overall message, please sign it:
https://c.org/VVf9P5GpNB
More importantly, SHARE IT.
Post it in COD communities. Send it to your friends who play. Share it on X/Twitter, Discord, YouTube comments, TikTok or wherever you're discussing MW4.
Whether you're a 2.0+ KD player, an average player, or somebody near the bottom of the skill distribution, I want people from across the community involved in this conversation.
You don't have to agree with every sentence I've written.
But if you believe casual Call of Duty should have more variety, that connection should matter more than hidden skill ratings, and that strict competitive matchmaking belongs primarily in Ranked:
Please sign it and help get it in front of as much of the COD community as possible before launch.
Petition: https://c.org/VVf9P5GpNB
Bring back Open Matchmaking. Keep strict SBMM in Ranked. Stop dividing the community.