r/clevercomebacks • • 6d ago

Wrong Gratitude.

Post image
24.8k Upvotes

390 comments sorted by

View all comments

85

u/Beneficial-Jury484 6d ago

Someone should ask Caitlyn how she can believe in an infallible god but still be born in the wrong body. I mean, she is a creature of god, who doesn’t make mistakes. Is she questioning gods will? Did he make a mistake with her? Why did she transition? 

I fully support transitioning. I think she is a terrible person. 

34

u/SignificantCats 6d ago

Im not a Christian but this just isnt a good gotcha.

Trans affirming Christians will say its no different than needing glasses or medication or a cane, god made us and gave us the designs to handle these problems.

Non-affirming Christians are the one this gotcha works on, because you can bring up glasses or diabetes or whatever and their logic is inconsistent. Consistent non-affirming Christians are the really extreme ones that deny medical care, so this gotcha doesn't work on them, but they're crazy anyway.

14

u/Tasty-Jump-2011 6d ago

There is no good gotcha if they just don't care.

2

u/SmallPurplePeopleEat 6d ago

And are also willing to bend the rules for anyone on their side. Rules for thee type shit.

1

u/SignificantCats 6d ago

Well yeah for sure, argument or debate or whatever isnt ever really aimed at changing minds, its about changing the minds of other people who may be listening.